5 ms·
Wow, this is eye-opening. What a scummy tactic. Do they also claim tax write-offs for your donations?
by echelon 4y ago
Wow, this is eye-opening. What a scummy tactic.
Do they also claim tax write-offs for your donations?
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoOf course
- mehlmao 4y agoI donate $5 at Publix. Publix's income (and tax responsibility) increases by $5. They donate my (and everybody else's) $5. Their income (and tax responsibility) decreases by $5 to the original level.
- whartung 4y agoWell, I hope so. They have to record the income, which is taxable. So if they're donating it to a charity, they should take the write off. It's an interesting situation, since the stores are not charities themselves. I don't know if you, the consumer, can write it off. I don't know if there's a some kind of "pass through" loop hole that lets the consumer write off the donation, while the store funnels it to the charity, but themselves do not get dinged for the taxes on the income.
- hackernewds 4y agoDoes it lower their effective tax? Where they claim the donation, so that I've effectively donated to them?
- neodymiumphish 4y agoNo, because if they bring in $10k in revenue from these donations, but then still donate $10k to the charity, their effective income isn't changed by the donation. Maybe they can stake a claim publicly to donating that much income, but that's all publicity (and shouldn't they stake some claim, since their efforts led to such an increase in funds donated to the chosen charity?). The issue in this case is that CVS committed to a donation to the charity, then had customers pay that money on their behalf, effectively.
- neodymiumphish 4y agoThere are two ways this could happen, either of them have the same effect for the company handling the donation. First, McDonald's takes the money and sets it aside, using their POS systems to segregate these funds from their traditional revenue. At the end of whatever time frame, they send the accumulated funds to the non-profit. The consumer can use these donations as a write-off by simply keeping their itemized receipt and showing the round-up. Second, McDonald's could collect the funds as revenue, then make the donation as themselves. This is most likely not legal, since the consumer can also count the revenue as charitable donations, so it wouldn't make sense to have the same funds sent for the same purpose but tallied as a donation from two entities. However, this money would be revenue, then a donation, so it would have an impact against their legitimate taxable revenue/profits. For example, let's say McDonald's earns $1b in revenue, including the consumers' donations of $10m and amount to a total profit of $100m. Their profits without the donations is $90m. By donating the $10m from their $100m in profits, their lowering their taxable profits to $90m, making for the same tax obligation as if they didn't take the money in as income. The only place for nefarious activity in all this would be the potential for earning interest from the donations in the time between receiving the funds and forwarding them to the charity. Curious how they would be able to justify those earnings, if they did something like that.
- jxramos 4y agoI wonder how these things even appear on the receipt; come to think of it I've never given to charity using these mechanisms I always give direct so I've never witnessed how such a transaction gets rendered on the receipt.
- butlerm 4y agoWhat you call a pass through "loop hole" is exactly what happens by default with ordinary business accounting. As a business you have other expenses that increase by the same amount as your other income. Net income is unaffected. Before special tax treatment comes into play, businesses in the United States are taxed on revenue minus expenses, i.e. their net income. Nothing about passing through charitable contributions for others affects their net income at all.
- aidenn0 4y agoI'm not an accountant, but I think tax write-offs are different for businesses. If you gave them $5 and they lit a 5 dollar bill on fire, they get a write-off because companies are taxed on profits, not revenue. Now whether or not sales-tax gets involved on the donation I have no clue; there are thousands of different sales-tax jurisdictions in the US, so I'm not going to even speculate.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> Do they also claim tax write-offs for your donations? Yes, but not in the "We pay less taxes because of this" way that people think. Pulling numbers out of the air here, but if they make $100 in sales with $80 in costs, they'll take an $80 deduction for their costs and pay taxes on the $20 profit. If they make $100 in sales, plus accept $30 in donations for a total of $130 in revenue, and have $80 in costs, they'll send the $30 to the charity, take a $30 deduction in their taxes for the donation, another $80 deduction for costs, and finally pay taxes on the $20 remaining profit. Obviously, it's far more complicated than that, and actual numbers will be wildly different, the point still remains that they do not get a tax advantage.
- syzarian 4y agoEdit: Misread what was intended.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoThat's basically the point I'm making.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- syzarian 4y agoWhen you write they deduct the $30 donation I thought you were meaning deduction on taxes. Your first paragraph is misleading. There is no tax write off since the money donated is not revenue and is not deducted in the tax sense. It’s just pass along money. The business can write off the expense of the accounting though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 4y ago> Do they also claim tax write-offs for your donations? Yes, but not in the "We pay less taxes because of this" way that people think. Businesses are not allowed to take charitable deductions for donations made using funds collected from customers for the stated purpose of donating funds to a charity (i.e., "round up for charity"). The money being donated is not the business' money to donate, ergo they are not the party making the donation and do not get the tax benefit of it. Technically, the customer gets the deduction, but for donations of a few bucks its not worth it for the business or the customer to bother with the donation receipt. Note that this does depend on the language of the solicitation. If they say "we'll donate" they can take the deduction, but they must also gross up their own revenue to include the "donated" funds, so they get no tax benefit.
- eljimmy 4y agoAFAIK they can't legally claim your donation as a tax write-off, at least in Canada.
- nrmitchi 4y agoIIRC they don't get a "tax write-off" in the traditional sense of lowering their previous tax liability. They have $X in extra revenue, but take a deduction for those $X, so it works out in the end. But the other tangiable benefits are: - Company makes big news about donating "$X million dollars to charity", which was really customers money - Company holds on to $X in money until it's actually donated (which may be in a lump sum at the end of the year). In the meantime, they're earning interest or otherwise using funds.