9 ms·
Cops can extract data from 10k different car models’ infotainment systems
- netsharc 4y agoHey ChatGPT, can you write a typical HN comment to this headline? "I'll never buy a modern car with all the surveillance tech, just something with no electronics that I can fix myself!".
- phpisthebest 4y agoWell we had a thread a few weeks ago and that was not a welcome comment, the poster that said they bought a older car with out all the tech was lambasted for their environmental impact
- dnadler 4y agoI mean, he did ask for a "typical" comment, not a popular comment!
- 1letterunixname 4y agoCareful what you wish for, GPT and the police are listening.
- JohnFen 4y agoI only buy older cars, mostly for this reason. It's too bad that we have to choose between two evils on this, but we do. I choose to use older cars and drive less.
- IgorPartola 4y agoIs that true? I feel like you can buy a cheap tin can like a Toyota Yaris that considers power windows to be a major selling point and an optional upgrade, yet has the drive train of a modern econobox.
- Marsymars 4y agoWell, kinda, temporarily, and at an inflated price, given that the Yaris is discontinued, and what used Toyotas are going for.
- FredPret 4y agoWhat about crash safety though - newer cars are much better
- SoftTalker 4y agoAn old Mercedes or Volvo is pretty safe.
- uoaei 4y agoVisibility makes crashes less likely, if you're comfortable moving your locus of control inward.
- JohnFen 4y agoThey are, yes, but the safety of older models is perfectly acceptable to me.
- encryptluks2 4y agoIf I recall, they were referring to an SUV that got maybe 12mpg. Anyhow, what we really need is a car company that produces generic cars and parts that are easily interchangeable and replaceable for like 20 years.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoThis exists all over the world. Just not here. Our regulations have killed simplicity in cars. Now we could adjust the regulations to allow more of this - like 'kei trucks' would be a big win. In fact, allowing small horsepower vehicles to skip safety requirements if they operate under 25mph is a great idea, and give a pathway for registration and insurance. instead of motorcycles which are licensed, registered and insured, i now see more electric bicycles, which actually look like motorcycles, cost as much as motorcycles, and just ride around willy nilly. Any small time manufactuer should be allowed to produce road legal vehicles for intracity use, and be allowed to skip most regulations that are onerous. Lighting, fine, brakes fine, but does it need a reverse camera or onstar or lane departure? no probably not.
- TylerE 4y agoReverse cameras are a safety feature, not a luxury. I also doubt any market for what you're describing exists beyond "15 year old Honda Civic/Toyota Camry"
- scohesc 4y agoIf I have to choose between a massive tech corporation being able to know exactly what I do with the car I've bought, as well as the cops begin able to retrieve the same data, and buying a 20+ year old "gas guzzler" that has manual, physical controls, non-subscription-required heated seats, an after-market backup camera... You bet your bottom dollar I'm going for the "gas guzzler" - I hate these massive corporations more than I love the earth because they're the ones trying to force me into their ecosystem I can't back out of. Too bad the barrier to entry for car manufacturing is so high due to the tech involved, the "back-door" deals, etc. etc. - I'm sure a cheaper company selling a well made equivalent of the GNU/CAR meme would be popular if marketed correctly.
- jollyllama 4y agoExactly. If they don't want us to buy the old cars, make good new cars, meaning, without all of the unnecessary and poorly implemented tech. The burden isn't on me to change and what's more, adding all the bad stuff is extra work, so they should just stop.
- adql 4y agoMargins on cars are pretty low, in single digit percentages, and only higher when you move to premium cars. You just cannot compete as "not huge" company with other big companies making cheap cars. They are making their money on service and replacement components, not on new economy car sales (well, pre-pandemic at least) So you're not getting "cheaper company" nor "well made" because making something well and cheap requires that scale in the first place. The issue is really that not that many come to dealership and want cheapest radio from the 90s in their new car. People do want at least android auto/carplay and that usually comes with whole rest of entertainment, and as we are in cheap economy car segment, well, the shit that cost few bucks in knobs also get moved to that entertainment.
- ok123456 4y agoA 20 year old Honda civic is hardly a gas guzzler. Under real driving conditions cars that are being sold new today have about the same emissions and fuel consumption as cars 20 years ago, with the exception of very large v8 engines and models like the The Suburban and the H2. You can only really start talking about old cars being generally 'gas guzzlers' if you go back to the malaise era in the 70s.
- sethammons 4y agoI had an environmental science professor who would not buy a new car to replace his beat up gas guzzler that was decades old. The production of a car produces about 40k gallons of hazardous waste, removing that water permanently from the water supply. https://www.automotiveworld.com/articles/water-water-everywhere-vehicle-manufacturing/ https://www.automotiveworld.com/articles/water-water-everywh...
- gjsman-1000 4y ago
- dontbenebby 4y ago>passwords isn’t there some law about trading stolen passwords? I’m a fan of easy to type passphrases designed to spark a riot if ever read in open court since this seems to be a common pivot from the “look the other way when the user types” model I followed when I worked a help desk. We were told when I moved on to Hci research it’s unethical to collect the passwords, there’s a whole cottage industry of academics analyzing leaked data sets since they aren’t allowed to… just ask. (I’m not Irb certified and not a professor, so I get to do whatever I want.)
- 14 4y agoInteresting. I am curious to hear an example of what such a password would look like that would cause a riot when read out loud in court.
- klausjensen 4y ago"Alexa, order anatomically correct inflatable sheep from amazon".
- dylan604 4y agoGreat, now I have to change the password on my luggage!
- dontbenebby 4y agoFor you? Two. >James Comey is watching me poop. >James Comey is watching me poop in 4K. (Context is everything, you probably don’t want me to explain the joke.)
- coreyp_1 4y ago> "designed to spark a riot" I'm intrigued. Example?
- iosjunkie 4y ago>Honda said it hadn’t seen any indication hackers had maliciously exploited the vulnerability. Forgive me if I don't feel reassured, given Honda's response to Rolling-PWN.
- mgarfias 4y agoTime to buy a ‘72 travelall. Can’t hack me if there’s nothing to hack. ETA: then swap in a modern engine and use megasquirt to run it instead of all this connected bullshit
- hef19898 4y agoAh, megasquirt! If it wasn't for budget, and my utter inability to work with, or get to work, anything electronic (PCs are plug and play and some drivers, that doesn't count) I would have it or something similar on my '82 Rover V8 by now. Things are what they are, so dual carbs it will be until my estate figures out a way to add EFI. Good luck "hacking" something that has all of three fuses and a 15 year old JVC radio...
- mgarfias 4y agoI feel good about the unhackability of my 2001 corvette. It don’t have any connected anything.
- adql 4y agoDoes opening and starting it with nothing but screwdriver counts as "hacking" ? If so it can lmao. > Ah, megasquirt! If it wasn't for budget, and my utter inability to work with, or get to work, anything electronic (PCs are plug and play and some drivers, that doesn't count) I would have it or something similar on my '82 Rover V8 by now. Damn I thought that's a cheap option but I've looked at assembled ones and is near the price of Ecumaster...
- hef19898 4y agoI always wanted to try to use a screw driver or hot wiring it, just for the fun of it. If I break something, well, me and electrics... So I don't have the courage! I once saw someone put a Bosch (?) EFI from a VW Golf GTI on a 3.5 Rover V8, should almost be cheap, if you onow what you do, so not for me. Either way, I can quite literally rebuild those dual Zenith carbs in the desert (don't ask...), if parts are there. So for overall reliability I take that over a cobled together EFI. At least for now, who knows what the future brings. Ah, and to answer your question, yes, I think a screw driver counts as a hack!
- pannSun 4y agoDo the car manufacturers themselves also need to abuse a vulnerability to access this data that normally only the car owner has access to? Or can we trust our benevolent corporate overlords to keep this data safe on our behalf, and not abuse it, so long as "hackers" don't get it?
- cronix 4y agoThey can probably just get it all from Jiffy Lube, car dealerships and places like the DMV, which plug into the computer to "check things."
- tedunangst 4y agoI had no idea there 10k different car models.
- bena 4y agoIt really depends on how "model" is being classified. You think of a Honda Civic as a "model". But Honda has the Civic Sedan, the Civic Sedan Si, the Civic Hatchback, and the Civic Type R. All-in-all, Honda has 13 different "models" listed on their US page. We can assume most other major manufacturers follow suit. Then some of them may be broken down even further into more ultimately meaningless categories. Yes, the Civic Type R STX Bayonetta Dragon Hyper Ultimate Vroom Vroom edition may be a different "model", but all I see is Civic with too many fucking qualifiers. And all of them will be using the same base infotainment package. Which isn't ultimately a big deal. You'd want some sort of consistency between your vehicles. Except when there's an issue like this. Then not one model, but every model has an issue.
- to11mtm 4y agoProbably also counting each model year, e.x. if all Civic LX trims from 2012-2022 can have this done, that probably counts as '10 models'.
- bena 4y agoHonestly hadn't even considered that factor. But yes, you're right, they do refer to it as the 2012 model, the 2013 model, etc. Each being distinct in the eyes of the manufacturer. So, from Honda, if their entire line is outfitted with the offending system for 10 years, that's 130 models just from Honda.
- to11mtm 4y agoIn a weird way, it -does- make sense from a capability standpoint, if a bit ridiculous of a marketing standpoint. Let's go full tin-hat and say I want to see where a car has been. By looking up the plate, I can get the registration. By getting the registration I can get Year/Make/Model/Trim. Now with that I can hit a dictionary of the 'best' data provider for that vehicle. A proper sales conversation would ask for some matrix of covered vehicles, and use that to compare to what they already have in portfolio, possibly account for volume request discounts, etc...
- burritas 4y agoI really wish we could buy a new car these days without some insane infotainment system. I don't even want a screen or backup cam. I know DOT requires a backup cam, but they cause more trouble than they're worth and are there largely to compensate for the beefier pylons they also require now (less likely to get crushed if you roll, but more likely to get in an accident from reduced visibility). I've owned or rented about four cars of different make and different software bases that would occasionally freeze up when you switch out of reverse into forward, but the cam would still be up, preventing you from accessing important car functions (and distracting the driver). I've had to look up how to reset infotainment systems on youtube because it just wouldn't turn on at all. There was also a report of an infotainment system which would glitch out if a radio broadcasted certain characters in their station or track info, causing it to stay stuck on that radio station, even across reboots (IIRC this was traced to an ancient js lib, I may be wrong though). How much help do you think the car manufacturer offered? It was likely asymptotic with 0. But even if infotainment systems didn't suck for all these reasons, I still wouldn't want one. They seriously just suck ass by their very nature. Just give me a vehicle.
- notyourwork 4y ago> I know DOT requires a backup cam, This is interesting and not something I was aware of. Since when does DOT require that?
- cronix 4y agohttps://abcnews.go.com/US/cars-us-now-required-backup-cameras/story?id=54854404 https://abcnews.go.com/US/cars-us-now-required-backup-camera...
- Kon-Peki 4y agoI don't agree that backup cameras are mandated (I may be missing some federal regulation, however). The regulations (that I've seen) provide a list rearward visibility tests that the vehicle must pass. There are no modern cars that can pass these tests without a backup camera, but I think that many sedans from the 1980s and maybe even the early 1990s could pass them without backup cameras.
- chasd00 4y agoFrom the article it seems the only remote hack was through a SiriusXM vulnerability. Everything else seems to involve a physical connection to the vehicle to pull the infotainment data which i'm assuming requires a court order.
- account-5 4y agoThat was my takeaway too.
- dogma1138 4y agoDoesn’t a search of a infotainment system count as in plain sight? E.G. if you consent or they have a valid cause to search your car doesn’t the infotainment system come under that too? Even if they can’t run full forensics might be able to just browse through the call log or recent trips.
- squarefoot 4y agoSo let me the one asking the inevitable question: short of buying a 1987 van with the environmental impact of a refinery, what are new or reasonably recent brand/models whose electronics can be hacked to the point every non essential system can be turned off, when not physically removed, without any hindrance for normal driving operations?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoIt really depends on your level of commitment to getting the infotainment out of the vehicle. Most cars will have the infotainment in a CAN or flexray network with a bunch of other stuff in the cockpit. Theoretically unless other systems are tightly integrating with the infotainment (using their GPS localization data for example) you could theoretical just snif the network through your OBD connector and find out what messages your infotainment sends (i.e. whatever messages dissapear when you power the infotainment off). Most of the time the Body Control Module (the master of ceremonies in the cockpit) is just checking that a particular range of message IDs are being sent to 'assume' that the infotainment is 'online'. So sending those messages on the OBD port as a man-in-the-middle of sorts would theoretically keep all the other systems happy. So I suppose it really depends on how far you are willing to go. Also I think it would be difficult to make the trim look any good after removing the central infotainment system.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoYou don't need a 1987 van, anything before ~2007 should qualify. For example, I own a 2006 Honda. I made the mistake of leaving the windows open several years ago before a massive downpour. As a result, virtually all of my onboard electrical systems no longer function (radio, interior dashboard lights, ect) but the actual function of the car (as far as driving is concerned) is unchanged. I shudder to think about what would happen to a "smart" car in a similar situation.
- neon_electro 4y agoMy hope is that as more "legit" EVs are scrapped due to insurance total loss decisions, their guts and parts will be heavily in demand to power EV conversions. I lost a 2018 Bolt EV this year after my insurance company decided it wasn't worth repairing. My car might not be the perfect candidate for this, but I know there will be parts worth scavenging off of it in the next life for the carcass. I sure hope to be able to perform one of these conversions myself in the future once the broader "swap infrastructure" and knowledge bases expand to better support individuals like myself (similar to how you can find a wealth of knowledge and aftermarket support for Honda K-series engine swaps into many cars beyond even Honda models).
- dawnerd 4y agoKinda laughed at this "gotcha" > Previous reports claimed that Tesla infotainment systems stored Wi-Fi and Spotify passwords. Like... how else is the car supposed to connect to wifi? And the new OS just has you sign into music services through a qr code.
- jacquesc 4y agoI'm trying to think of what useful evidence that law enforcement can get out of an infotainment system. Guilty of listening to too many Brittney Spears tracks?
- dogma1138 4y agoNavigation/location data, and also likely time stamped car activity data which you don’t get from the MCU. Call data and other data from devices tethered to it, and for connected infotainment systems also wifi and cellular data which can provide a secondary source of location data in case the location history has been purged. It wouldn’t surprise me if there are some more rich logs there including CANBUS data from other car systems on some of the newer models. Overall if you have a late model car especially towards the upper end of the spectrum I would assume the infotainment system has about as much information as a cellphone you carry because they are basically phones stuck to the console at this point.
- uoaei 4y agoI assume there's certain functionality similar to the casual surveillance tools from Allstate and other insurance companies that you plug into your OBD2 port. You know, the ones that log eg GPS location, velocity/acceleration/jerk of the vehicle or its controls, VIN and associated PII metadata, etc. I've heard tale of all sorts of data that are broadcast back to the manufacturers' servers from your car for later sale to data brokers for advertising, etc. information. Not exactly surprising to hear that that information is available if you connect to the car directly using LE tools.
- olyjohn 4y agoThe Lotus I had would datalog all kinds of data over time. It was very common for buyers to have someone do a data dump of the car's ECU to see how it was used / treated. The ECU was very much designed just to run the engine in this car (no infotainment, network upload, or any other integration), but kept some interesting long term data. That data can be very telling. It tells you percentage of time that the engine spent at each RPM, and percentage of time spent at certain speeds, percentage of time spent at various manifold pressures, maximum engine speeds at certain coolant temps, highest vehicle speeds attained, and number of full load standing starts. This info would not be useful to LE, because they don't keep timestamps on the data. But it is a big tell to the dealership how hard you have been driving your car.
- rabuse 4y agoI really hope some new manufacturer comes in to make cars "stupid" again.
- _chu1 4y agoChevy and Dodge still sell vans and trucks with basic radios (the latter of which I think is only in Mexico)
- gnicholas 4y agoSeeing what's happened with 'smart' TVs, I'm not holding my breath.
- zie 4y agoThe commercial vehicles market tend to still be "stupid". Of course this limits you to full size vans, big trucks, and things like that. I suspect "smarts" will infect these as well eventually, when it's just cheaper for the manufacturer to just include them in the build even when not asked for them.
- genocidicbunny 4y agoThere was a recent article about Toyota still making old-school Land Cruisers that have little to no electronics[0] I don't think they can pass emissions tests in Europe or US though, which would make them unusable, if not unimportable. 0: https://www.carscoops.com/2022/11/this-shop-in-gibraltar-modifies-classic-toyotas-for-the-u-n-and-other-aid-agencies/ https://www.carscoops.com/2022/11/this-shop-in-gibraltar-mod...
- yrgulation 4y agoI never imagined there are this many car models in existence.
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: Remotely unlock/start/locate any remotely connected Honda/Nissan [resolved] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33831127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33831127 - Dec 2022 (223 comments)