5 ms·
TikTok is transforming the music industry. Is that a good thing?
- garrettjoecox 4y agoTikTok is the worst thing to happen to anything it involves. Children, music, internet, advertisements, etc. Going to be very interesting to see what long term repercussions this attention span shortening craze will have on our society. I have friends who can’t even sit through a film anymore, let alone read a book or stay focused on one thing for more than a few minutes.
- kyleamazza 4y agoI've definitely noticed this both with myself and others younger than me who either grew up with short-form entertainment or heavily adopted it later on. Anecdotally speaking, the rapid context switching has a massive effect over time on a person's ability to concentrate. It's a lot harder to focus on anything without the physical and mental urge to fiddle with something and scroll through short videos. I haven't looked into whether or not there's significant literature on this though; definitely would be curious if this is indeed a worsening trend
- tennis_sort 4y agoI read "Dopamine Nation" recently and TikTok "ticks" so many negative boxes. Having lost hours to this ultimate time wasting app, there is no chance my kids are getting this on their phone. As the book hypothesizes, poor Dopamine regulation and the increasingly prescribed medication to treat this are becoming the norm. Particularly among working classes who have poorer earning potential and engaging work. Tiktok is literally mind numbing.
- klabb3 4y agoIndeed. The crazy thing is that we’ve come not just full circle, but full spiral. I used to tell people that the internet is better than zapping on TV, and other consumption media, precisely because you are in control – nothing will happen without you choosing to. All of the above is not just false today, but we have even more passive entertainment. TikTok has been promoted precisely because the only feature is zapping, for the vast majority of users.
- jaclaz 4y agoAs a side note, IMHO good ol' zapping (on TV) has been effectively killed a long time ago, when "modern" TV's came out. Once changing channel was instantaneous, since several years it has a delay/lag that takes most of the fun out of it.
- treme 4y agochinese version severely limits usage to teens for something like 30m/day
- taurath 4y agoThe real problem (in the US) is that for many many people on the app there’s absolutely nothing real to really look forward to. There’s a bit of a doom on a lot of the younger generations who are gonna be the ones to handle the effects of climate change, have insane costs of living, education, and healthcare. They have zero representation in any policymaking, as they enter their 20s to their 30s and now their 40s. Let them have a thing that makes their day a little brighter, or if you’re in an older generation encourage your peers to get out of the way so they can fix the damn problems. The worsening trend is what it takes to survive, let alone thrive in the US, and tiktok is something that people would pay less attention to if there were more agency to have better lives and not just slave it away for some holding company’s shareholders.
- kelnos 4y agoSo the solution to growing up with fewer opportunities and a difficult future ahead is to drown yourself in distractions so you don't dwell on how crappy things are? Man. Bleak.
- taurath 4y agoIt’s because whatever the next step is is far off in the distance, and very gatekept. People don’t have much opportunity, and frequently don’t have much in the way of community either. Yes it is bleak. I still believe it’s still possible to have a lot of agency but meeting basic needs is so difficult. Scraping by is how many people will live their entire lives. I moderate some online mental health communities and it’s basically assumed that nobody can access mental healthcare except for hospitalizations (which then bankrupt you after). It’s a huge privilege to have access to even be helped with the tools to make your life better.
- kleene_op 4y agoLike that sibling reply said, sounds more like a death spiral than anything else. The problem with collective suicide is that it impacts more than just the ones doing it.
- ketzo 4y agoGrammar pet peeve: this is the wrong way to use “let alone.” The “bigger” thing should be listed second, not first: “He wasn’t capable of lifting a mouse, let alone a 500-lb weight!” “She couldn’t see her hand in front of her face, let alone an iceberg on the horizon!” So in your example, you would say “I have friends who can’t stay focused for more than a few minutes, let alone watch a movie or read a book.”
- dayjaby 4y agoReading a book is bigger than watching a movie though?
- thfuran 4y agoBut staying focused for a few minutes isn't.
- akiselev 4y agoHe phrased it "Can't do X, let alone Y or Z" where Y > X > Z. Reading a book (Y) takes longer than watching a 90 minute movie (X) which takes longer than staying "focused on one thing for more than a few minutes" (Z). It should be Y > X and Z > X
- usui 4y agoThank you very much for this! I was reading the original comment and I was actually confused on the correct syntactical order of this phrase. For years I struggled in the back of my mind for how to parse this phrase, now I get it.
- iggldiggl 4y agoReading a book might typically take more time total than watching a movie, but books are often read in shorter increments, whereas a movie is usually watched straight-through in one sitting.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> The “bigger” thing should be listed second, not first Do you have a link for this grammatical rule?
- solumunus 4y agoTo be honest, I can't sit through many films anymore. I think it has more to do with the degradation of film quality and the rise of quality TV shows. I almost guarantee those same friends will watch entire seasons of long TV shows which are still pretty long form (1 hour episodes). I get what you're saying and it's concerning, but there are also counter examples. Podcasts are ever more popular, for example.
- telotortium 4y agohttp://archive.today/kKf6p http://archive.today/kKf6p
- edent 4y agoMP3 is transforming the music industry. Is that a good thing? AM Radio is transforming the music industry. Is that a good thing? Shellac records are transforming the music industry. Is that a good thing? The player piano is transforming the music industry. Is that a good thing? Perhaps TikTok's algorithm is as corrupt as Brian Epstein (allegedly) buying up early Beatles' singles to take them into the charts. So what?
- djaychela 4y ago>Perhaps TikTok's algorithm is as corrupt as Brian Epstein (allegedly) buying up early Beatles' singles to take them into the charts. So what? I'd imagine the scale of being able to do so globally, across multiple genres is significantly more impactful than the actions of one person, no matter how powerful they were.
- edent 4y agoThat's basically what Payola was. And it's how movie studios choose the soundtracks for their blockbusters - by using music from their own companies. Look, you can probably make anything a hit if you're prepared to invest enough money into it. And you can probably push fashion in a certain direction if you're inclined. But no amount of advertising could make people drink New Coke or Crystal Pepsi. No amount of prime time TV could make superstars out of American Idol winners.
- Semaphor 4y agoDisclaimer: This is written by a non-user purely about observations made about TikToks that were posted elsewhere. It is also not a statement of any kind of china issues with TikTok. What I see is amazing. Sea Shanties that were mainly for seamen and some German metalheads became popular again, suddenly everyone knew Wellerman, there were tons of covers, everything. Remixes, something that YouTube long ago forgot about (probably copyright laws, those tend to stifle creativity) are commonplace, people build on releases of others over and over again, creating a completely new and amazing endresult. What I see from TikTok, is a return to the creativity of years ago. edit: Because people thought of established artists when I mentioned remixes, I’ll clarify. I mean taking some person singing or playing an instrument, adding yourself playing guitar, putting it to the side of the original and releasing it. Then the next person adds a violin. And so on. Just non-commercial remix culture.
- poisonarena 4y ago>remixes, something that YouTube long ago forgot about you have to be joking.. Everytime I see a song I like I search for it, can often find all the remixes official / unofficial, extended mix, and instrumental (official or amateurs using cross filtering techniques.) Also Sea Shanties are on youtube as well, maybe moreso, and easier to find and save to a playlist.. I hate the new youtube UX decisions and limitations but it still blows tiktok completely out of the water(spotify too(spotify is for normies))
- Semaphor 4y ago> Also Sea Shanties are on youtube as well, maybe moreso, and easier to find and save to a playlist.. The new popularity of them started on TikTok. Of course it spreads afterwards, otherwise I wouldn’t even encounter them ;) And with remixes, I’ll edit my comment, I don’t mean remixes of some chart artist.
- mschuster91 4y ago> What I see from TikTok, is a return to the creativity of years ago. And since Tiktok is barely moderated, we also see a return of the "creative" bullshit. Tide Pods, filing down one's teeth, dancing on graves, licking random public stuff to catch COVID intentionally, the "Skull breaker" challenge... Tiktok is cancer, and additionally it's spyware of an enemy government. It should be banned.
- echelon 4y agoWait until they see what AI does to the music industry. - Anyone can license Taylor Swift to make any new song of their choice. Or perhaps Elvis and Whitney Houston in duet. - Firehose of interest-driven novelty music, generated on the fly. - Everyone can create music without training, instrumental talent, or vocal ability. It's coming fast [1]. [1] Source: I'm working on this.
- saurik 4y agoOooo!! I've been waiting with bated breath for this... but, mostly because (from my experience doing DMCA advocacy work and testifying on the other side of the table from them before the US Copyright Office) I'm pretty sure the RIAA will go nuclear with lawsuits against any such product and we'll finally see the epic showdown of AI vs. traditional copyright interests (which, to me, doesn't sound so good for you... but maybe you have a really great plan ;P).
- have_faith 4y agoHow will you manage the inevitable novelty crash? I’m assuming people will get bored of having 10,000 knock off Taylor Swift songs quicker than they would of her normal release cycle. In the real world there is tension and release, ebb and flow, etc. Without it I think novelty wears off very fast or burns you out.
- emptyfile 4y agoIs it any good? I'll believe it when I hear it.
- tgv 4y ago> Everyone can create music without training, instrumental talent, or vocal ability. No, they can't. It's calling a child that bangs on the piano a pianist. At least the child isn't ripping off anyone.
- janvdberg 4y agoAccording to 'Betteridge's law of headlines' the answer to this question would be a No. According to the comments here, I am not so sure.
- meindnoch 4y agoI can’t bear being in the same room when my fiancé’s niece watches tiktok due to the constant barrage of extremely annoying music snippets. The average time spent on a video is about a dozen seconds, so the creators try to put the most attention-grabbing, dopamine-inducing, annoying music on every video. Imagine the average brostep song from the 2010s, filtered through layers of autotune and pitch-shifting, condensed into 10 seconds. I can’t stand it. And this is from someone who’s perfectly capable of enjoying genres like breakcore or gabber…
- Joeboy 4y ago> this is from someone who’s perfectly capable of enjoying genres like breakcore or gabber… An old person, you mean?
- meindnoch 4y agoIf 31 is considered old, then yes.
- Joeboy 4y agoNot by me (I'm much older than that), but it's not particularly surprising if somebody who's 31 and enjoys music from 25 years ago isn't down with the kids.
- meindnoch 4y agoI just mentioned gabber and breakcore (“music from 25 years ago”) because those are genres that people typically consider a bit too much. I could have name-dropped the SVBKVLT label [1] for a contemporary example of electronic music I like, that might be too much for the average listener; but I don’t think it would have rang a bell for most people on HN… Anyway, I was never really “down with the kids” per se in terms of pop music - I found the genre too vapid for my taste. But it was at least some sort of music. These TikTok soundbytes (I would consider “music” a misnomer) on the other hand are downright sonic torture devices straight from some MKUltra mind-control cookbook. [1] https://svbkvlt.bandcamp.com/ https://svbkvlt.bandcamp.com/
- taubek 4y agoIs this like "Video killed the radio star" thing? YouTube has also made a great change. This seems to me like the next step.
- tgv 4y agoToday we stand at the edge of a great abyss. Tomorrow, we take a giant step forward. -- Leonid Kuchma
- WilTimSon 4y agoThe one thing I dislike about TikTok's influence, and I'm saying this as a very casual modern music listener, is that pop songs seem to be becoming extremely short sicne only a snippet is needed to blow up. Now I don't mind a short song or a long song, as long as it's good, but I'm still often left feeling like another chorus or bridge would really flesh out some of these hits. Like that 'Unholy' song by Sam Smith and Kim Petras [0], which I think is rather fun but it really feels cut short to me. [0] had to search this up, heh.
- tgv 4y agoAn important part of the art is music is development. You can't do that in a handful of bars. It just boils down to a blitzy intro, like jingles: catching attention, but no sustenance.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> pop songs seem to be becoming extremely short sicne only a snippet is needed to blow up That is approximately what happened during the punk-rock era. A bunch of musicians were tired of overly-complex neo-classical jerkoff that was popular in the age of Deep Purple, Pink Floyd and Jethro Tull and just decided to write three-chord songs with a catchy melody and get rid of all the complexity. Perhaps this is an introduction to some kind of neo-punk era? Probably not, though.
- plaguepilled 4y agoThis will be yet another drop in the ocean of anti TikTok sentiment but, what is the value proposition of TikTok? I ask because I am told it is meant to have a good algorithm, and yet I can't find ANYTHING on the platform that I like. The easy answer is that I'm not the target audience, but I want to know why.
- awestroke 4y agoYou are too old. Don't feel bad, though. Be thankful that you do not have to deal with Tiktok addiction.
- est 4y ago> yet I can't find ANYTHING on the platform that I like Have you tried to create something you like and post it? Tiktok algorithm generally favors new content.
- harryf 4y agoIt’s for people that find other forms of social media too slow and like a more panic inducing, crack-fueled experience
- paganel 4y ago> , what is the value proposition of TikTok? Coming home from work or from a stressful day out and relaxing and forgetting about everything else. I.e. what good TV used to be in the good old days, even the old web in some parts. People don't want to be reminded each and every minute of their waking hours that there are wars and pandemics going on or that we'll all going to die if we don't recycle the yogurt plastic containers the right way.
- modo_mario 4y agoWhen you search for stuff or find something vaguely interesting do you like, share or save it? The algortithm does require interaction to work but i found it picks up rather quickly. Sometimes a little bit too much so i adjust my behaviour accordingly to not give the impression i want to see it again if i think something is cool as a oneof.
- tannhaeuser 4y agoNo such thing as the music "industry".