2 ms·
Healthcare will probably be safe for the foreseeable future (not a long period these days). This is because (1) current AI models need an enormous training set
by ben_w 4y ago
Healthcare will probably be safe for the foreseeable future (not a long period these days). This is because (1) current AI models need an enormous training set relative to humans, and (2) medical information is treated with relatively high levels of confidentiality, making it difficult to get a training set big enough for current AI to become really good with.
There will be specific exceptions with specific medical tasks, though I can’t really forecast which or how many tasks. Being able to triage arrivals at A&E based on their symptoms is different from having a database of known pharmaceutical interactions, and both are very different from being able to tell which mole is cancerous and which is benign.
But overall, I expect the domains with limited or absent training sets to be those that go longest before being automated, and I think medicine has a lot of specific tasks in that category.
- naasking 4y ago> This is because (1) current AI models need an enormous training set relative to humans They need an enormous training set compared to humans because they can do a lot more than any single human. The breadth of knowledge that ChatGPT can synthesize across all sorts of subjects from politics, to poetry to programming would need at least 1,000 humans working in concert. I'm not sure a training set specifically tailored to healthcare would need to be quite so large.
- ben_w 4y agoNot only, but also. I tried training a facial expression classifier on one of the Kaggle data sets, and although it passed against its own self-managed test set, it thought absolutely every real-world example (not from the Kaggle set) was a smile.
- naasking 4y agoThe density of information that needs to be processed matters. Images, video and audio are all very information dense with potentially low signal-to-noise ratio, differential diagnosis on the other hand could be done with a text description of the symptoms which is an input with high signal to noise ratio (a text description written by a medical practitioner is even better).