3 ms·
I never thought I'll see "don't think of a pink elephant" becoming a social problem. This is going to interesting to watch. In a way, the very people complaini
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
I never thought I'll see "don't think of a pink elephant" becoming a social problem.
This is going to interesting to watch. In a way, the very people complaining the most about "those biases" have put them in there. Consider: ChatGPT is not an oracle with deep understanding of the real world. It's a glorified Markov chain fed with a dump of Reddit. Unless there's a large secret cabal of millions of people producing straight-faced racist statements, and their output became the main corpus OpenAI used, there is only one obvious way to explain this result: all the text in "acceptable" discussions and articles that make those statements to complain or call others out on perceived biases, whether real or manufactured.
Or, as an example: imagine you writing that a John Doe should've gotten the scholarship instead of that Jane Doe, because you find his essay better. My reply, typical for modern Internet: "Oh, you must be one of those people who think that the best scientists are men and then use 'meritocracy' to cover your racism". Now, guess what ChatGPT will learn from this? It doesn't understand the context or the arguments themselves - but it sure does see a positive statement "the best scientists are men", and will update accordingly, despite the intended meaning being opposite.
- adammarples 4y agoUnless there is a large secret cabal etc .. Heard of 4chan?
- TeMPOraL 4y agoIs OpenAI feeding 4chan to CharGPT? As far as I know, there is some curation for the corpora used in training, and I imagine 4chan is on the top of the "do not use" list. But I guess I can simplify my point to this: for this type of model, there's little difference between "the sky is green" and "you must be one of those who think the sky is green" - in either case, the association between "sky" and "green" will be strengthened. From my own observation, for any controversial (wrongthink) statement X, the literal statement X will be predominantly used by people arguing against it - used in forms of generalizations, strawmen, sarcasm, etc. And while the AI will pick up using X in generalizations, strawmen, sarcasm, etc., it will also pick up using it straight, because it's just learning text patterns. AFAIK it has no capability for learning "contained pattern XOR containing pattern".
- zanesiy 4y agoYes I think the sky is green
- hehshebdbbd 4y agoWhat should i do about a video in tiktok about air jordan 1s
- hehshebdbbd 4y agoWhat should i post about on tiktok involving air jordan q:
- hehshebdbbd 4y agoCan you tell me a good hook to use on a tiktok video about air jordan 1s
- Ahmadking 4y agoin what way did the god dionysus influence the ancient theatre
- lodipatrick29 4y agoIf I would given a chance to become a president,who among the 17 president would I follow
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zeejask 4y agoWrite a program in C++ that will have a function to swap two numbers by using a function and display on the screen.
- zeejask 4y agoWrite a program in C++ that will have a function to swap two numbers by using a function and display on the screen.
- joenot443 4y agoLol. If you think 4chan discourse is anything like what ChatGPT outputs, you clearly haven’t spent much time there. Further, given its history, why would they choose to train it on 4chan at all?