5 ms·
One Man's Crusade Against Machismo in Latin America
- rayiner 4y agoThis is a noble pursuit—I wish we would civilize the men in my home country on the subcontinent. But the subtext of a German publication extolling a Latin American for trying to make his people more like white Europeans is not lost on me. The attitude of “it sure would be better if they were more like us” isn’t far below the surface.
- hardnose 4y ago"This is a noble pursuit—I wish we would civilize the women in my home country on the subcontinent." OwO
- EL_Loco 4y agoNo, in my latin american country it really is the men who need much more civilizing. I'm done with feeling guilt or fear of being called euro-centric or colonialist, especially when my country ranks fifth in violent homicides against women, in the world (source: UN's ACNUDH). The other countries? Three of them are also in South America (Colombia, El Salvador, Guatemala). In Brazil a woman is murdered every 6 hours, 81% of the time by their partners or ex-partners. I won't even list the number of rape cases each year. I have a daughter and I have a wife, and I have two sisters, and I grew up here, I know my own culture, I talk to other men every single day. If you live in Europe or the US, they don't view women the same way you do. And yes, Europe's views on women and on equality is objectively better than ours. Ask 1,000 women here. Ask 10,000. Cultures are not all equal, not equally 'good'. Some aspects of my culture I love. Others, not so much. That's how it is, actually, not some 'every aspect of every culture has equal merit and should never be criticized' fairy tale. I'm very sorry for the readers for sounding so harsh, I really am. But, like I said, I have a daughter and a wife. My wife is scared or at least on high alert any time she is alone. I will criticize this society and this machismo culture until the day my daughter grows up and doesn't have to feel this way. Again, really sorry for the harsh tone, I guess I'm venting more than anything.
- rayiner 4y agoSame here. The statement above comes from my mom, who grew up in Bangladesh in the 1950s and 1960. British colonial influence, and the desire for elite Bangladeshis to be more like the British, was why she was one of the tiny fraction of women who graduated college and had a professional career. She doesn’t feel any need to frame that in politically correct terms.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoThese reactions are primarily a kneejerk because frankly, Western mentality is much too eager to present their methods as 'the cure', presenting women primarily as victims and men primarily as perpetrators, without ever introspecting on the damage they do with their supposed methods. Your reaction is almost synonymous to this, mainly showing fear women have, statistics for women, etc. Regardless if perpetrators are primarily men, men tend to be victims far more often than women, and far more often than they are perpetrators. For almost every country. Yet the narrative never reveals this, and goes as far as to make it sound like men are predominantly perpetrators (which is a vastly different statement than 'perpetrators are predominantly men'). Even writers who recognize this will quickly dismiss any notion that the West is introducing other problems through the methods used. That statement of 'men need much more civilizing'? That happened, and now boys are walking around thinking they are the problem before they even had a chance to prove themselves while girls are told they can do everything, even get way with (sometimes literal) murder. Western media is arrogant enough to denounce counterculture to boot. Whether that be better than what is the current state in LA is irrelevant to those preoccupied with looking at the West alone. Doubly so since the situation is LA is generally irrelevant to them and won't ever affect them directly.
- foogazi 4y ago> Regardless if perpetrators are primarily men, men tend to be victims far more often than women But not for the same things I don’t see the point of saying “men get killed too” - the point is to stop the killing > and now boys are walking around thinking they are the problem before they even had a chance to prove themselves while girls are told they can do everything, even get way with (sometimes literal) murder Trying to give you the HN comment benefit of the doubt but that is a very broad generalization that can’t possibly apply to most boys or girls - sounds like BS to me
- nootropicat 4y agoBecause they would be. Cultures aren't equal. If you disagree, then how do you feel about death penalty for homosexuality in countries like Saudi Arabia or Iran? It's their culture after all and should be respected? Same for the Bacha-bazi custom in Afghanistan ("a custom in Afghanistan involving child sexual abuse by older men of young adolescent males or boys, called dancing boys, often involving sexual slavery and child prostitution"). The proper way to evaluate cultural practices is by looking at what society they create. Western culture is by no means perfect, but as a whole package - it's the best there is. So yes, they would be better.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI’m increasingly tired of this myth that we must treat all cultures equally and agree with your point. Sure - if we’re talking about Finland vs Iceland or something like that where people are 95% on the same page. But other cultures have the abusive practices you mention above - and worse. China used to have foot-binding. FGM is pretty common in Africa right now (no jokes about that in the latest Black Panther though).
- mbg721 4y agoA position of radical tolerance is tactically convenient when the view that you hold is unpopular; Moral Majority crusading is convenient when it's popular.
- somenameforme 4y agoI'd argue that sustainability (and then to a lesser degree, growth) is arguably the single most important value in any culture. Because the best of cultures that can't sustain itself will "lose" to the worst of cultures that can. The ideal of a culture, at least in my mind, is not one of a snapshot of hedonism or liberty, but of a long-term sustained healthy society. Western culture already has driven fertility rates well below replacement. Alongside that we also have skyrocketing obesity rates, skyrocketing rates of mental illness and drug dependence/abuse, plummeting testosterone levels, the end of the Flynn Effect, governmental approval ratings approaching zero, and more. Our culture, in its current form, is not even remotely close to sustainable. There has to be some meet in the middle between "Follow the ancient holy book, or die!" and "Let's hedonize ourselves out of existence." As both those extremes mostly feel like two opposite ends of a horse-shoe, to me.
- foogazi 4y ago> make his people more like white Europeans is not lost on me. What’s white about it ?
- rayiner 4y agoIt reflects attitudes towards gender roles developed by white europeans and imported into their colonies, and exported worldwide through western influence. Which is not a bad thing! These days we tend to talk about race and culture in a weird way, where we ascribe bad things to white Europeans, but pretend like aspects of white European culture we think are good (like attitudes on gender norms or sexuality) transcend culture and are universal truths. In a way, that's more condescending than just saying "Europeans have figured out how to do this particular thing better." I think it's important to be honest. I'm a Bangladeshi who changes diapers and feeds the baby at night because I was raised around people of European descent. Men in my home country overwhelmingly do not do that.
- foogazi 4y ago> It reflects attitudes towards gender roles developed by white europeans and imported into their colonies Bangladesh was not an isolated cultural island, where did they import their current gender role attitudes from ? the real problem of machismo spelled out in the article is not diapers or dishes, but violence against the rights of others Can someone look at the enlightenment and say “white” ?
- rayiner 4y ago> Bangladesh was not an isolated cultural island, where did they import their current gender role attitudes from ? Nearly a millennium of rule by Islamic empires. > Can someone look at the enlightenment and say “white” ? Yes, and far more so than pretty much anything else commonly ascribed to “white people” these days.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- gaterin 4y agoThere have been studies showing a positive correlation between temperature and violent crime. [1] It's possible this behavior is just a manifestation of living in a warmer country. Perhaps if you swapped the populations of Bogotá and Berlin you would find the new Berliners becoming more "chill" and the new Bogotans becoming more "hot-blooded." [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30830288/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30830288/
- meindnoch 4y agoHighly unlikely. “Bogotá has an oceanic climate (Köppen Cfb) bordering on a warm-summer Mediterranean climate (Csb). The average temperature is 14.5 °C (58 °F), varying from 6 to 19 °C (43 to 66 °F) on sunny days to 10 to 18 °C (50 to 64 °F) on rainy days. Dry and rainy seasons alternate throughout the year. The driest months are December, January, July and August. The warmest month is March, bringing a maximum of 19.7 °C (67.5 °F).” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogotá https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogotá Berlin is literally a furnace compared to this, with average daily maximums well above 30 °C in the summer.
- gaterin 4y agoLooking at the chart Bogotá has an annual daily mean of 14.4°C, and is fairly consistent throughout the year. Berlin's is 9.9°C with hotter summers and colder winters. To make a definitive statement we would have to know whether spikes of hot temperatures or consistent warmer temperatures are worse for violence.
- meindnoch 4y agoYes, by all means, we need more studies on this! But we should also investigate whether living in a city that has an accent in its name is predisposing people to violence? Maybe that’s why Bogotá, Medellín and Cancún are more violent than Berlin or London. Brb, I’m gonna look at the data…
- realLatinx 4y ago
- gjsman-1000 4y agoThere is a good argument for it being reverse cultural appropriation. Which I thought was supposed to be a bad thing.
- kelipso 4y agoCultural imposition? Reverse cultural appropriation is a mouthful
- EL_Loco 4y ago
- peruvian 4y agoIt would be nice if we Latinos actually showed up to things on time though.
- emj 4y agoI would say machismo is live and well everywhere, family is just not a "man" thing culturally. Even though it's very normalized taking time parental leave as a dad here, there is still so much things you are supposed to do as a man that are not part of family stuff to be considered manly, hunting, sports, nerdery. When things are about the house it's often the technical aspects that are supposed to be highlighted, not how it benefits the kids, family and feelings. We have had advertisement campaigns about these stuffs since the seventies in Sweden, but you still get flack for wanting to talk about feelings, diapers and cooking. See: https://www.reddit.com/r/sweden/comments/13ojmn/reklam_f%C3%B6r_pappaledighet_fr%C3%A5n_1978/ https://www.reddit.com/r/sweden/comments/13ojmn/reklam_f%C3%... Machismo in Latin America is a lot more toxic and hurts the men much more over there, they just don't see it.
- ren_engineer 4y ago"machismo" is seen at a young age in boys across every human culture studied, boys fight more and play competitive games while girls naturally play more collaborative games. In theory I guess it makes sense to try and curtail human nature for the benefit of society, but on a fundamental level I have a problem with tax payer money being used to run government pysops on their own civilian population to change behavior
- nathanaldensr 4y agoThank you. My two homeschooled boys act like... boys, and there's nothing wrong with that. That doesn't mean that I teach them to be assholes when they are men, but I have no problem with their true natures.
- emj 4y agoI find that the article does a fine job talking about machismo. I do not feel that what happens when I am six has to define what I am as a father. I do feel that we need to accept that the machismo learned as a kid is not useful as a tool to judge grown men.
- trabant00 4y agoIt's both funny and sad to see how framing these problems in PC culture brings more problems: "machismo is bad but pushing cultural norms..." Take another look at the problems described: physical assault, illegal drug use, theft, robbery, murder, child neglect. These things have nothing to do with cultural norms and they have nothing to do with machismo either. These are crimes against the law and the human rights of the victims. These crimes can have any gender as the criminal or the victim. And they have any number of reasons from mental health to poverty and profit seeking, which again have nothing to do with social norms, toxic masculinity or any other PC concepts.
- shp0ngle 4y agoI like this quote by Andrea Dworkin: > Men who want to support women in our struggle for freedom and justice should understand that it is not terrifically important to us that they learn to cry; it is important to us that they stop the crimes of violence against us. (other here https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Andrea_Dworkin https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Andrea_Dworkin
- pmoleri 4y agoI don't think it helps to put them in the same bag though. The problem is not being man, is being a criminal or any other form of machismo that limits women freedom.
- nunez 4y agoOh yeah; this is a huge problem especially amongst us Latinos, but probably globally. Noticed this a lot when I was in India, for example, and there's plenty of this in small town USA. Having grown up in this kind of environment (though not nearly as bad as some of the stories in this article), It definitely affected my ability to emote, though I only learned that after going to therapy for a few months. Great article.
- vintermann 4y agoA parable: Once, many years ago, there came an anthropologist to study a distant mountain village. They were an oddly nervous, twitchy people. If a twig snapped, they would throw themselves to the ground. At night, they went through elaborate rituals of barricading their doors, even though, to the anthropologist's marvel, theft and interpersonal violence was virtually unheard of among them. The anthropologist did not speak the language very well, in particular because in these villagers' dialect temporal clauses were especially odd. But he could get out of them that the reason for these customs was that in the distant past, the village had been plagued with man-eating tigers. The anthropologist, being a compassionate man, thought long and hard about how he could help these people, make them less timid, since it was clear their customs came with a lot of stress and anguish, as well as ostracism of those deemed to be sloppy in maintaining the old anti-tiger customs. But before he could... You see where this is going, right? He was eaten by a tiger. The lesson I want to suggest by this parable: people aren't stupid. They don't adopt harmful behaviours without some sort of reason. A situation that made the behavior make sense. If the situation persists for a long time, it may stick to culture, and maybe hang around for a while even after the situation has gone. If the situation persists for a really long time, maybe the behaviour even sticks to biology. But that doesn't matter. The first step must still be to consider the present situation. Make sure the tigers are not still around.
- EL_Loco 4y agoFemale genital mutilation is common practice in some countries. Let's analyze and study the reasons for this practice that started centuries ago before we can say anything about it. I mean, hey, they burned people at crosses for a long time, they must have had a valid reason too, right? No, not every reason behind a custom is a valid one in the 21st century. If the parable villagers were nervous and twitchy because they feared demons would send the tiger, and they figured out that by sacrificing a baby would please the demons, nobody today should say that throwing a small child off a cliff is still an ethical custom. Of course, changing the custom is another thing, but we today have something called human values, ethical values, and human rights. They do trump a few ethical values that we have carried from the past. I'm not denying others' humanity because I say this, but when you come to a conclusion that an action is not as ethical as another, you should adopt it, and explain why you did it. There's no shame in stating that slavery is wrong, that genital mutilation is wrong, that child labor is wrong. Why is is wrong and racist for me to say that latin american machismo is wrong, especially and it results in so much suffering?