3 ms·
What do you mean by complicit? I was on a team in a federal agency which did large research grants to universities. We knew the overhead rates of the universiti
by adastra22 4y ago
What do you mean by complicit? I was on a team in a federal agency which did large research grants to universities. We knew the overhead rates of the universities we contracted with and factored that into our grant allocations. If the team needed $1m to do the research but the university takes half, we allocated them $2m. It was just the cost of doing business.
- lmm 4y ago> We knew the overhead rates of the universities we contracted with and factored that into our grant allocations. I read this and thought you meant you preferentially allocated grants to universities with lower overhead rates, and was hopeful for a moment, but then: > If the team needed $1m to do the research but the university takes half, we allocated them $2m. It was just the cost of doing business. Right, that's exactly what being complicit is! You're the problem!
- adastra22 4y agoWe did try to be cost conscious. Often there were multiple ways of allocating funds, especially supplemental funds for specific events. The typical overhead was 50%, but if we were coving the cost of a conference then often we could use a different grant mechanism which had a lower overhead, like 30%. Our staff secretary was really good at knowing all the tricks to lower overhead. I don't know what you expect us to do though? We are required by law to make these grants to universities. It's an actual line in the federal budget. The awards are competitively selected, and overhead cost has to be disclosed and is a factor in consideration. But it's a choice between bad, and worse. No organizations have good overhead rates, although the non-profit orgs were generally better than the universities. I agree there should be reform here, but talk to the GAO or your congressional rep. The worst was our own contractor overhead. My boss was a civil servant, but everyone else on the team was an employee of Lockheed Martin or one of its subcontractors. If we had to go through the Lockheed contract for anything (which sometimes we were forced to do), they'd skim another 15%. For doing nothing except cutting a check. That ought to be illegal IMHO, and we avoided it whenever we could.
- i_am_proteus 4y agoExactly your agency's behavior. If federal grant-writing agencies put a ceiling on overhead (at a high level, such as the level of the entire agency), I have no doubt that universities would start submitting proposals that included less overhead. (I do not intend to indict you personally; as you have said, individuals at your level were executing the mandate of the agency as directed and did not have power to effect change.)
- adastra22 4y agoPlease write your congresscritter and advocate for that!