4 ms·
There's a question I often ask people, and they seem very uncomfortable with it: > What do you do when 10% of your country's population is unemployable? I usu
by godelski 4y ago
There's a question I often ask people, and they seem very uncomfortable with it:
> What do you do when 10% of your country's population is unemployable?
I usually frame this in the context of automation to avoid the "new jobs will appear" argument (which is poor regardless because it is avoiding the transitionary period that you allude to, but I digress). 10% is depression level unemployment. But the real question here is "How do we transition into a post scarcity society?" (10% is arbitrary, and we'd expect it to rise) I think a lot of people have a lot of answers but do not think deeply about this problem. There's a decent chance that this kind of event happens within our lifetimes. Handling properly would probably mean we've already needed to have started down this path. If handled poorly revolutionary bloodshed isn't unlikely. Post scarcity would be a big boon for humankind, but the process of getting there is potentially a great filter in of itself.
Personally, I don't think our modern concepts of things like Socialism, Capitalism, UBI, or other similar systems can accurately capture the nuance needed to make this transition while maximizing human benefits/quality of life. We are talking about a complete shift in our organizational structure that no one has ever seen before, so I don't think we should accept simple answers. But I do think this is a question that needs to become more commonplace and is not as absurd as when I proposed it a decade ago.
We coders are not in the same spot as the Luddites, most of the world is.
- mgrthrow 4y agoI mean, most socialism (but especially Anarcho socialism as proposed by Kropotkin) starts with a foundation of people's right to life. We produce enough to give everyone in the US a comfortable existence. Almost twice as much food is produced as we need, for every homeless person there are 30 vacant houses, people gladly share their productive time with others (even highly skilled labor, like engineering time in open source. There are many, many socialist and anarchist thinkers who have written extensively on this topic.
- godelski 4y agoDo you have any reference that specifically discusses the transitionary period into post scarcity? I'm extremely disinterested in violent revolutions and tearing something down and putting it back up with a theoretical system. I want to see a system that still pushes us quickly towards post scarcity, and that's something I haven't seen that isn't also extremely vulnerable to authoritarian takeovers.