5 ms·
I've made this kind of post many times, so apologies if you've seen it before. My question to you as an academic is this: everyone I talk to in your discipline
by anigbrowl 4y ago
I've made this kind of post many times, so apologies if you've seen it before.
My question to you as an academic is this: everyone I talk to in your disciplines loathes university administrators and the politicians they effectively answer to, so why don't more academics cooperate across disciplines to topple the administrators? You're among the smartest people in society, you're in a cluster with expertise on everything from legal analysis to military history to economic analysis to system biology, and you have a relatively straightforward collective action action problem whose contours are pretty independent of geography and academic field.
Organize. You have an absolute embarrassment of intellectual and political resources at your disposal but you insist on playing by the very rules that are designed to limit your professional autonomy and keep you in your place. Doing everything by the book is clearly not working out for your profession, and if you keep doing what you've always done you'll keep getting what you've always gotten, ie less and less.
Find the people in your department who are most pissed off and select a small number that you trust. Network with people in other departments and encourage them to do the same. Develop an off-campus social life where you study the administrative organs of your university and analyze their composition, function, strengths, and vulnerabilities. Then start messing with the vulnerabilities to dislocate the control functionality of the administrative bodies. Start small, conduct experiments to deepen your understanding and get them to move this way or that. Then get them to misdirect their attention and resources to a dummy issue of your choosing and leverage their distraction to get something you actually need.
You're describing how administrative decisions basically have you subsidizing the university so people in your department can do their jobs effectively. This is such a common scenario that they definitely know what they're doing. It's OK for you to put stumbling blocks in their path.
- fknorangesite 4y ago> You're among the smartest people in society Being an expert in one specific field does not necessarily mean that you are also an expert in labor activism.
- Teever 4y agoUneducated blue collar workers around the world are able to organize and resist their overlords I'm sure that a motivated group of academics could muster up the resources to learn how to solve the problem they find themselves in. The fact that they could but don't seems to indicate to me that academics as a whole don't consider the situation as precarious as we think.
- maegul 4y agoThank you for asking this. I stated something to the same effect here too and think the same way as you. From what I have seen, the answer is that academics are more or less like teachers’ pets that kept going all the way into tenure. Their whole professional being is directed at pleasing their peers at large or their superiors. They’ve been broken into a relatively harsh hierarchical way of relating to their profession. All of their intelligence has been well domesticated and easily controlled for a while now. And it’s not like they’re starving. They’re doing well, but not too well, and scarcely have any incentive to rock the boat while they’re family rely on them and become increasingly reliant on the academic career with their age making it harder and harder to fathom surviving in the real world. Just think about the amount of time and energy they have to spend on grants to get permission to do their job through sales pitches and papers to promote themselves. They’re like an influencer that has to re-apply for their job every three years, with the real risk of falling out of fashion every time all the while acquiring few real world skills, which looms hauntingly should the fate, that’s inevitable for most, of being cast out into it befall them.
- TapWaterBandit 4y agoYep. Academics like Jordan Peterson who raise a middle finger to the world are outliers, not the norm. And his success isn't really to do with ground-level institution building but leveraging social media to spread a message (he is more like a preacher than an academic in most ways).
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> They’re like an influencer that has to re-apply for their job every three years, with the real risk of falling out of fashion every time I don't really understand the message of this comparison. An influencer must do this every day. Are you saying professors have really cushy jobs? That's a common message, but it doesn't seem to fit the rest of your comment.
- maegul 4y agoWell it may be a poor metaphor! The idea was that an influencer doesn't (AFAIK) have to really apply for their job. They have a profile and platform and are their own brand (again, AFAIK), and apart from whatever advertising contracts they have, I imagine they're not beholden to any one employer. Their work, seems to me to be in keeping up their profile with constant activity and promotion. As an academic who does research that requires funding, you need grants. These grants are often referred to as the lottery because it's not always clear why some get accepted and others don't. If an academic doesn't get a grant one year, especially for two years in a row, they'll fall behind in their ability to do research and publish and risk being kicked out of the industry. Sure, an academic could try to move country for a new funding agency, but that's getting prohibitively disruptive and unlikely. This is the bit that I don't think influencers have to go through. All of this, if you want the best people doing research, sounds good, right. Except, remember the "lottery" part above, and also that making good/interesting/exciting discoveries involves a good amount of luck that often doesn't translate to a greater likelihood of making discoveries in the future (senior academics have admitted this to me in private). And so researchers have to influencer-like work in promoting themselves by finding ways to be constantly publishing papers.
- jonahbenton 4y agoThis is such a ridiculous post. Thanks for the laugh. Academia in the US has been productized and the need for academic talent abstracted away. Students don't attend a given school because of specific star professors. They attend because of the things that admin does. Maintain the brand and messaging- a management and marketing exercise, not intellectual. Set up competitive housing, food, entertainment, job search and other amenities- also administrative, not intellectual. Operate the real estate and digital portfolios- also management. etc. For the lucky, manage the endowment. I say this as a parent with 2, soon 3, college age kids. Universities in the US are hotels that provide a particular flavor of entertainment to their attendees. Particularly in undergrad. Yes, students learn some subject domain material while there, usually, because that's what humans do in every situation they're in. But curricula are a dime a dozen. The open curriculum movements from the early 2000s, like open source, benefit those academics who are able to produce new material, harm those who cannot (but who may be good at teaching) but mostly they make it easy to commodify the actual academic talent in any given university. And student success? Not an academic issue. It's an administrative concern. Good thing, too. There is no action academics can take to "take back" their university. To think that something like that even makes sense is to live in fantasyland. It is neither how the university machine works (any more, if ever it did) nor is it what the payers in the market value. No students would attend a university run by academics, rather than run by managers. Without competitive amenities and messaging, the venture would be a failure. Any that succeeded would do so because of the academics took over ran the place like managers. Apologies for the strong language. There is no cynicism here. Just humor at the disconnect. Though expensive I find the university offerings in the US appropriate for my kids. As human beings first they need all of the things the administrative state provides. The actual intellectual/academic parts of the journey- even given the fact that they are all academically strong, 1500 SATs, etc- are relatively minor and incidental. Cheers. Hope this helps.
- pdonis 4y ago> No students would attend a university run by academics, rather than run by managers. I'm not sure what you're basing this claim on, since AFAIK there aren't any universities run by academics. But the reason for that has nothing to do with free competition in university education, and everything to do with government putting its thumb on the scale, both in the way it funds research and in the way it makes various forms of financial aid available so universities face zero cost pressure.
- blix 4y agoAcademics can't effectively organize because the pool of people who want to be professors but can't find a position is huge, and consequently the demands to simply stay afloat are so large that it doesn't leave a lot of time for much else.
- jackcosgrove 4y agoI think it's as simple as there is a glut of potential professors and instructors to act as scabs if the current faculty act up. Organizing is always undermined by an oversupply of labor.
- mnky9800n 4y agoalmost all academic staff are on temporary contracts and many of them have visas attached to those contracts. almost all administrative staff have permanent contracts and are local people. collective action by the academic staff would result in most of them losing their jobs and being deported. The administrative staff need only wait a year for this to happen and the thorns to be sent away.
- csomar 4y ago> veryone I talk to in your disciplines loathes university administrators and the politicians they effectively answer to, so why don't more academics cooperate across disciplines to topple the administrators? Barbarians at the gate. These organizations are already captured. Unfortunately, according to history, this will go only one way: Down.