3 ms·
Except that much of what we theorize about hunter-gatherers comes from relatively modern foragers, who lived in very resource-poor environments and were thus un
by zozbot234 4y ago
Except that much of what we theorize about hunter-gatherers comes from relatively modern foragers, who lived in very resource-poor environments and were thus unable to transition to more complex societal arrangements. Ancient "hunter-gatherers" may have been very different, and Gobekli Tepe is suggestive of that.
- defrost 4y ago"Relatively modern foragers" did have and still have complex social arrangements and rich trading partnerships. Göbekli Tepe is deeply interesting for being an apparent transition between fully nomadic living and the first permanent cities in Europe, however Graham Hancock is not some sole lone outsider commenting on this, there are many more qualified people providing a bedrock of thought on what may have occurred there with Hancock repackaging their work and adding a twist of magical thinking.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe fact that long-range trading arrangements among ancient foragers have only been posited very recently, and on the sheer weight of evidence, is quite significant and means Hancock has a point. Even then though, there's complex and then there's complex. Having more resources around means that people can devote time and effort to something other than bare survival--and that turns out to be one of the main factors behind complex societies. Any widespread disaster leading to lower resource availability would in turn have social collapse as its unavoidable consequence. Even mainstream historians and archaeologists readily accept that this happened, e.g. on Easter Island; Hancock is just generalizing that same kind of scenario.
- defrost 4y agoThe best of Hancock is unsourced and uncredited from the actual progenitors, the bulk of Hancock, that which remains, appears to be pop rubbish and discredited conjecture. I couldn't be arsed banning the chap, but he's offered nothing original of value that I'm aware off.
- kodyo 4y agoWho else should interested people be reading who are attempting to popularize this topic?