3 ms·
>The boat in the tweet likely isn’t even privately owned. The average cost of a cruise is $200/day, so this is hardly a signifier of exceptional success. It’s l
by coldtea 4y ago
>The boat in the tweet likely isn’t even privately owned. The average cost of a cruise is $200/day, so this is hardly a signifier of exceptional success. It’s like congrats, you took a photo on a boat…no one has ever done that before.
All of which is irrelevant, as the poster is Jeremy Clarkson. Like him or hate him, I'm pretty sure he didn't just booked a cabin in a cruise, more like rented the whole boat or is a guest of someone, or it could very well be his. But even if not: he does have a net worth of $70 million.
>As evidence of the predictive value of IQ beyond just exams, I’m sure many have seen the illustration below
It's not like Taleb hasn't argued about those very statistics and the same of similar illustration, time and again.
I mean, instead of refuting a soundbite in a Tweet, how about refuting his arguments on the subject, which have already answered to the stats you provide as refutation...
Talk about bringing Coals to Newcastle...
- paulpauper 4y agoThe crux of Taleb's argument is that IQ is not highly predictive of financial success at the high-end of IQ. But he fails to control for individual preferences. It's not like all high-IQ people aspire to high-paying jobs (such as writers, artists). If one aspires to make a lot of money, especially at a relatively young age, IQ is likely a major asset. If I want to be an engineer or work on Wall Street, my 110 IQ is likely going to put me at a disadvantage against those with 120+ IQs. You need a high IQ just to make it past the screening, let alone pass the interview. Credentials, math puzzles act as such a filtering mechanism.
- fzeroracer 4y agoWell no, someone with 120+ IQ is going to be disadvantaged against a 100/110 IQ person who understands how to lie or knows how to play the job game. Those are two separate and unrelated functions. Similarly, someone can be incredibly good at solving math puzzles, but unable to pick apart linguistic puzzles or define requirements. Someone who can perform well on the SATs is more a proxy for wealth and time as a correlation for ability to study, free time to study and lack of outside factors to interfere with studying. This also includes the ability to hire tutors for the SAT and the fact that those that do end up taking the SAT can be seen as having survivorship bias in the first place. As an aside; the fact that this article quotes Jordan Peterson as an 'expert' on IQ seems like a funny joke.
- lostmsu 4y ago> Well no, someone with 120+ IQ is going to be disadvantaged against a 100/110 IQ person who understands how to lie or knows how to play the job game. Statistically, I'd expect IQ and ability to lie to be positively correlated.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoJeremy Clarkson is the son of a woman who sold unlicensed, knock-off paddington bear dolls so well that the author of the books eventually decided to just license the bear to her for production. It is his mother's explicit opinion that without the millions of dollars she earned doing that Jeremy wouldn't have been part of the British upper class and wouldn't have had the success he has. His family was very rich when he was a child. He's an anecdotal case from a classist society and his success probably should not be used in a generalized discussion about IQ. In general, Britain has been so thoroughly classist that it's hard to make any meritocratic statements about any British people over about 40. Also the Brits don't have SATs? It's a very weird chain of arguments.