4 ms·
I hate submitting expenses probably as much as the typical engineer, but Concur seems “no better, no worse” than the typical dumpster fire of these systems. I
by sokoloff 4y ago
I hate submitting expenses probably as much as the typical engineer, but Concur seems “no better, no worse” than the typical dumpster fire of these systems.
I will say that it does have good integration between the company card transactions and the expense reporting feature.
I am more mystified than the author at why my 75-mile range electric car offers a default sorted list by full street name, then by state, happily inquiring as to whether I intend to drive 225 miles to my entered street name before a matching entry that’s 4 miles away.
- ghaff 4y agoOf course, Google Maps seems to be equally random when it starts guessing your destination. I reluctantly started using a corporate card for most things because I sort of had to. I don't like not getting the personal benefits but it actually does make (most) things easier with Concur. Only real issue is it's harder to split personal and company charges.
- emodendroket 4y agoDon't you still need to make an expense report in that case?
- ghaff 4y agoYes. But it means that all the expenses are accounted for and added to the expense report even if I need to add receipts for some of them and may have to add some additional information, e.g. category. As I say, not my choice but it probably captures some random fees etc. that I otherwise tend to forget about.
- jojobas 4y agoDepends. Most companies would have you specify the project/cost centre for every purchase, but amounts/locations/etc are automatically provided by the card issuer.
- hef19898 4y agoOf course, you are still spending company money at thosr expenses have to be properly accounted for.
- emodendroket 4y agoSure but I was asking why it saved any trouble.
- bragr 4y ago>I will say that it does have good integration between the company card transactions and the expense reporting feature. This surprised me too. Every expense system is ass but at least that saves a lot of data entry.
- lol768 4y agoI'd hazard a guess that it's because it's sold to finance people that value that sort of functionality (reconciliation of bank statement events with expense claims). Not much thought is given to the end users that have to put up with these tools.
- efitz 4y agoThis ^^^ The issue is a typical moral hazard, where the people who buy the software aren't the ones who have to bear the pain of using it. The requirements from the finance team were probably all around “expense coding is mandatory” and “pick things from a list to avoid typos”; i.e. things that make their lives easier. When it came to user experience, it got a ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ or no consideration at all. After all, most finance people rarely if ever travel. SAP has little incentive to put effort (money) into fixing it, because (1) they’ve got an ecosystem of third parties that do that and also probably serve as resellers or at least evangelists, and (2) complaints are going to help desk, not finance, so SAP’s paying customers aren't advocating for a fix. Executives are just handing their EA’s a wad of receipts; they don't feel the pain either.
- dude187 4y agoUsed to use concur in a past life, now expensify. There's not even words for how much better expensify is. It wasn't _that_ bad for a lot of entry types, but for me what made it a constant problem were hotels. It wanted a daily rate and number of days. Yet our rates were different day by day, and it made you do a separate tax entry. So you're having to BS a close enough "daily rate" and adjust the tax field of a specific day to adjust for any single penny rounding errors. Then there were resort fees or other things, which it would also make you call out but I think it even had a fixed number of "extra fees" input boxes. For a set of a few non travel expenses it was only a bit worse than any system ought to be. For travel it was practically unusable and for reasons that actually butchered your report
- geraldwhen 4y agoYou can enter each day manually now, with fees. It’s been this way for at least 7 years. That’s how long I’ve been filing expense reports with concur for hotels.
- dude187 4y agoI do remember that being a thing, but I think with the way it auto populated from our booking system meant I couldn't use it. It's been a bit, but I'm pretty sure I had to go through that realization each time too
- geraldwhen 4y agoIt’s definitely not pleasant, but it eventually works with enough clicks.
- ghaff 4y agoA lot of this is related to corporate policies. I use Concur and just enter the total and enter X nights in $CITY for a justification. I don't need to enter nightly total much less any sort of breakdowns. As I said in another comment, a LOT of Concur (and expense software generally) pain relates to the hoops a company makes you go through as opposed to the software itself. When we first implemented Concur, there was a lot of kvetching. A bunch of requirements got dialed down and while there are still a few silly things here and there, they're easy to work around once you know about them and it's mostly just the very random audit thing at this point.
- Aloha 4y agoWe used Excel based expense reporting for years, it takes me much less time to assemble my reports on concur, I rather like it, its the least of all evils.
- deely3 4y agoCould it be that by using Excel you just move complexity of reporting to someone who have to extract these data from Excel and import it into some system or analyze it?
- rsj_hn 4y agoCurious, what is the complexity of extracting data from excel or of loading a csv file into an external reporting system?
- triggercut 4y agoIt's not so much complexity as it is removing manual process steps and reducing all the risks and overhead associated with taking data on one format and loading it in to another - at scale
- sokoloff 4y agoWithout good validation (possibly including locked sheets), people will make all fashions of inconsistent entries that “look right enough” but will stymie automated ingestion. We had some hellish “use Excel as an interface to ‘real SAP’ process” for budgeting/headcount planning and it was almost utility-free for us as users. Even doing copy/paste would break parts of it, but invisibly to the user in real-time but would fail on import days/weeks later.
- rvba 4y agoYou never did this, so you dont know that even the "simplest" thing like writing an address can be done in 50 differenr ways, and then someone has to clean up the data before importing. Of course you can partially prepare for it by making a file where users have to pick things like town name from a scroll down list (hope your list has every town), but they still can get "creative" and mess it up.
- sailfast 4y agoAutomating policy always ends up manifesting all of the crufty, imprecisely implemented “people” and policy issues of an organization, just using computer UIs. This often restricts these kinds of systems from UI / user delight greatness.
- emeril 4y agoI had designed a simple excel file and upload template with my piss poor accounting system years ago but, of course, head office wanted to use concur so now it's a bit of a mess and our compliance is far worse than it was...
- starky 4y agoI've used Concur and Certify and they are oodles better than the crappy one that my company now uses that probably hasn't changed since the early 2000's and doesn't have any sort of mobile support for uploading receipts.
- dijit 4y ago> Concur seems “no better, no worse” than the typical dumpster fire of these systems. Circula has been good to me. I've submitted maybe 50 expenses with it, it's very easy to use. Not associated, other than being a (suprised) happy customer.
- Daneel_ 4y agoSadly it doesn't allow all my receipts to be uploaded as a single pdf, I have to split them all up individually. Most other systems let you do this.
- beart 4y agoMy experience as a traveling engineer The software we used before Concur was definitely better, or maybe it was the original version of the software before SAP bought them, I'm not sure. Prior to the switch, expense reports would take 5-10 minutes. After the switch, more than an hour easily. They made a lot of changes to Concur to try to help speed up the process, and fill gaps where the old software worked great. However, the final product still ended up far less efficient, and far more confusing.