4 ms·
I assume that this is by folks wanting to up their scores. That's a huge problem with "gamification." I'm not especially a fan of the concept, in a venue like
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I assume that this is by folks wanting to up their scores.
That's a huge problem with "gamification." I'm not especially a fan of the concept, in a venue like SO. I think it has led to a rather nasty community, and I hardly ever go there, anymore.
I assume that we'll be seeing a lot of robotic HN content (I would not be surprised if it is already here, but has been sidelined by the mods).
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoSmaller StackExchange communities don't have this problem from what I can tell. Stack Overflow maybe should be split up into smaller communities.
- mdaniel 4y agoThere already are plenty of smaller communities, but no one enforces the on-topic rules as they exist today, making SO into the "I haz computer problem" dumping ground it has become
- theptip 4y agoThe gamification mechanic was the innovation that let SO become as successful as it has, IMO. Without it there was no real way to figure out the “best” answer to problems. It’s fair to note that big communities can have somewhat unfriendly dynamics, but I think that’s more about big communities than the gamification mechanic.
- fouric 4y ago> I would not be surprised if it is already here, but has been sidelined by the mods I can virtually guarantee you that there's been a nontrivial amount of GPT-generated content on HN that has not been caught by mods since ChatGPT, and likely since GPT-2/3, as well. Dang (and the other one whose tag I can't recall) already have their hands full trying to keep the tone civil across thousands (tens of thousands?) of comments a day - it's impossible for them to catch every ML-generated comment (some humans actually do write like these newer language models, after all), and more than likely they're missing a decent number of them - through no fault of their own, it's just an extremely hard problem. The three solutions that I'm shilling for this problem are (1) invite-trees for HN (like Lobsters, which makes the community much less open but also much more resistant to abuse) (2) webs of trust (not cryptographic, just databases of how much you trust users) overlaid onto HN and other places and (3) people actually reading the content of comments very carefully and upvoting logically sound arguments and downvoting illogical and emotional/manipulative ones, but all of these require a lot of effort and social buy-in.
- patneedham 4y ago> some humans actually do write like these newer language models, after all Wouldn't it be more accurate to say these newer language models actually write like humans? Or is there a subset of the population intentionally trying to write in the way that these language models write.
- fouric 4y agoSure, you can also say that some language models write like humans - however, even pre-GPT-2, I read several high-schooler's essays that read very much like these ML-generated products, so even if you don't believe that the relationship is transitive, I think you can say that the relationship is true in both directions.
- seydor 4y agoIt seems to have a tendency to write stereotypical preamble-statement-conclusion paragraphs and to repeat itself. The model repeats itself often. It repeats the title and then writes a statement that basically repeats the title and after that it provides the useful nugget. At the end it adds a sentence usually using "overall" as an opener. Overall, the model tends to respond in a stereotypical format
- tpxl 4y ago> people actually reading the content of comments very carefully and upvoting logically sound arguments You can make a perfectly logical comment that is completely wrong.
- Dwedit 4y agoStack Overflow literally forces you to reach a certain score before you get downvoting rights. The gamification is real, but once you reach that point, you aren't required to play anymore.
- bnralt 4y agoSome years ago I was trying to do something that required a certain amount of points. Perhaps write a comment to a question instead of posting an answer. So I looked for ways to make points. Most of the interesting questions I could easily find looked to be already answered, and the new questions seemed to be mostly requests to fix bugs in people's code. I saw someone suggest fixing up answers that people had already made, and I found an upvoted answer that had a simple bug in it's code (something like "<" was used instead of "<="). So I went about to fix it, but was instructed that edits had to change more than five characters. I tried to find how people handle this, and the answer I saw was to make additional changes to the answers, no matter if it needed it or not. In the end I just left the bug in and gave up on trying to provide answers for the site.