9 ms·
> "... Live and let live" which seems to me the most logical/reasonable way to go about it. Only if you assume we're not a society, and that there's no social
by rayiner 4y ago
> "... Live and let live" which seems to me the most logical/reasonable way to go about it.
Only if you assume we're not a society, and that there's no social benefits to enforcing socially desirable behaviors and suppress socially undesirable ones.
- weard_beard 4y agoYou assume that there is and of a right aught to be enforcement. Others view that social evolution as up to god. We all cooperate and the least rigid will adopt the best and we’ll all copy one another.
- ricardobeat 4y agoWe have 3000+ years of very detailed data on how well that works, and all the “cooperation” that can be achieved…
- weard_beard 4y agoPrisoners dilema. We have 3 billion more to get it right.
- Thursday24 4y agoRemove the law, and all that remains is a jungle, where the strong domineer the weak.
- gavinray 4y ago"Live and let live" is based on the hope that everyone adopts that philosophy. Obviously with humans this can never be the case, until we modify our own brains/neurochemistry. IMO, adhere to it so long as the "Non-aggression Principle" holds, once that's breached, do whatever it is you have to do. "Leave me alone and I leave you alone. Poke me with a stick, and..."
- rayiner 4y agoPartly, yes, but it also assumes that "leaving each other alone" results in societally beneficial outcomes. That's not necessarily true. For example, in many Asian countries it's common to call out family and friends on their weight. It's not a "live and let live" approach, but it might explain why Asians tend to be skinny. (I'm reminded of the line from "Everything, Everywhere All at Once," where the mom goes "Wait. You are getting fat. And you never call me even though we have a family plan. And it's free. You only visit when you need something. And you got a tattoo and I don't care if it's supposed to represent our family. You know I hate tattoos.")
- gavinray 4y agoFair point and great anecdote. Though when I think "interference of my 'let-live'" my mind jumps to things a decent bit worse than family who make some well-meaning remarks that sting. I don't want to turn this into a big political/philosophical thing, but it feels like the line is between suggestions or commentary and forcible policing.
- ghufran_syed 4y ago“live and let live” has traditionally described the more tolerant end of the spectrum of possible “social enforcement”, not the absence of such enforcement - the problem is that the group that wants religious rights for society doesn’t want marriage rights for others in society, and the group that wants abortion rights in society doesn’t want gun rights for others in society. And so on. So the question is whether to have a society where we generally allow people to do things we don’t like, as the price of being allowed to do the things we do like, or a society that prevents us doing what we want as the price of preventing others doing things we don’t like. Or, you know, each side trying to get freedom for the things they care about but trying to ban the things they dislike? There is an obvious analogy with religion and religious freedom that I think the US constitution and bill of rights handled very effectively (compared to most other countries) at the “live and let live” end of the spectrum, maybe as a society we might want to see if the same principles might work more broadly?
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThat's a false equivalence. "Pro-life" advocates use a topic that some people find emotive purely for political ends. Gun control advocates object tto avoidable gun massacres in schools, malls, and other public places. They're not remotely comparable. The obvious difference is that if a woman has an abortion it's fundamentally a private matter. The outcome affects a single person. Or two people at most. The outcome is not a line of ambulances and coffins and a traumatised community of teachers, parents, and neighbours. Of course they're framed as if they're equivalent freedoms, because in the US "freedom" is a master-frame that can be used to justify almost anything. And that's the real problem. One group consistently uses deceptive single-issue appeals to emotion to gain and hold political power. If there are no real issues to appeal to, they'll quite happily invent some. They fundamentally don't care what the issue is as long as it's politically useful. The other group actually cares about outcomes - not just in a negative sense of wanting certain things not to happen, but in the positive sense of expanding political access to everyone in the community for the benefit of the entire community. What's missing - in the US particularly - is a political system which makes this fundamental distinction clear and explicit. Democracies have few defences against deceptive framing used for political grift. And that's not a good way to build a better future.
- marmetio 4y agoThere's a line where you should intervene when others are not letting others live and let live. That's the overall human societal obligation that everyone has to each other. Then there's another line where you build the type of society you want, but only within your own circle of culture or geography or whatever. Live and let live requires assuring the first part, while also not imposing your own version of the second part on people who are not within your circle. The expression has always had nuance. Until now, I had never heard such a simplistic interpretation.
- rayiner 4y ago> There's a line where you should intervene when others are not letting others live and let live. But why should that be the line? Why shouldn't we police each other's behavior to ensure everyone is making better decisions that serve larger societal ends while preserving social peace?
- marmetio 4y agoMaybe I wasn't clear, but that's the second line I described in the second paragraph that I wrote. You can build whatever society you want. But there are also different societies. Some by choice, some not. People can be part of multiple societies at the same time. The trick is to manage the interfaces between societies without imposing yourself on a society you don't belong to. Live and let live.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoBecause authoritarianism is bad.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe Counterpoint is that individuals should serve their own ends as long as it preserves social peace. Many object to the idea that Society should extract as much utility value from individuals as possible up until they're breaking point is reached. Furthermore, the breaking point for social peace can be modified and delayed by harsh repression and subjugation, so I don't think it is a suitable limit on suppressing the desires of individuals
- generalizations 4y ago> no social benefits to enforcing socially desirable behaviors and suppress socially undesirable ones What universally-agreed-upon moral standard do you think you can base that determination on?