4 ms·
> I thought anything taken/found outside the scope of the warrant would be impermissible. That isn't true in general, the supreme court has a test for whether
by Spivak 4y ago
> I thought anything taken/found outside the scope of the warrant would be impermissible.
That isn't true in general, the supreme court has a test for whether things outside the warrant can be seized / not constitute an unconstitutional search.
1. Must be in plain sight.
2. Must be apparent that it was used in a crime.
3. Doesn't have to be accidentally or inadvertently found but if it's not the bar for it being a legal search is much higher.
Since it's a safety deposit box 1 & 3 are pretty much already checked and I think falls down on 2. I can't possibly see how the existence of cash is apparent that it's used in a crime.
- jandrese 4y agoHow is something locked in a safety deposit box "in plain sight?"
- cperciva 4y agoIt's in plain sight once there's a legal justification for opening the box.
- pdonis 4y agoBut whether or not there was legal justification for opening the boxes is precisely the point at issue in this case. So the "plain view" doctrine can't possibly be used as a justifying argument in this case.
- CogitoCogito 4y agoOn the upside, maybe the next time cops go into the vault of a bank during a robbery, they can just take all the money they find and fund their pensions. Edit: I posted this as a (bad) joke, but then I see this sister comment on the article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33848245 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33848245 I liked it better as a joke.