5 ms·
Conflating crypto and AI seems unhelpful. But the subject of "realish domains" is useful. "Realish is reality rendered a bit user-friendly. Natural reality with
by Animats 4y ago
Conflating crypto and AI seems unhelpful. But the subject of "realish domains" is useful. "Realish is reality rendered a bit user-friendly. Natural reality with some improvements." Like sidewalks and traffic lights, and barriers around holes in the ground. Working definition: a realish environment can be traversed by someone who is looking at a phone.
This is a useful concept for targeting AI systems. I sometimes talk about the difficulties of getting AI to squirrel-level manipulation capability. There was an article today about Amazon's latest bin-picking system. It's way below squirrel level. But, in the "realish domain" of an Amazon warehouse, it's almost good enough to be useful.
This comes up all the time in manufacturing. Do you drop parts into a bin, or put them on something that keeps their orientation? If you lose orientation, at some point you have to pay somebody or something to get it back for the next step in the process.
There are degrees of order in part handling. The strict form is, they're in a mechanical feeder which will dispense one item in the desired orientation through a simple motion. Much of manufacturing works like that, but you need specialized tooling for each part. The other extreme, all the parts in a bin with a human pulling them out, is general-purpose but expensive, and slow for small parts. In the middle, there are systems which use simple computer vision systems to find parts in trays that keep the parts in approximately the right place. The vision system can deal with minor misalignment, empty slots, and upside down parts. Those are becoming popular now that simple vision systems are cheap.
"Realish domains" can get similar treatment. If you pad the sharp edges, the AI can be dumber. This applies to tasks outside manufacturing.
- bluepizza 4y agoI felt it is a fundamentally snobbish concept, as if a mall is less real than a park. All human spaces are artificial, we build them for a reason! Pretending that malls, offices, restaurants, airports, libraries and any other curated spaces are not absolutely real is self delusion. They are the building blocks of our reality, today.
- sdwr 4y agoA mall is less real then a park.
- bluepizza 4y agoWhy?
- sdwr 4y agoLess living things, less variety of living things, shorter pedigree. More things trucked in from the outside. A park in the desert is less real than a park in an appropriate climate. In some sense a mall is a fad, and dies without people. A park doesn't care either way.
- teddyh 4y agoAll that is true. But it does not make it any less real. It exists.
- sdwr 4y agoI disagree! I believe that the universe optimizes away unnecessary calculations, like occlusion culling in a game engine. The sun and the plants and animals make the park more real, more resilient against being optimized to nothing than an office.
- pixl97 4y agoYou have a very strange definition of real I cannot understand. Maybe you're conflating real with natural.
- bluepizza 4y agoIt's all real. It's all atoms. Every human space dies without humans, but that's the whole point: we are humans. Our lives are organized around those spaces. More people have fallen in (or out of) love in food courts than in nature spaces. An office also dies without people, but we spent most of our lives in an office. All of the ups and downs of life are being felt in that space. You might be anxious about your kid going to the kindergarten, but you are feeling this angst while sitting in your chair. Humanity is where the humans are.