4 ms·
The Internet has the same incentive landscape as bathroom stall graffiti. That's why you're so mad, Robyn. This isn't a back-and-forth between two real people
by ReactiveJelly 4y ago
The Internet has the same incentive landscape as bathroom stall graffiti. That's why you're so mad, Robyn.
This isn't a back-and-forth between two real people who mutually respect each other. If I was talking to Robyn in real life, over coffee, for 2 or 3 hours, we'd probably get something productive done.
But online, it's a hit-and-run dumpster where the truth matters a little, and humor and presentation matter _much more._
Robyn writes their wounded-gazelle piece whining about the woke cancel mob, and I try to 'clap back' without 'seething'. Wittgenstein would roll in his grave to see the level of MLG language gamers we have online these days.
Nuance gets buried online. I am not gonna sit here and write a boring screen-long essay expressing my nuanced thoughts on the rights of trans adults and trans children, to an audience that might literally be reading this on the shitter.
It works fine for less-controversial topics like Rust vs C. It just doesn't work for gender.
They who write on shit-house walls...
P.S. - If you have 2 hours to spare for nuance, I highly recommend the Contrapoints video about J. K. Rowling. This is a good, calm, nuanced discussion about why LGBTQ people and our allies don't like Rowling as much as we used to. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gDKbT_l2us https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gDKbT_l2us
If you don't have 2 hours to spare, then you aren't gonna get nuance, sorry to tell you.
- 0ct4via 4y agoI'd be curious as to what your views are, since you so eloquently wrote your previous lines, but then basically refused to share your own views. I wouldn't necessary recomment ContraPoints as a "calm, nuanced discussion" when it comes to these issues when Natalie Wynn (who portrays various characters as Contrapoints) takes issue with gender-neutral language (invalidating non-binary people), entertains and employs transphobic views, and fails to even understand gender properly[1]. [1] https://alyesque.medium.com/how-contrapoints-misunderstands-gender-bd833cc6d8c8 https://alyesque.medium.com/how-contrapoints-misunderstands-... The nuance involved takes a lot more than a ContraPoints video to go through, and would be better served with both a different source and topic than the video you linked.