6 ms·
"We are living in the post-truth" This implies there was a truth era. When was that?
by giantg2 4y ago
"We are living in the post-truth"
This implies there was a truth era. When was that?
- scatterhead 4y agoIt's just a dumb name to represent an idea. "an era of increased skepticism towards the idea of objective truth" is the idea.
- poszlem 4y agoThe "truth era" wasn't the era when everything was true, but when we actually believed that there is such a thing as "the truth". I would argue that up until the time when "Applied Postmodernism" took hold in some of our most important institution we could say that we lived in the "truth" era.
- wwweston 4y agoPostmodernism is the reckoning with the problem, not the problem itself. It recognizes epistemological difficulties and how different power interests or ideological preferences are often tied up with claims of "the truth." The people who dislike it the most tend to be either those who've been effectively manipulated by power interests, or those who find reckoning with the difficulty of finding the truth inconvenient.
- akiselev 4y ago> It recognizes epistemological difficulties and how different power interests or ideological preferences are often tied up with claims of "the truth." Down the nihilistic rabbit hole we go! That's this layman's understanding of where postmodernism almost invariably ends up.
- wwweston 4y agoIf you're equating the elaboration of difficulty with the declaration of impossibility, then the nihilism is inside you.
- akiselev 4y agoThat’s exactly what a nihilistic postmodernist would say.
- wwweston 4y agoI mean, I guess your pithy comeback is a sentence someone could say if they were all in on posture and casual in their nihilistic contempt for semantics and substance.
- akiselev 4y agoWe should start a podcast! No one will be able to tell if we’re serious, trolling ourselves, trolling each other, or trolling the audience. The essence of postmodernism is actually plausible deniability.
- adolph 4y ago> The people who dislike it the most tend to be either those who've been effectively manipulated by power interests, or those who find reckoning with the difficulty of finding the truth inconvenient. Excellent way to avoid engaging with an idea you might find disagreeable, a tip of a straw hat to you
- naasking 4y ago> Postmodernism is the reckoning with the problem, not the problem itself. It recognizes epistemological difficulties and how different power interests or ideological preferences are often tied up with claims of "the truth." Which is fine for "claims to truth", but it's not fine when people think this entails that there is no such thing as truth, or sometimes that all claims to truth are equally valid.
- bjornsing 4y agoMaybe I was just young and naive back then, but when I was at uni 20 years ago the truth still seemed to hold some sway. In my subjective experience there’s been a massive change since then, but it’s hard to say how much of that is me changing and how much is actual change in the world.
- zdragnar 4y agoThe age of enlightenment was a time of new emphasis on, among a great many other things, obtaining knowledge through reason and structured logic. Even seeing "science" as a discreet concept (i.e. the scientific process) came to be in this time period. Modernism was a shakeup and rejection of "realism"; post-modernism took it a step further by rejecting the notion of a universal truth entirely; the replacement idea is that what is true can only be discerned based on an individual's experience as we can only gain knowledge through imperfect means.
- jltsiren 4y agoMaybe from the Enlightenment to the early 20th century. Back then, science was still understood as the pursuit of truth. The big idea in 20th century science, philosophy of science, and mathematics was that the truth is fundamentally unreachable. We got quantum mechanics as the foundation of reality. We got the idea that experiments can only rule out explanations but not establish the truth. We got used to probabilistic estimates based on data. We got all those uncomfortable results about the incompleteness and undecidability of formal systems. Science became a social construct. We got evidence instead of facts; we got explanations, predictions, and interpretations instead of the truth. Science became a system of best practices for building and updating consensus based on empirical evidence.
- JadeNB 4y ago> The big idea in 20th century science, philosophy of science, and mathematics was that the truth is fundamentally unreachable. We got quantum mechanics as the foundation of reality. We got the idea that experiments can only rule out explanations but not establish the truth. We got used to probabilistic estimates based on data. We got all those uncomfortable results about the incompleteness and undecidability of formal systems. I am not an experimental scientist or philosopher, but I am a mathematician, and I thoroughly reject the claim that the big idea of 20th-century mathematics is that the truth is fundamentally unreachable. To be sure, we found that one can speak meaningfully, and rigorously, of the limits of decidability; but only an algorithmic view of mathematics will lead one to conclude that this makes the truth unreachable. Perhaps one could advance the claim that certain truths are unreachable (I do not, and find the claim woolly), but that is quite different from saying that truth itself is unreachable.
- analog31 4y agoI'm an experimental scientist. My take would be that truth is reachable, but the Truth with a capital T is a potentially meaningless throwback to a past age of certainty. What I mean is that some theories have been corroborated to the point that they can be regarded as "truth" for all intents and purposes, and despite known limitations in some cases. Examples might include electromagnetism, quantum mechanics, gravitation, and biological evolution. Regarding those theories, we can still say that we accept them on a tentative basis, but it would not be irrational to assign a vanishingly low likelihood that any of them will be radically overturned.
- downvotetruth 4y agoNo, it does not. A post-truth era may be one in which truth & falsity are not absolute & the only choices. Relativity brings about the realization that two people can witness the same event, obtain different measurements (usual example is in "empty" space where both start at the same velocity & distance to the event location, but one is in an accelerating reference frame relative to the other leading to different photon counts & "time" passage) & both be correct.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoIf you've got an experiment (either relativistic or quantum, or both) where two individuals can obtain different photon counts, I'd like to hear about it.
- JadeNB 4y ago> If you've got an experiment (either relativistic or quantum, or both) where two individuals can obtain different photon counts, I'd like to hear about it. The experiment could simply be measuring photon counts at a pre-agreed location after a pre-agreed duration, where the elapsed time is measured by a local clock. (Probably it is reasonable to argue that this is not a "reasonable" experiment, but it's beyond me to make rigorous the sense in which it should be excluded.)
- dinosaurdynasty 4y agoThere is stuff like the Unruh effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect
- downvotetruth 4y agoDescription was trying to avoid the misnomer eponym ("Stigler's law").
- ycombigator 4y agoThis example doesn't mean what you think it means.
- jl6 4y agoRoughly prior to the mid-2010s, when people talked about “the truth” instead of “my truth”.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoDifferent people have different lived experience. "My truth" is just a recognition of that.
- jl6 4y agoExperience is a different thing to truth and it doesn’t help to conflate the two.
- TeeMassive 4y agoWhen truth was the goal, back to the ancient Greeks. Postmodernists believe that it is more important to have the "right" political impact than to be correct.
- throwawayacc4 4y agoIf a "truth era" did exist, it was definitely before the current era of "math and acronyms are racist" and "men can get pregnant".
- animitronix 4y agoSo well said