17 ms·
What good is legal action upon entities that are, by design, extrajudicial to begin with? You can sue NSO out of existence and the people and tradecraft involve
by solardev 4y ago
What good is legal action upon entities that are, by design, extrajudicial to begin with? You can sue NSO out of existence and the people and tradecraft involved will just reappear a few months later under a different name and organization, but keep doing business as before.
The whole point of setups like this is to circumvent legal checks and balances to get information they wouldn't normally be able to get. No intelligence apparatus is going to give up that ability, especially not over some silly foreign lawsuit complaining about hacking. This isn't even a slap on the wrist, it's just legal theater.
- tptacek 4y agoA successful judgement against NSO makes it radioactive for US investment firms and potential acquirers.
- solardev 4y agoEven if that company ceased to exist, they'd just reorganize under a different name later on.
- vorpalhex 4y ago1. Forming companies and getting clients isn't zero cost. 2. Judges are human and can apply appropriate principles.
- solardev 4y agoYou're dealing with what is essentially a front for gray-area extrajudicial hacking. The company itself isn't the issue, it's that it gives governments and other entities cover when they want to do shady shit. Same reason we use private military companies. The profitability of any one such company isn't really terribly important (from a privacy standpoint)... when one goes down, another takes its place, and the willing buyers will just buy from a new one instead. Like drug dealers. From the privacy angle, nobody cares about NSO profitability... the point is that even if they go bankrupt, the underlying people, technologies, procedures, and overall shadiness will not only remain but grow stronger and more hidden, learning from this incident. Zero-days will keep getting found and bought and used for surveillance, and that is not something the legal system can solve, because a major customer IS state buyers who are funneling resources to it to purposefully circumvent legal protections. Judges aren't almighty, the law is selectively enforced, and almost always overridden for "national security" purposes.
- tptacek 4y agoI mean, this is all fun stuff to noodle about, but, no: NSO was almost sold to L3Harris; legal drama prevented that from happening. You really can just look this stuff up. You don't have to start from first principles and try to reason your way to conclusions.
- worik 4y ago> You're dealing with what is essentially a front for gray-area extrajudicial hacking. The company itself isn't the issue, It is a game of whack'a'mole. But a business that gets you sued is radioactive for investors. SO while the technology exists, and means will be found by well funded agencies to exploit it, it will become less and less accessible to private corporations as a business model. That is a good thing. That results from suing them.
- EMM_386 4y agoLet's not kid ourselves here, NSO is no regular "company" and doesn't face any of these issues. This is literally an arm of the Israeli intelligence apparatus. The laws as you and I see them do not apply in any form whatsoever to NSO.
- tptacek 4y agoIf that's the case, then Israeli intelligence attempted to sell an arm of their own intelligence apparatus to a US defense contractor. Have you spent a lot of time looking into NSO?
- brookst 4y ago2 is critical. Tech people tend to fall for “one simple trick” because they believe there is a highly formal rule system we’re any technical loophole is just “oh well, the rules didn’t apply” But reality is judges and the justice system are intentionally analog and human and fallible, and can use judgment to sledgehammer people trying to use one simple trick.
- drivebycomment 4y agoIt imposes a significant cost and friction to their operation and proliferation of the access to what they have, even if they reorganize. So this is a very good action in my book.
- paganel 4y agoCompanies like NSO and its potential clones do not rely on the money given by US investment firms.
- tptacek 4y agoAnother very weird NSO take. There was a whole spate of news stories about NSO shopping themselves to US investors, and ultimately putting the whole company on the block. The sale would have actually occurred had the Biden administration not stopped it. No, I think this is comprehensively false. I think people on HN have a really bad habit of mythologizing CNE shops. You do not in fact need state sponsorship to do exploit R&D and build software implants; dozens of people have started companies that do exactly that, and they get bought routinely. All of them have state actors as their primary client base. I wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that NSO has a tight relationship with the IDF, the same way lots of commercial CNE shops in the US have relationships with NSA. I wouldn't even be surprised to learn the relationship is deeper than that. But there is no evidence at all that NSO is an "arm of Israeli intelligence" in any formal sense, and a lot of countervailing evidence. It's possible the only thing that distinguishes NSO from any of a dozen other shops is that they happen to be Israeli. Somehow, a CNE shop in Auckland just doesn't seem to excite HN the same way. Maybe there's more to the story than I'm suggesting! But, like, you know what they say about extraordinary claims.
- saurik 4y agoIn case anyone wants some references, I hadn't been paying much attention to NSO in many years, and so got really curious about the "ultimately putting the whole company on the block" comment, so I figured I'd provide some links that I came across: https://www.axios.com/2021/07/22/nso-group-spying-investors https://www.axios.com/2021/07/22/nso-group-spying-investors > The bottom line: NSO isn't some rogue company being operated out of the basements of shadowy founders. Instead, it's been empowered by institutional investors that appear to have turned a blind eye to its deeds in the pursuit of profit. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/magazine/nso-group-israel-spyware.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/magazine/nso-group-israel... > The F.B.I. had bought a version of Pegasus, NSO’s premier spying tool. For nearly a decade, the Israeli firm had been selling its surveillance software on a subscription basis to law-enforcement and intelligence agencies around the world, promising that it could do what no one else — not a private company, not even a state intelligence service — could do: consistently and reliably crack the encrypted communications of any iPhone or Android smartphone. > Since NSO had introduced Pegasus to the global market in 2011, it had helped Mexican authorities capture Joaquín Guzmán Loera, the drug lord known as El Chapo. European investigators have quietly used Pegasus to thwart terrorist plots, fight organized crime and, in one case, take down a global child-abuse ring, identifying dozens of suspects in more than 40 countries. In a broader sense, NSO’s products seemed to solve one of the biggest problems facing law-enforcement and intelligence agencies in the 21st century: that criminals and terrorists had better technology for encrypting their communications than investigators had to decrypt them. The criminal world had gone dark even as it was increasingly going global. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/jul/31/nso-group-israeli-spyware-company-berkeley-research-group https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/jul/31/nso-group-israe... > If the deal proceeds, the California-based company would take over the fund that owns NSO at a difficult time for the Israeli company. The French government has called for an investigation into allegations that NSO clients listed key government officials, including most of Emmanuel Macron’s cabinet, as persons of interest. In the US, a senior Biden administration official involved in national security has also raised concerns about the Pegusus project revelations to an Israeli official.
- FormerBandmate 4y agoIsn’t it already radioactive? They’re already on the Entity List
- tptacek 4y agoAs recently as July, the 6th largest defense contractor in America was set to purchase them, so I think whatever radioactivity they had, it was pretty mild.
- ok123456 4y agoStephen Watt got prison time for writing hacking tools that he himself didn't use. Why is this any different?
- solardev 4y agoLots of hackers get jail time. That doesn't mean it stops warrantless wiretapping. They're just the low-hanging fruit and/or fall guys.
- tptacek 4y agoEvidence was presented at trial (including chat transcripts) demonstrating that Watt supplied hacking tools and expertise knowing that he was providing individualized assistance to what was at the time the largest identity theft conspiracy ever uncovered. The getaway driver doesn't stick up the bank either, but he has approximately the same luck in sentencing. These things tend to come down to the level of intent the prosecution can establish, not just to the specific actions conspirators take. I don't know what that says about NSO. I have no trouble believing NSO has culpability comparable to Watt's. It helps NSO that they're not generally operating under US criminal justice jurisdiction. Nothing special had to be done to convict Watt.
- stefan_ 4y agoNSO operates the spyware. They have tried to claim they are entitled to immunity because they sell to governments but were predictably laughed out of court. So while this might be a civil suit, all NSO employees and certainly its leadership are similarly exposed to criminal liability in all countries their spyware has been operated.
- _jal 4y ago> hat good is legal action upon entities that are, by design, extrajudicial to begin with? So do you think fighting all organized criminal activity is pointless? If not, how do you distinguish someone like NSO from, say, a smuggling ring?