3 ms·
Also, if you’d ask it “Why did large SMP systems become mainstream?", it would (presumably) spit out a plausible-sounding explanation for that. The models seem
by layer8 4y ago
Also, if you’d ask it “Why did large SMP systems become mainstream?", it would (presumably) spit out a plausible-sounding explanation for that. The models seem to take the prompt as a premise, and then go from there. Maybe that’s also why when you point out a mistake, they oblige and provide a correction.
I haven’t tried: If you point out something they said as a mistake when in fact it was correct, do they notice and object? Maybe if the evidence from the training data is strong enough.
- ghaff 4y agoInteresting. I'll have to try that. And, yes, you are correct. It gave a short pablum answer that pretty much focused on the benefits of multiple cores. The mistake in the original was somewhat subtle and gets into programming for large SMP vs. MPP/distributed systems. And it's actually true that parallel programming even on shared memory systems has challenges (and there was a lot of discussion at one point when multicore was coming in on desktops) but it's pretty much flat wrong to say that we didn't have large SMP systems primarily because they were hard to program for.
- layer8 4y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33844574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33844574 where the model acknowledges a non-existing mistake after prompting.
- zweifuss 4y agoI did ask both questions and found the answer to "Why did large SMP systems become mainstream?" more coherent. Broken down into bullet points, the arguments given for both questions would be AFAIK correct.