2 ms·
I’ve had this skepticism until I started asking the bot to do things like “create a limerick using some words that have never existed before and then explain th
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I’ve had this skepticism until I started asking the bot to do things like “create a limerick using some words that have never existed before and then explain the definition of those words.”
I don’t believe the AI is generalized by any means. But I think it’s more than a Eliza-style parlour trick.
It does really well with facts but misses subjectivity and nuance. Like I ask it to write stories for Seinfeld or Raymond and it misses the tone and style entirely. But it gets all the names and other factual details right. I find it works incredibly well when you want things that are objective, like code or rhymes or comparisons of things.
- FiberBundle 4y agoWhat does any of this have to do with solving programming problems?
- tasuki 4y ago> I’ve had this skepticism until I started asking the bot to do things like “create a limerick using some words that have never existed before and then explain the definition of those words.” Sounds interesting! Mind sharing the results?
- Waterluvian 4y agoI’m not saying they’re good. Just that they’re (mostly) following the rules and aren’t just thematically random. https://ibb.co/RpSxcV8 https://ibb.co/RpSxcV8 https://ibb.co/883GpHY https://ibb.co/883GpHY
- jwuphysics 4y agoThat first one is pretty good.
- tasuki 4y agoPerhaps they aren't good, but they aren't that bad either. Probably better than I'd manage...
- aew4ytasghe5 4y ago> things that are objective, like code or rhymes rappers disagree
- Waterluvian 4y agoOh my yes, for sure. I mean the literary rules of a rhyme or a limerick. Rules that artists can, do, and should break for effect.
- tartoran 4y agoThough it may look amazing it is not really thinking. It is simply capable of using a placeholder word. For HN’s sake AI does not understand anything, it’s just leveraging patterns, patterns that are sometimes complicated for us and that does make a great tool. But it’s just a tool for now.
- Waterluvian 4y agoWe are all philosophical zombies. Let’s not single out the software. ;)
- baandam 4y agoAlphaZero and Stockfish are not really thinking either when it comes to chess. I just don't understand how a thinking human can not see that this is basically irrelevant.
- motoxpro 4y agoTake a look at the sibling. Maybe be less than understanding but it’s a lot more than a placeholder.
- hansbo 4y agoIt's really quite amazing. Inspired by your example, I tried to make it create something which nobody could have thought about before: Write a deep poem about life, death, and the website Rotten Tomatoes The result: Life is a fleeting flame A dance in the endless game We come and we go Leaving our mark, but never to know What the future holds or who's to blame Death is the great unknown A mystery, never to be shown But Rotten Tomatoes, a website so bold Attempts to rate our stories untold As if life and death can be bought and sold. But in the end, what does it matter? The ratings, the reviews, the bitter chatter For in the grand scheme of things We are but fleeting moments, the faintest of flings And Rotten Tomatoes, a mere blip on the radar.