4 ms·
Not really. If Google or Bing hadn't paid enough then it would be pretty easy[1] to raise the money from random investors. There are precedents for that - Lyc
by nl 15y ago
Not really.
If Google or Bing hadn't paid enough then it would be pretty easy[1] to raise the money from random investors.
There are precedents for that - Lycos (I think? or Infoseek?) raised capital after buying a default slot on the original Netscape browser with money they didn't actually have.
[1] Not saying that building a web scale search engine is easy, exactly, but I am saying that the default search engine for ~25% of the world web browsers is a business a lot of investors would want to invest in.
- bobthebee 15y agoIt's a great option to consider, but: * What matters is not just default placement, but actual share. How many would not switch to Google? Say hypothetically half which I think is generous. * That leaves them with the kind of share that Bing had prior to the yahoo deal. And bing was losing over a billion a year. * That still doesn't actually create a business model, because now they have create a search ad network to compete with AdWords. That's another tough problem - especially without scale. So all in all I don't doubt they could raise some money, but chances of success would be extremely slim. I don't think that Mozilla has a BATNA to Bing/Google which is why the economics are so different in each round. It's entirely based on Google and Bing bidding against each other.
- zobzu 15y agoInvestors don't invest if there are no shares to get. And, there are no shares to get. And that's the whole point of Mozilla's existence. Thus, there's only such deals and donations. An investor would therefore need to donate, to support Mozilla.
- cpeterso 15y agoI think nl was suggesting that investors could raise money to buy Firefox's search spot and then create a search engine. Imagine if some VC firm raised $301M to outbid Google and then signed a deal with DuckDuckGo.
- bobthebee 15y agoIf DuckDuckGo could really make $301+ M on search in Firefox, they would bid that. Reality, they can't. There is no value created in the imagined middle man investor.
- nl 15y ago1) Create a company 2) Bid $300 million for Mozilla's search spot. 3) Raise $600 million, build search engine 4) Profit (Yeah, in practice steps 2 and 3 would need to happen simultaneously)
- dextorious 15y agoProfit how? From your search engine? 99% of FF users would just switch to Google as soon as they install it. It's not like anybody has made a competent enough search engine yet...
- nl 15y ago99% of FF users would just switch to Google as soon as they install it. I assume you can back that up somehow? Most evidence I've seen indicates that the majority of people don't change defaults. It's not like anybody has made a competent enough search engine yet http://blekko.com/ http://blekko.com/ http://duckduckgo.com/ http://duckduckgo.com/ http://www.gigablast.com/ http://www.gigablast.com/ http://www.yandex.com/ http://www.yandex.com/ http://www.baidu.com/ http://www.baidu.com/ There would be more if there was an easy way around the distribution problem. Becoming the default search engine in Firefox would sure help with that problem.
- dextorious 15y ago"""99% of FF users would just switch to Google as soon as they install it. I assume you can back that up somehow? Most evidence I've seen indicates that the majority of people don't change defaults."""" Then the evidence you've seen is wrong. If people "don't change defaults" how come they switched to FF in the first place, which is not the default browser on Windows, but is (or rather, was until it lost to Chrome) an extremely popular windows browser? Maybe naive users don't change defaults, but those users are sticking with (duh) the default IE. Users that moved to FF are more likely to change defaults. Also, they won't even have to change the default: they just navigate to google.com and search from there, instead of using the search in the toolbar with this unfamiliar "Bing" thing. """http://blekko.com/ http://blekko.com/ http://duckduckgo.com/ http://duckduckgo.com/ (...) """ Note the use of the word: "competent". None has results that good that make people actually want to switch to it. (For example, DDG's main selling point is privacy). The only example I agree with, Baidu was made from a similar algorithm to Google's and with a remarkably similar history (RankDex vs PageRank etc). And even that is mainly popular in China for national/cultural/political reasons, methinks.