3 ms·
The worst part of this censorship was the pure stupidity of trying to censor links to a website that was always available independently of Twitter and Facebook.
by lapcat 4y ago
The worst part of this censorship was the pure stupidity of trying to censor links to a website that was always available independently of Twitter and Facebook. If someone wanted to read the story, they could always go to the original source, the NY Post. It's just impossible to keep it a secret, and that's why the censorship attempt was an utter failure, predictably so. Failure was inevitable in this case. Twitter could delete tweets and DMs, but they couldn't erase the NY Post. It was hubris that made Twitter and Facebook think they controlled access to the whole world (wide web), but they didn't.
The story itself, though, was a nothingburger IMO. Which is why the censorship of the story became the story. I hear a lot of people complain about the censorship of the story, which may be a legit complaint, but I haven't heard a good argument of why Hunter Biden should have been a crucial factor in deciding how to vote in 2020, when there were a ton of other vastly more important issues.
- mikkergp 4y agoBut your point is the point as to why it’s not hubris! they weren’t trying to censor anything, they were just trying to follow their own moderation policies. This I think is why the censorship story is such a non issue, because Twitter is not an exclusive source of this information.
- lapcat 4y ago> they weren’t trying to censor anything, they were just trying to follow their own moderation policies. Well, it seems more like they were trying to apply their moderation policies to another website, which isn't the same as applying their moderation policies to their own website. Anyway, moderation is censorship. I'm not saying that's bad, I'm just saying that's what it is.
- jpgvm 4y agoDid they? Where did they try to get NY Post to take the original article down?
- lapcat 4y ago> Where did they try to get NY Post to take the original article down? Your reply is based on a mistaken assumption.
- jpgvm 4y agoCan you clarify what you mean about them attempting to apply their moderation policies to another website then? The rest of the context makes this appear as if you mean the NY Post...
- lapcat 4y agoYes, I do mean the NY Post. The content in question was not hosted on Twitter, it was hosted on the NY Post website. Twitter moderates the content hosted on Twitter, the NY Post moderates the content hosted by the NY Post. But when Twitter censored links to the NY Post, Twitter was attempting to apply its own moderation policy to content hosted outside of Twitter. Again, I'm not claiming that blocking links is inherently bad. For example, it may be reasonable to block links to malware, phishing, misleading URL shorteners, etc. I'm just saying that this is censorship. "Moderation" is a euphemism for censorship.
- jpgvm 4y agoSo they didn't try remove it from NY Post... they just removed links to NY Post... That isn't moderating the NY Post or attempting to extend their moderation policies beyond the border of their own systems.
- dmitrygr 4y agoDid you read the OP? Even their CEO questioned of this was proper application of the policy. Their top legal dude admitted that they had been wrong but advised to stay the course. It was NEVER about the policy, except as a justification. They literally admit so multiple times...
- mikkergp 4y agoYes exactly! They asked all the right questions then realized they didn’t have justification and it was a mistaken, apologize and I hope learned from the incident. And will react faster in the future. But this is the point. They made a mistake, fine but no one said “hey, I hate Trump, maybe we should keep this down” Never make moderation mistakes can’t be the standard.
- jackmott 4y ago
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoWhen moderation policies (or laws) are subjectively and arbitrarily enforced based on the identity of the party being persecuted, it ceases to be a policy and is simply another tool used to bludgeon those who are disfavored. It was a big story in September of 2020 when the NYT published Trump's hacked/leaked tax returns - a story that did not receive the Hunter Biden treatment, but was amplified all across Twitter. How can anyone who is even reasonably impartial and reasonably intelligent argue that Twitter was merely neutrally enforcing moderation policies in the Hunter Biden situation when it took the polar opposite stance when it came to Trump? https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/09/27/us/donald-trump-taxes.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/09/27/us/donald-tru... Indeed, numerous articles written explicitly from hacked sources (unlike the Biden laptop, which was only [faslely] rumored to be "hacked") were published and advertised on Twitter. These articles were never suppressed. How can it be argued Twitter was merely neutrally enforcing their policy when the only articles suppressed were clearly done to benefit their preferred political partisans? https://twitter.com/ZaidJilani/status/1598855600083177472 https://twitter.com/ZaidJilani/status/1598855600083177472 Personally I am (and have never been) neither a Republican or a Trump supporter, but what I (and many other like me) am is someone who supports free speech, open discourse and rational thinking. This is only part 1 of the "Twitter files", with many more revelations to come, and it is already incredibly damning. It is stunning to me that so many otherwise intelligent people do not see the problem with big tech colluding with government officials and intelligence agencies to brazenly attempt to distort and censor public discourse - especially right before an election. The ability of people to willfully delude themselves is astounding.
- mikkergp 4y ago>It is stunning to me that so many otherwise intelligent people do not see the problem with big tech colluding with government officials and intelligence agencies to brazenly attempt to distort and censor public discourse - especially right before an election. You took a giant leap from maybe people at Twitter were acting with bias. You’d need a lot more information to justify this assertion, and who is saying this wouldnt be a problem? I al saying this didn’t happen, not it wouldn’t be a problemZ
- we_never_see_it 4y agoI don't think it's about removing access per se. It is more about making the story radioactive to Dem voterbase - (upper-)middle class suburban white collar demographic. To ensure that their loyal voterbase stays loyal. Same thing happened with Andrew Cuomo. It was an elaborate play designed to make Dem voterbase to believe how amazing Dems are at handling COVID. Meanwhile dilligent citizens knew what Cuomo had done with the nrusing homes. The moment Biden took office Cuomo was thrown under bus because Dems knew due to his nursing home scandal he has become a liability. The longer he stays in the office the more it'll draw attention to Dems' creafully written PR plot.
- rhaksw 4y agoNY Post is an established source that still needs to refresh its audience. So it's a little of both: dumb and concerning. Lesser-known domains will indeed suffer from draconian moderation policies of today's largest social media sites. Case in point, my domain appears to be shadowbanned. This Tweet [1] only appears when directly linked. It does not appear beneath its parent [2] for anyone but me. That leads me to believe that tweets mentioning my .win domain [3] are all shadowbanned. I don't know for sure what's going on. I know it wasn't the parent author's action that hid my content because Twitter is auditable for when that happens. [1] https://twitter.com/rhaksw/status/1594103021407195136 https://twitter.com/rhaksw/status/1594103021407195136 [2] https://twitter.com/TheFIREorg/status/1594078057895063553 https://twitter.com/TheFIREorg/status/1594078057895063553 [3] https://cantsayanything.win/2022-10-transparent-moderation/ https://cantsayanything.win/2022-10-transparent-moderation/
- coredog64 4y agoThere are two possibilities to consider Hunter Biden a legitimate election influence. The first is that he’s a human shit show and will be a distraction to his father. The second is that he’s leveraging his father’s political connections for a high paying, do nothing job. While the latter may be more damning, it’s also pretty common.
- robryan 4y agoEven if he was, it is only going to turn the vote of someone looking for any reason to vote for Trump, given the whole Trump family was basically leveraging Trump being president for their own high paying/ high status positions.
- newZWhoDis 4y ago> It's just impossible to keep it a secret, and that's why the censorship attempt was an utter failure Context matters. They didn’t fail to hide the story, that wasn’t the goal. They succeeded in their goal of preventing the story from harming their candidate a few days before the election. This is everything the left says they care about, a mega corp colluding with powerful connected political interests to determine the outcome of an election
- lapcat 4y ago> They succeeded in their goal of preventing the story from harming their candidate a few days before the election. Did they? Of course Joe Biden was elected, but there's no evidence that this was the cause. I said "I haven't heard a good argument of why Hunter Biden should have been a crucial factor in deciding how to vote in 2020, when there were a ton of other vastly more important issues." And I still haven't heard one. In any case, the censorship seems to have backfired somewhat and raised the profile of the story. People won't shut up about it even now, two years later.
- newZWhoDis 4y ago> but there's no evidence that this was the cause. “Prove our massive illegal censorship campaign was effective!” You can not in good faith argue that this was acceptable. This is obvious because your only argument at this point is that sure it was wrong, but it didn’t work. That’s not going to save everyone on these email lists from prison.
- chrisbaker98 4y agoPrison? I think Twitter was wrong to censor this story, but what crimes were committed?
- iinnPP 4y ago18 U.S. Code § 595 - Interference by administrative employees of Federal, State, or Territorial Governments Whoever, being a person employed in any administrative position by the United States, or by any department or agency thereof, or by the District of Columbia or any agency or instrumentality thereof, or by any State, Territory, or Possession of the United States, or any political subdivision, municipality, or agency thereof, or agency of such political subdivision or municipality (including any corporation owned or controlled by any State, Territory, or Possession of the United States or by any such political subdivision, municipality, or agency), in connection with any activity which is financed in whole or in part by loans or grants made by the United States, or any department or agency thereof, uses his official authority for the purpose of interfering with, or affecting, the nomination or the election of any candidate for the office of President, Vice President, Presidential elector, Member of the Senate, Member of the House of Representatives, Delegate from the District of Columbia, or Resident Commissioner, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than one year, or both