4 ms·
> Even the Romans weren't always so conciliatory and rational - in conquering Carthage they sold the entire surviving population into slavery and destroyed the
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Even the Romans weren't always so conciliatory and rational - in conquering Carthage they sold the entire surviving population into slavery and destroyed the original city entirely.
But Carthage wasn't just a city, it was a region. The city was sacked for standing up to Rome -- essentially the same policy the Mongols used. What happened to the rest of the region?
Britain during and after the fall of Rome is worth considering here; it's similar and also different. Roman Britain was overrun by Germanic tribes and the system that resulted wasn't closely related to the system in place under the Romans.
But I see that as related to the invasion being decentralized. It was more "a large number of small groups of people showing up" than "Genghis Khan showing up with his horde".
We may have different ideas of what "the local administration is left in place" means. The Yongle emperor (Chinese) deposed his own nephew (also Chinese) and subsequently executed a very large share of the people who had been administrators (still Chinese) under the previous regime, along with their families.
But the system of Chinese administration was left untouched by the mass executions. A slate of administrators was wiped out and replaced by very similar people doing very similar things.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWell all bureaucracies must do a very large number of very similar things regardless of location, culture, etc..
- thaumasiotes 4y agoYou might think so, but that just isn't true. There are a few core tasks, like tax collection, that have to be done everywhere. But even those core tasks are handled in very different ways from place to place. Questions like who is eligible to potentially be an administrator; how do they actually become one; what does the org chart look like; and what functions does the administration perform, all vary radically between different cultures.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoEvery military hierarchy in a sizeable country (> 10 million population), since WW1, has been organized almost identically except during the communist revolutions, and even then they reverted to the norm. I'm pretty certain there are close to optimal organizational structures for certain other functions as well, given the same standard human and technological limitations. Comparing two societies at different points in time would obviously yield much larger differences.
- qwytw 4y ago> What happened to the rest of the region? They were left alone? e.g. the elites in Utica probably didn't mind the destruction of Carthage that much. However the core of the Carthaginian territory in North Africa was a collection of 'allied' cities dominated by Carthage (just like Roman Italy before the Social War). So there wasn't really much of a centralized system to keep in place (unlike in China and some other empires)