7 ms·
I wonder if the existence of a stable overclass of alexandrines distinct from the native population pre-prepared Egypt to be a Roman vassal state: it was alread
by ggm 4y ago
I wonder if the existence of a stable overclass of alexandrines distinct from the native population pre-prepared Egypt to be a Roman vassal state: it was already functioning as an analogous model, they just replaced the top set, but kept the governance model as-is.
Egypt was a breadbasket for Rome long before it was incorporated as were Tunisia and Sicily. I suspect "do not break the supply chain" was huge in not altering the governance
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoI think Egypt had been controlled by a foreign overclass since at least the Sea Peoples. Perhaps longer. The Nile is incredibly valuable but also very difficult to defend from invasion.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> I wonder if the existence of a stable overclass of alexandrines distinct from the native population pre-prepared Egypt to be a Roman vassal state: it was already functioning as an analogous model, they just replaced the top set, but kept the governance model as-is. No, those are two different phenomena. The piece notes that once the Romans took over the Greek elites immediately fused with the native elites. Any time anywhere with a functioning administration is conquered, the local administration is mostly left alone. The existing administration is already doing the job you want it to do; why would you change it? But it's not relevant (to this question) that the top level of the Ptolemaic administration was ethnically distinct.
- DoughnutHole 4y ago> Any time anywhere with a functioning administration is conquered, the local administration is mostly left alone. Not universally true - this presupposes that maximum economic output is the only goal of a conquering power. Conquering rulers are not always rational, or they may have other rational goals. The Mongols maintained the existing administrations wherever they submitted to them, but wherever they faced stiff resistance they wiped out the old power structures (and much of the population at large). In mesopotamia they even destroyed ancient, essential irrigation systems to an extent that the the region's productivity didn't recover for centuries. Even the Romans weren't always so conciliatory and rational - in conquering Carthage they sold the entire surviving population into slavery and destroyed the original city entirely. It wasn't exactly rare for them to choose to be brutal to make a point.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Even the Romans weren't always so conciliatory and rational - in conquering Carthage they sold the entire surviving population into slavery and destroyed the original city entirely. But Carthage wasn't just a city, it was a region. The city was sacked for standing up to Rome -- essentially the same policy the Mongols used. What happened to the rest of the region? Britain during and after the fall of Rome is worth considering here; it's similar and also different. Roman Britain was overrun by Germanic tribes and the system that resulted wasn't closely related to the system in place under the Romans. But I see that as related to the invasion being decentralized. It was more "a large number of small groups of people showing up" than "Genghis Khan showing up with his horde". We may have different ideas of what "the local administration is left in place" means. The Yongle emperor (Chinese) deposed his own nephew (also Chinese) and subsequently executed a very large share of the people who had been administrators (still Chinese) under the previous regime, along with their families. But the system of Chinese administration was left untouched by the mass executions. A slate of administrators was wiped out and replaced by very similar people doing very similar things.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWell all bureaucracies must do a very large number of very similar things regardless of location, culture, etc..
- thaumasiotes 4y agoYou might think so, but that just isn't true. There are a few core tasks, like tax collection, that have to be done everywhere. But even those core tasks are handled in very different ways from place to place. Questions like who is eligible to potentially be an administrator; how do they actually become one; what does the org chart look like; and what functions does the administration perform, all vary radically between different cultures.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoEvery military hierarchy in a sizeable country (> 10 million population), since WW1, has been organized almost identically except during the communist revolutions, and even then they reverted to the norm. I'm pretty certain there are close to optimal organizational structures for certain other functions as well, given the same standard human and technological limitations. Comparing two societies at different points in time would obviously yield much larger differences.
- ggm 4y agoSo which other Roman provinces had functioning civil service which was taken over? Parts of Greece I guess.
- DoughnutHole 4y agoItaly, Greece, Anatolia, the Levant, North Africa, parts of Spain, Crimea, and Armenia and mesopotamia for the brief period they controlled them. ie, the areas containing the vast majority of the population and economic productivity of the empire. Now, few of these regions had an overarching government or civil service - but they were all developed regions made up of various kingdoms, empires and city states, and each of those had their own elites and methods of economic management and tax collection. Egypt was pretty unique in its size, wealth, history and organisation, but in the vast majority of places they conquered the Romans worked with existing power structures and elites (where they didn't wipe them out).
- thaumasiotes 4y agoAs the piece notes, Gaul and Spain were in the very early stages of that process, but the rest of the empire - the areas to the south, southeast, east, and northeast of the Mediterranean - all did. Greece was a comparative newcomer. You can fruitfully think of administration as a phenomenon which originates in Egypt and Iraq and radiates outward from there.