9 ms·
No longer possible for the public to learn who owns a EU company
- r721 4y agoAnother thread (and article) on this topic: https://twitter.com/mattsteinglass/status/1598692892645597184 https://twitter.com/mattsteinglass/status/159869289264559718...
- betaby 4y agoMaking finding of the companies owned by Russian oligarch basically impossible. Regular pedestrians can no longer find the info, while gov agencies / bureaucrats have no interest. As usual, (un)intended consequences.
- betaby 4y agoAs the same time tax records and mailing addresses for the regular folks in Sweden (EU member) will continue to be open I suppose?
- amurf 4y agoUntil someone files a complaint at the same court.
- NoboruWataya 4y agoGiven that it's a Swedish law that only applies within Sweden, I wonder if the ECJ would take jurisdiction as there isn't really an EU element to it.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoDoes the ECJ only have jurisdiction over cases that cross national borders?
- M2Ys4U 4y agoSort of, in that the court's role is to be the authoritative interpreter of EU law, and EU law crosses national borders by definition. But all domestic law in EU member states must comply with EU law, so the court can rule on domestic law insofar as it is to determine compatibility with EU law.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoHow does it address the issue that all laws can conceivably affect trade, and other activities, across borders, via sufficient degrees of separation?
- lizardactivist 4y agoWhat a boon for the US conglomerates this would be.
- personomas 4y agoThe EU is going dramatically overboard with privacy rights (aka GDPR). It's causing a lot of dont-talk-to-your-neighbor-because-you-might-break-privacy-laws issues, and causing prices to rise across the board.
- eternityforest 4y agoAnd I kind of blame the tech community for it.
- nickpp 4y agoThe tech angle was just an excuse. The real reason was to protect old European money scared by the newcomers.
- eternityforest 4y agoMaybe partly, but I'm pretty sure it's grassroots. The tech community loves privacy and is willing to accept large amounts of cost and inconvenience for it, to the point of many appearing to view tech as a net negative due to the spying.
- nickpp 4y agoThe great majority of people do not care about "privacy" and gladly give it away for something as frivolous as Facebook or TikTok. So it wasn't a democratic process that gave birth to GDPR. Now tech is pretty underrepresented in EU, but old money is not.
- eternityforest 4y agoThe great majority of people in general, myself included, seem to not care about privacy all that much, although they say they do, and at least I personally care about right to encrypt and truthful advertising. The tech community is different though. And public perception of GDPR is heavily influenced by tech bloggers, hardly anyone else thinks or talks about this stuff. Could be all about old money, but programmers sure seem to love it.
- NKosmatos 4y agoOne of the stupid rulings in favor of EU oligarchs. Yes, EU oligarchs not Russian ones. They hide behind corporate entities, shell companies, shady legal operations and they claim GDPR for everything. Nowadays it’s very difficult to find out who is behind every company, but there’s an easy way to do it without violating sensitive info. Just publish the name(s) of the real owner without any other personal data (address, phone, DOB and so on).
- hypertele-Xii 4y ago> they claim GDPR for everything What does this mean?
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIt means the rich and corrupt people (they're lawyers) use the EU's strong data protection regulations to hide from the public knowing the extent of their wealth, businesses and influence.
- yrgulation 4y agoCar mileage criminals and official car dealers too. They hide behind gdpr to not reveal mileage, and accidents particularly on cars from germany.
- bennysonething 4y agoWhy is the EU doing this?
- ehvatum 4y agoSo that, next time, Gerhardt Schroeder can stay on the Gazprom board of directors in exchange for Russian ownership of German industry.
- M2Ys4U 4y agoBecause the EU, and specifically the Court of Justice in this instance, believes in having a strong human rights framework where the right to privacy is vital.
- chrismeller 4y agoFun fact, Estonia’s commercial register is still available and, as far as I can tell, never had anything to do with complying with EU regulation, but was completely internally legislated. Similar to the US federal law vs. states, one not enforcing it anymore doesn’t necessarily mean that the rest won’t keep doing it. https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng
- chrisandchris 4y agoQuedtion: What exactly is public in EU/Estonia? E.g. in Switzerland, one can see share holders of limited companies (GmbH) but not for Aktiengesellschaft (public companies).
- chrismeller 4y agoIn Estonia I believe anyone who holds more than 10% of shares has to be listed for a public company while private has to list everyone.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoDoesn't seem like it? I tried searching up some examples of subsidiaries of larger companies and the 'Beneficial Owners' section doesn't actually contain who ultimately owns the company. For example Toyota in Estonia: Toyota Baltic Aktsiaselts (10234087) https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/10234087?active_tab=register&wmsg=4163636573732064656e696564%7C2555e7f7fa5341d4747952e8acb93256 https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/10234087?active_tab=r... Has 1 board member listed. SIA Toyota Material Handling Baltic Eesti filiaal (11629379) https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/11629379/SIA-Toyota-Material-Handling-Baltic-Eesti-filiaal?search_id=e512344&pos=3&active_tab=register https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/11629379/SIA-Toyota-M... Has no one listed at all, which would be illegal?, if the law mandates it. Eesti Toyota Ühing (80226178) https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/80226178/Eesti-Toyota-Ühing?search_id=e512344&pos=2&active_tab=register https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/80226178/Eesti-Toyota... Has 3 board members listed.
- chrismeller 4y ago
- greatgib 4y agoIt is a difficult question, because on one side, sure it is very useful for citizen to have access to these info. But on the other side, I was always stunned that just because owning or operating a company, all your private info had to be public. These kind of registers are very bad for privacy rights. In all case, the worst thing with this decision about the UBO is that a lot of money laundering regulation and co force company to check UBO of customer and provider companies and it is complicated to request that all the time from companies themselves and ensure that the statement are truthfull.
- iudqnolq 4y agoI don't think people have a natural right to create a legal entity that shields them from consequences, so I think it's fine for society to add conditions. I think a reasonable compromise with privacy would be to remove the residential address and ID number, but keep name, DOB, and nationality.
- caslon 4y agoWhy should a person be forced to give their name? Plenty of HN users run internet businesses. Doesn't it suck that to deliver a service for anyone online commercially you have to dox yourself? Some of the best things in the world have been made by people who aren't willing to part with that information. What the EU has done is incredible.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- Aerroon 4y agoBut not every business is an LLC. They all go onto the register anyway. In some cases that includes self-employed people.
- seppel 4y agoThese registers are only for legal entities (at least in Germany). And it has nothing to do with doing business.