3 ms·
I don't know how you took that away from my simple sentence. You're like my wife that always reads "between the lines". You're also either building a strawman
by bad_user 15y ago
I don't know how you took that away from my simple sentence. You're like my wife that always reads "between the lines".
You're also either building a strawman or you're losing yourself in your own arguments to somehow reach your original point - interaction with a desktop computer, featuring a keyboard and mouse, also relies on "touch, sound, speech, vision and gestures" (again, stay off the weeds).
First of all, let me quote Wikipedia:
A common misunderstanding of the "Natural User
Interface" is that it is somehow mimicry of nature
or that some inputs to a computer are somehow
more 'natural' than others.
In truth things that feel "natural" to us are things that are familiar to us, just because we interacted with similar things before. If moving a box from one screen corner to another with our finger feels natural, that's only because we've been using our hands to move objects since forever. However, that doesn't mean a keyboard is not natural. Quite the contrary, because of repeated usage I can now type at 100 WPM, which is a speed that can't be matched with a touch-screen or speech recognition. I never think about the keyboard in front of me, but the on-screen keyboard on a tablet is definitely not "natural".
Touch-screens are not natural when you want to write text (a trait essential to humanity as a whole btw). Touch-screens are also not natural when you have complex interfaces with functions organized in a tree-structure. For example you can use a simple word-processor or a simple photo retouching app with a touch-screen, however, try imagining how Adobe Photoshop would "feel" on those tablets.
Bill Buxton, of Microsoft Research [2], says in his own essay "Multi-Touch Systems that I Have Known and Loved":
Everything is best for something and
worst for something else
Also, see this essay published by Don Norman in the ACM CHI magazine: "Natural User Interfaces Are Not Natural", which explains with detail how interactions based on touch aren't a panacea [1]
[1] http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/natural_user_interfaces_are_not_natural.html http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/natural_user_interfaces_are_not_na...
[2] http://www.billbuxton.com/multitouchOverview.html http://www.billbuxton.com/multitouchOverview.html