4 ms·
Remember though that if you are a smart poor person (here poor means not filthy rich) Harvard will give you a discount on tuition. I'm not sure how much or how
by bluGill 4y ago
Remember though that if you are a smart poor person (here poor means not filthy rich) Harvard will give you a discount on tuition. I'm not sure how much or how it works, but I'm under the impression that only a tiny minority actually pay the full price.
- dehrmann 4y agoSome pay more than the full price. Look up the "Dean's Interest List."
- jandrese 4y agoI'm not sure I'd spin this as a good thing. Smells a lot like "kid get surprisingly good grades after parents buy a new wing on the law building".
- dehrmann 4y agoIt's only a good thing if the school's goal is connecting the smartest with the richest.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoIt subsidizes everyone else's tuition, and is a critical piece of the value proposition for privates schools: access. By subsidizing the the poor-but-outstanding with money from the still-accepted rich-but-dumb, they maintain the opportunity for those two groups to intermingle, granting access to networks that that poorer students would be able to break into otherwise, which the rich also benefit from in the form of having known-competent individuals in their network. That's the primary reason to go to private school. That's what justifies the 2-4x price gap with public universities. All the niceties (not having to enter into a bi-yearly battle royal for seats in limited space classes, not having to put up with overly impacted class sizes, other little luxuries) are just there to maintain the appearance of prestige. The actual value comes from the admissions department.
- robocat 4y ago> It subsidizes everyone else's tuition I think that is a myth, unless the student is paying more than say $100k per year. Elsewhere I read that average fees were about $50k, but I presume there is quite some variation. Total operating expenses = $5.4 billion[1] Operating Revenue: Endowment income 36%, Education/Tuition 21%, Research 17%, Gifts 9%, Other 17%[1] The 21% Education/Tuition income is split: Degree Seeking Education 13%, and Continuing and Executive Education: 7%[3] Student income 1.2 billion[3] There are 30,391 students including 8,527 undergraduate and 21,864 graduate students at Harvard University for academic year 2020-2021. By attending status, there are 19,030 full-time and 11,361 part-time students[2] Assuming teaching the students costs 2.5 billion (rest is research costs) and 25000 full-time-equivalent students, then if each rich student pays enough to fully subsidise a second poor student, the rich student would need to pay $200k, and you trend towards a larger percentage of the students being rich. Argued from a different perspective (with a similar outcome): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33838201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33838201 [1] https://finance.harvard.edu/financial-overview https://finance.harvard.edu/financial-overview [2] https://www.univstats.com/colleges/harvard-university/student-population/ https://www.univstats.com/colleges/harvard-university/studen... [3] https://finance.harvard.edu/files/fad/files/fy22_harvard_financial_report.pdf https://finance.harvard.edu/files/fad/files/fy22_harvard_fin...
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoSure, but not all of the subsidized students are paying nothing. Plenty just get enough aid that it works out to being about even with going to a public university, but with the added benefit of a larger percentage of the students being rich (and generally getting a better educational experience). The fact that having those rich kids at the school is actually the primary value proposition for expensive private schools shifts the priorities substantially compared to a "the rich kids aren't paying enough to offset all the other students" rote accounting.
- robocat 4y agoI have reread your comment multiple times, and I am struggling to understand the purpose of both your comments, and the meaning of your recent reply eludes me. Are you are responding at all to the idea that “wealthier full-fee students are not subsidising other students at all”? The closest I can paraphrase your point-of-view would be “rich students are great”, or potentially that poor students gain by associating with rich students?