4 ms·
The Moon is a moon because the center of mass of the system is inside the Earth. It's as simple as that.
by ars 15y ago
The Moon is a moon because the center of mass of the system is inside the Earth. It's as simple as that.
- tzs 15y agoThat's a rather unsatisfactory way to define moon-hood, because it doesn't depend on any essential features of the two bodies. Replace Earth with something of the same mass but more dense, and the Moon gets promoted to planet, even though its size, shape, and orbit don't change? Yuck!
- mturmon 15y agoMore on this at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_planet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_planet
- dalke 15y agoand http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_satellite#The_definition_of_a_moon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_satellite#The_definitio...
- njm 15y agoBy being made more dense the Earth would shrink, so it is very reasonable to promote the Moon to planethood according to that definition.
- joshAg 15y agoI believe the center of mass for the earth moon system is something like 3000 km from the center of the earth (in a moonward direction). Just for reference, the radius of the earth is 6300 km. The density of the earth is ~5.52g/cc, and halving the radius of the earth will increase the density by 8 which gives a density of 44.16 g/cc or 44,160 kg/m^3, which is about twice the density of osmium and a third as dense as the center of the sun. In other words, the scenario you imagine is not practically possible in a system where one body is much larger than the other (if they're both about the same size, then it a dual planet system).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- johno215 15y agoI don't think this destroys your argument, but the barycenter of the Earth-Moon system is located, according to wikipedia [1], 4670 km from the center of the Earth. Interestingly, both the Pluto-Charon and the Sun-Jupiter systems have barycenters above the surface of the primary body. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barycentric_coordinates_(astronomy) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barycentric_coordinates_(astron...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- joshAg 15y agoseems i forgot to multiply by 1.6. whoops. pluto-charon (imo) is a dual dwarf-planet system not planet and moon. Sun Jupiter is my argument for why a planet shouldn't be defined only by barycenter location. updated density: 13.55g/cc. this is about the current density of the core of the earth now. It's about halfway between rhodium and mercury at STP, so not as horribly unlikely, but still pretty out there. Note: all density comparision made based on info from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Density#Densities_of_various_materials http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Density#Densities_of_various_ma...
- maaku 15y ago> Sun Jupiter is my argument for why a planet shouldn't be defined only by barycenter location. But Jupiter doesn't sustain nuclear fusion so it can't be considered in the same category as the sun. If it was a red/brown dwarf, then we would be in a binary system and that'd be a different story entirely.
- digitalsushi 15y agoI am so confused now. The center of mass of the solar system is often not inside the Sun.
- joshAg 15y agoi believe the center of mass is inside the sun if you look at each planet-sun pair individually. IOW, 2 body to n-body kind of messes this definition up. also, by inside the sun do you mean inside the corona?
- wisty 15y agoSo, if a star becomes a black hole, it's planets are no longer planets unless their COM is inside the event horizon?
- joshAg 15y agonope, not at all. the event horizon (schwarzschild radius) of the sun is 3km. i don't think planethood should be defined based on whether the barycenter of the system is within the orbited object, but I do think that's a pretty good definition for determining whether two objects are a planet moon pair or dual planets. this wikipedia entry hasa fairly good description: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_planet#Definition_of_a_double_planet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_planet#Definition_of_a_dou... but in case you con't want to follow, here's a summary: dual planet system (eg pluto charon): barycenter lies outside of either object planet with moon (eg earth and moon): barycenter lies within the radius of the planet planet: "(a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and (c) has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit[1]." [2] as for why planethood shouldn't be determined by barycenter location alone: "If the definition of a double- or binary-star system is used as a comparison, and it depended only on the location of the barycenter, then any revolving body with a barycenter beneath a star's surface would be a planet, and any body with a barycenter lying outside the surface of the star would be another star. In the Solar System, all of the major planets would be planets under this definition except one. The Sun–Jupiter barycenter is the only center of mass that lies outside the surface of the Sun. Therefore, since Jupiter is not a star, the difficulty faced by astronomers to derive a reality-based definition of double planet begins to become clear." [3] [1]: meaning it has become gravitationally dominant, and there are no other bodies of comparable size other than its own satellites or those otherwise under its gravitational influence. [2]: IAU [3]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_planet#Definition_of_a_double_planet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_planet#Definition_of_a_dou...