3 ms·
Who gets to decide what is or isn't a joke? I assume you'd be okay with Twitter (and other forms of media) banning right-wing politicians and groups in the USA
by paxys 4y ago
Who gets to decide what is or isn't a joke?
I assume you'd be okay with Twitter (and other forms of media) banning right-wing politicians and groups in the USA that associate with Nazis and fly Nazi flags at their rallies? Or those who call for Jewish people to be exterminated? Except no, everyone was up in arms about Twitter and liberals doing just that pre-Musk, because "free speech". Banning Kanye a month ago was the worst thing in the world, and today it's completely justified (despite the fact that he is posting much milder stuff). Funny how the conversation has turned now, and everything Musk does is justified using whatever mental gymnastics is necessary.
- nailer 4y ago> fly Nazi flags at their rallies? Or those who call for Jewish people to be exterminated Yes. I would support this ban for same reason I support Kanye being banned. > associate with Nazis I don’t support guilt by association. Punish people that do bad things not people that talk to people that do bad things. > Except no, everyone was up in arms about Twitter and liberals doing just that pre-Musk No they weren’t. They were pissed off about political bans not bans on racial violence. I mentioned an example earlier in this thread. I don’t think you listen to people that you perceive to be your opponents. Edit (can’t reply due to rate limit): I don’t think Kanye should have been reinstated after “death con 3” - please, if you want to know my opinion on something, just ask rather than assuming.
- paxys 4y ago> Yes. I would support this ban for same reason I support Kanye being banned. Twitter banned Kanye for exactly this, were heavily criticized for it, and Musk reinstated him when he took over. So what is different now? If anything his recent tweets are milder (remember going "death con 3 on jewish people")? And why is trans hate okay but Jewish hate grounds for an instant ban?
- ss108 4y agoI am on your side generally, but are you labelling "men are not women" (or w/e) hate speech? I think this is the sort of thing that poses a problem; that's basically a position on a controversial issue. It's not hate speech anymore than saying "There is no God" is hate speech against religious people.
- assbuttbuttass 4y agoI think a closer equivalent would be saying "marriage is between a man and a woman"
- ss108 4y agoI disagree; I think saying God doesn't exist is much closer. Some people have a subjective belief God exists. Some of them admit it is subjective, others assert that God objectively exists. People who do not believe in God typically say no, it's not subjective, and, as a descriptive matter, we have no evidence God exists, etc. Similarly, some people believe gender is subjective, and that people can "be" another gender if they feel like it (if I am getting this wrong lmk; it's obviously a simplistic statement of that position). Others believe the question is purely objective and determined by observable biology--i.e. "it's not subjective, and as a descriptive matter, you are x gender". In contrast, "marriage is between a man and a woman" is basically purely normative. It is not a statement about what "is". It is a statement about what should be.
- assbuttbuttass 4y ago"Trans people exist" is an objective statement of fact (though some people would say it's just a "choice"). But also, "trans women are women" is normative, since it seeks to prescribe how trans people are treated by society.
- ethanbond 4y agoToday's hate speech is yesterday's "position on a controversial issue." (I don't think this is a simple question at all, but this particular tack is not as sound as it might appear. There was a time not so long ago that vitriolic antisemitism, even in the US and western Europe, was pretty much the consensus view.)