4 ms·
As an employee and an employer, I like having only one type of paid leave. It should not matter to the employer why an employee is not working. If the issue i
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
As an employee and an employer, I like having only one type of paid leave.
It should not matter to the employer why an employee is not working.
If the issue is insufficient time off for illnesses, then the negotiation should be for more paid time off (PTO) in general.
This eliminates all the resources wasted on catching fraudulent use of sick days.
- actionfromafar 4y agoWouldn't that create an incentive to run your employees so hard they develop health issues? No skin off your back, just get a new employee when the first gets permanently broken. I'm cheeky, but I think that is one of the rationales for having sick leave at all.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHow would they run you hard if you have sufficient PTO? California requires overtime after 8 hours of work per day and on the 7th consecutive day. If that is not enough, make overtime cost 2x. Lots of ways to ensure employers do not run employees hard without getting into details of sick days and whatnot.
- actionfromafar 4y agoGlad you asked in earnest! I was thinking more about work environment, possibly bullying etc etc, anything harsh on the body and mind. Of course your system could be setup to a working level, but you'd need more of other controls or incentives to rectify the kinds of problems which can lead to work related health issues.
- JohnFen 4y agoI agree. My employers over the last couple of decades have just had a general PTO amount. But for that to work, two other things have to go with it: the PTO amount has to be enough time to cover both uses, and there still has to be a mechanism that allows for unplanned time off. The true cruelty of "no sick days" isn't that employees have to burn vacation days, it's that vacation days have to be scheduled in advance and approved. Neither of those things leave room for sudden illness or injury, and prioritizes company schedule needs over things like scheduling doctor's visits.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoPerhaps this is solved by requiring all accrued PTO to be paid out, and by requiring a minimum of X number of days where you can call out? States with sick leave policies have stipulations like these: https://www.lni.wa.gov/workers-rights/_docs/ReasonableNoticeUsePaidSickLeaveSamplePolicy.docx https://www.lni.wa.gov/workers-rights/_docs/ReasonableNotice...
- JohnFen 4y agoWhere I've worked, this was addressed somewhat loosely. You have PTO. You commit to scheduling time off in advance to the greatest degree you can. The employer commits to accommodating those requests to the greatest degree they can. If you need to miss work unexpectedly, you do so. The employer just trusts your judgement that it's necessary. If it's going to be more than a day or two, you are expected to talk with your employer and explain what's up -- mostly so the employer can adjust assignments and schedules with a better understanding of what to expect. Do some employees abuse that? Sure. But, in my experience, that's rare and the people doing it are usually poor workers anyway. They can be handled through whatever the normal review mechanisms are. This is my most common experience. I don't know how common it actually is, and I'm sure other situations would require different, perhaps more formal, procedures. But it's worked well in the places I've worked.
- ragingrobot 4y agoI suppose the employee can opt to take fewer planned vacation days, reserving the balance for unplanned absences. This would require the balance to be rolled over, or the employee compensated at the end of the year or other period, otherwise it would make employees unhappy. Perhaps a mechanism that allows for unplanned time off, with a little education on how to properly plan PTO to allow for unplanned leave.
- Avshalom 4y agoTechnically they have PTO, but it has to be scheduled, and may not be approved, a month in advance. Which is unworkable for almost anything.
- naasking 4y agoSeems fine in theory, but the types of leave are different. Vacation can be anticipated and scheduled but sick days cannot. If you mandate a certain number of paid days off, you still need to require that some percentage of those days can be taken with no notice. In other words, you're still making the distinction between sick days and vacation days, you're just not using those labels, which seems unnecessarily confusing.
- adolph 4y ago> When an employee calls out sick, a Special Inspector may be sent to their home to check if they are really sick and at home. If the label between sick and vacation is meaningful, are "Special Inspectors" needed to ensure people are sick when taking a sick day?
- pwg 4y agoThe one issue here is that in many industries, the use of "vacation days" is, per the labor contract, required to be scheduled in advance. Often quite some time in advance. Which makes use of "vacation days" for unexpected illnesses (went to bed last night and felt fine, woke up this morning to fever and chills) difficult to impossible if the requirement for "advance scheduling" is actually enforced. In many jobs with separate vacation and sick days, the vacation days still require the "advance notice" for scheduling, but the sick days do not require that one know, days in advance, of an unexpected illness. That gives the employee a few days that can be used for unexpected things, and the employer some assurance that a maximum of X days of unexpected outages will occur per employee. More often than not, the "only one type of paid leave" comes attached with the "requirement for advance scheduling" of those same days, which does not provide for the unexpected illness situations.
- Mezzie 4y agoThe one thing about this that sucks is that if you have a chronic illness, you end up using all your PTO as sick and you get no actual breaks. (Whereas if you run out of sick days you can use FMLA or short term disability without giving up all of your vacation or holidays).