Well, you just described the point of product red and why it is not irrelevant just because there are "proper" charities. 1 they manage to collaborate with bi

Well, you just described the point of product red and why it is not irrelevant just because there are "proper" charities. 1 they manage to collaborate with big names like Apple that create products in demand, 2 they make sure the color is not ugly, 3 they make sure you don't pay more. If not for product red Y-bar may not have donated to HIV/AIDS cause at all. Same for me, I always buy product red if device is available because why not, I don't care about the color much.