4 ms·
> I think it's sad that Apple doesn't even give attribution to any of the authors. Pretty much like Stable Diffusion and the grifters using it in general and t
by rvz 4y ago
> I think it's sad that Apple doesn't even give attribution to any of the authors.
Pretty much like Stable Diffusion and the grifters using it in general and they will never credit the artists and images that they stole to generate these images.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoDo your point is that Apple and those grifters are equally reputable? two wrongs don't make a right.
- rvz 4y agoI'm neither defending Apple or the grifters using Stable Diffusion in my comment. Both are as bad as each other, giving no attribution or credit.
- astrange 4y agoThis is sort of like if you learned English from reading a book and the author said they owned all your English sentences after that. Of course you can see the original images (https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/ https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/), it was legal to collect them (they used robots.txt for consent just like Google Image Search) and it was legal to do this with them (but not using US legal principles since it's made in Germany). "Crediting the artist" isn't a legal principle - it's more like some kind of social media standard which is enforced by random amateur artists yelling at you if you don't do it. It's both impossible (there are no original artists for a given output) and wouldn't do anything to help the main social issue (future artists having their jobs taken by AIs).
- pmarreck 4y ago> future artists having their jobs taken by AIs that's simply not going to happen. as in every technological development so far, this is just another tool. 1) artists create the styles out of thin air 2) artists create the images out of thin air 3) computers are just collectors of this data and do not actually originate anything new. they are just very clever copycats. you're looking at an artist tool more than anything. sure, it's an unconventional one and a threatening one, but that's been true of literally every technological development since the Industrial Revolution.
- astrange 4y ago> that's simply not going to happen. I don't think it will either, but artists think it will, so it's strange that their proposed solution "credit the original artists behind AI models" won't solve the problem they have with it.
- athrowaway12 4y ago4) If computers get good enough at 1) or 2), then there'd be much bigger problems, and essentially all humans will become the starving artists. Also, I'm not so sure that language models like SD, Imagen, GPT-3, PaLM are purely copycats. And I'm not so sure that most human artists are not mostly copycats either. My suspicion is that there's much more overlap between how these models work and what artists do (and how humans think in general), but that we elevate creative work so much that it's difficult to admit the size of the overlap. The reason why I lean this way is because of the supposed role of language in the evolution of human cognition (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_language https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origin_of_language) And the reason I'm not certain that the NN-based models are purely copycats is they have internal state; they can and do perform computations, invent algorithms, and can almost perform "reasoning". I'm very much a layperson but I found this "chains of thought" approach (https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/05/language-models-perform-reasoning-via.html https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/05/language-models-perform-re...) very interesting, where the reasoning task given to the model is much more explicit. My guess is that some iterative construction like this will be the way the reasoning ability of language/image models will improve. But at a high level, the only thing we humans have going for us is the anthropic principle. Hopefully there's some magic going on in our brains that's so complicated and unlikely that no one will ever figure out how it works. BTW, I am a layperson. I am just curious when we will all be killed off by our robot overlords.
- pmarreck 4y ago> and essentially all humans will become the starving artists all of these assumptions miss something so huge that it surprises me that so many miss it: WHO is doing the art purchasing? WHO is evaluating the "value" of... well... anything, really? It is us. Humans. Machines can't value anything properly (example: Find an algorithm that can spot, or create, the next music hit, BEFORE any humans hear it). Only humans can, because "things" (such as artistic works, which are barely even "things", much more like "arbitrary forms" when considered objectively/from the universe's perspective) only have meaning and value to US. > when we will all be killed off by our robot overlords We won't. Not unless those robots are directed or programmed by humans who have passionate, malicious intent. Because machines don't have will, don't have need, and don't have passion. Put bluntly and somewhat sentimentally, machines don't have love (or hate), except that which is simulated or given by a human. So it's always ultimately the human's "fault".
- 55555 4y agoThe artist(s) are normally cited. Just download any Stable Diffusion -made image and look at the PNG info / metadata and you'll see "Greg Rutkowski" (lol) in the prompt.
- astrange 4y agoThat proves nothing except someone decided to say his name to an AI. He basically isn’t in SD’s training set! You can look it up. It seems that he works coincidentally because CLIP associates his name with concept art.
- wellthisisgreat 4y ago> Of course you can see the original images (https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/ https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/) In fairness this is an obscure Github page that <0.001% of people will be aware of. If creators of all these AI generating tools sat down and thought of consequences the author's names could have been watermarked by default and the license required to keep it unless allowed by the author for for example. there clearly was no thought around mitigating any of these problems and we are having what we are having now with the storm around "robots taking artist's jobs" which they may (at least for some 90% of "artists" who are just rehashing existing styles) or may not, only time will tell.
- gcanyon 4y agoAdam Neely discusses this from the standpoint of music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAFUdIZnI5o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAFUdIZnI5o He equates it to sandwich recipes: there are only so many ways to make a sandwich, and it's silly to think of copyrighting "a ham sandwich with gouda, lettuce, and dijon mustard."