4 ms·
"A brand raising awareness on <topic>" to me reads "an artificial brand to create market segmentation and publicity, possibly for tax avoidance reasons." Becau
by sph 4y ago
"A brand raising awareness on <topic>" to me reads "an artificial brand to create market segmentation and publicity, possibly for tax avoidance reasons."
Because when people see Product Red written somewhere, they Google it, and it's not like they're going "ah, yes, AIDS. It's still a thing isn't it?"
It's just a vehicle to drive sales. Because the only effect it has is suckers that really care about AIDS giving more money to Product Red.
> "Product Red has been criticized for not having an effect proportional to the advertising investment, for being much less efficient than direct charitable contribution, and for having a lack of transparency"
- irjustin 4y ago> It's just a vehicle to drive sales. I'll bite - Why is this a problem? Let's assume (Red) is using funds properly (not going to touch that). If selling products that carve out a portion of profits get donated then isn't this great? > Because the only effect it has is suckers that really care about AIDS giving more money to Product Red. If more money is going to the right causes why the holier-than-art-thou thought process. It was the same criticism with the ice bucket challenge. "people don't care about ALS..." "nor about <fit your cause here>". It gets more money into good causes. If <said thing> didn't exist, they'd have less money.
- Vinnl 4y agoSee also "The Copenhagen interpretation of ethics": https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-ethics/ https://blog.jaibot.com/the-copenhagen-interpretation-of-eth...
- nickpp 4y agoOh this is a beautiful concept - I didn't know about it. Explains so much. Thank you!
- hoosieree 4y agoI'm afraid to respond saying how thought provoking that article is, because then I might be on the hook to actually do something to make the world a better place.
- jmpman 4y agoNice article, but sounds like it was written by an Uber product manager justifying their decision for surge pricing. My cynical view is that Uber predominantly benefits from surge pricing, and they pass the minimal amount on to their drivers, drenching their disadvantaged potential passengers with much higher prices.
- squeaky-clean 4y ago> If <said thing> didn't exist, they'd have less money The "Criticisms" portion of the article has one response to this sort of argument. Most of Red's aid is in the form of purchasing pharmaceutical treatments for those who need it. It sounds good in the short term, but it's essentially a private subsidy to the pharmaceutical companies and an excuse to keep drug prices high and not bother with government pricing regulations or government funded treatment programs. The argument is that the money could be better spent on lobbying for government aid and price limits.
- gambiting 4y ago>>The argument is that the money could be better spent on lobbying for government aid and price limits. By whose judgement? If someone comes to me and asks for money for their medical treatment, of course I'm going to give them it. They need it now, I'm going to help. Or are we going to argue that this money that I spent would have been better off donated to an organisation that lobbies government for regulating medicine prices(while the person who needs help now suffers because they aren't getting the meds). It just strikes me as such armchair judgement of the situation(not you personally, I mean the general criticism around this).
- marcinzm 4y ago>The argument is that the money could be better spent on lobbying for government aid and price limits. So it's better for lobbyists to get the money to encourage pharma companies to increase US prices to give Africa free doses? I don't see how that is a better use of the money. Now you've spent twice as much money on this. Once for lobbyists and then again from US price increases and pharma companies make just as much in the end.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThe idea that there's some kind of globally-optimizing resource allocation for altruism and that you're open to criticism for failing to adhere to someone's line on it is just so fucked up.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoMy interpretation of the ice-bucket challenge criticism was that it had a lot of people dunking ice buckets on their heads on social media; but it is unclear how many wrote checks instead (or as well). At least in this case there's pretty clearly money flowing to the cause rather than just teenagers doing teenager stuff on social media with added warm fuzzies.
- Y-bar 4y ago> Because the only effect it has is suckers that really care about AIDS giving more money to Product Red. Guess I am one of those. I bought a Red iPhone 8 a few years ago for the following reasons: 1. I had to get a phone for my new job. 2. I liked the colour. 3. It was the same price as non-Red models. 4. It happened to send a few dollars towards a good cause which would not have been sent if I had bought the regular colour product. I'm apparently a sucker who would rather give a little than nothing at all.
- dontlaugh 4y agoI also got a red iPhone because I liked the look. I doubt the money does anything to help anyone, even if it is actually donated.
- Y-bar 4y ago> anyone If you want but a single data point Apple yesterday highlighted a woman who got tested through a Red-funded clinic, and because she was tested early, she could also be treated and give birth to a HIV-free baby.
- pavlov 4y agoIt's also worth reminding people just how amazingly successful medical science has been in solving the HIV health disaster. A multi-year untreated infection would have been a death sentence still in the mid-1990s, but today we can routinely treat these cases to a level where the virus is undetectable. Something that people also tend to forget is that there was a strong HIV-AIDS denialist movement. In the 1990s a lot of regular people and also some scientists were convinced that HIV doesn't cause AIDS, despite accumulating evidence to the contrary. Nobel Prize winner Kary Mullis was involved in this conspiracy-minded movement. The president of South Africa was also convinced, which caused thousands of unnecessary deaths in the country where HIV spread like wildfire at the time. When somebody tries to argue that Covid-19 or climate change are fake based on the views of a single doctor or other scientist, I point at Kary Mullis. The HIV-AIDS denialists even had a magazine, but it ceased publication in 2001 when all the editors had died of AIDS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_(magazine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_(magazine)
- s_dev 4y agoIt doesn't just raise brand awareness but reduces stigma. By associating a disease with high end products like premium iPhones etc people are likely to feel less threatened by the disease.
- sph 4y agoIt's a good theory, but I'd have a very hard time telling if it's concrete effect or just wishful thinking.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoMy iPhone has this “product red” branding on it and it kind of annoys me. Im always skeptical of these kinds of branding/marketing for a cause type things but I just wanted a red iPhone…
- tomatotomato37 4y agoI don't really care if it's internally some tax dodge or sales strategy if it serves as an opportunity to bring color back to a world dominated by monochromatic colors and brushed aluminum. The donation to a good cause is just an added bonus.
- some_random 4y agoSample size one but I've seen Product Red multiple times before and had no clue it was about AIDS.