2 ms·
...obviously there needs to be demand for whatever the workers are going to do. There is demand. I'm willing to pay someone $10/hour to clean my house. My star
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
...obviously there needs to be demand for whatever the workers are going to do.
There is demand. I'm willing to pay someone $10/hour to clean my house. My startup would love to employ fashionable girls for mechanical turk work at wages far below the US minimum wage (we employ several of them in India). So how come unemployment exists at all?
Keynesian economics postulates wage stickiness as an explanation for this unemployment.
That is why I say that you need to be able to break contracts too - then whole economy would need to be able to realign in a very short period of time to match the effects the spending can have in the same period of time.
This is not Keynesian economics. This is a structural theory of recessions - things have changed, and the economy needs time to re-adjust. I.e., a former construction worker in CA needs time and training to find a new job, the business owner needs to renegotiate contracts or go bankrupt, etc.
Note that in structural theories, monetary or fiscal stimulus has no clear effect, and government spending/austerity measures should focus on getting fundamentals right (i.e., eliminate wasteful spending) and speeding up adjustment (promoting job mobility).
Do you have another way that would work and quickly that I am not seeing?
The easiest would be cutting the pay of government workers, cuts to payroll taxes (particularly the employer side), and reducing unemployment benefits and welfare.
Another method would deal with unions. If any union refuses an immediate cut in total comp, the employer gains the right to fire union workers and permanently replace them with non-union workers.
But if you accept my premise that this is the path and believe the unions are too powerful then wage stickiness is a moot point - as a non-starter why bother discussing it, Keynesian or not?
Intellectual curiosity, mostly. So far, I've only seen a single Keynesian (Karl Smith) actively promote wage flexibility, in spite of the fact that it's a logical conclusion of the theory.
It's also relevant to this discussion - Greece has absolutely no ability to prevent austerity (they run at a budget deficit, even ignoring interest/debt service), but they do have the ability to promote wage flexibility within their own borders.
- JamisonM 15y agoFrom your specific suggestions I think what you are advocating is employing the Keynesian economic model in a way compatible with a libertarian belief in markets. Nobody in the mainstream believes that, that is why you are not seeing it and it is not a practical route. Krugman does discuss that the only way in the current situation to get wages down is deflation, which he does not regard as quick enough (or a humane way to solve the problem). I suspect the Keynesian model would probably perform pretty well if the suggestions you make were undertaken. The demand that suddenly disappears when such a large section of the population has their wages cut drastically plus the fear that it could be cut again at any time with no notice would seem to me to do a lot to offset the demand created by being able to employ a Spanish employee at $1/hour. I'm not a big believer in libertarian ideas so I think that it would probably be a disaster for society as a whole, but that is a debate for another place and time.