3 ms·
I read English (my native language) and Chinese (my undergraduate major subject). I have been reading articles about reading speed of second-language speakers o
by tokenadult 15y ago
I read English (my native language) and Chinese (my undergraduate major subject). I have been reading articles about reading speed of second-language speakers of Chinese since my first year of study of the language, back in the 1970s. There is a very strong impression among persons who read both languages that reading Chinese is faster, but the experimental finding, over and over over, is that for a given reliable level of comprehension, reading speed does NOT differ in a way that favors Chinese for most bilingual readers, whether their first language is Chinese or their first language is English.
The late John DeFrancis, who through his innovative textbooks was the first teacher of a whole generation of Americans who succeeded in acquiring Chinese as a second language, was a co-founder of the Journal of the Chinese Language Teachers Association, and author of a fascinating article titled "Why Johnny Can't Read Chinese." The Chinese writing system (no matter which form of the spoken language, ancient or modern, it is applied to) is full of ambiguities and other partially cued information that slows down reading--as is every other writing system in the world. By dint of much practice, I can read Chinese comfortably for information on a variety of subjects. By test, I was one of the most proficient readers of Chinese among second-language learners who participated in the norming rounds for a Test of Chinese as a Second Language in the mid-1980s (which I think was never rolled out into regular use, perhaps because it showed that most learners learned more Chinese from overseas residence than from taking university courses in Chinese).
Hacker News readers who would like to learn about English, Chinese, or other writing systems would be well advised to read the specialized articles in The World's Writing Systems
http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-Writing-Systems-Peter-Daniels/dp/0195079930 http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-Writing-Systems-Peter-Daniels/d...
edited by Peter T. Daniels and William Bright. The article on Chinese is very good, and the overview articles that discuss general features of writing systems are also very good.
- donw 15y agoI'm interested in reading the articles, but $200 to get ahold of them in an out-of-print-book is a bit steep. Any other sources that you could recommend by chance?
- Jun8 15y agoThe book's not out of print, here's the link to OUP: http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Linguistics/?view=usa&ci=9780195079937 http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Linguistics/?v.... You can get it used from Amazon or wait until OUP has their seasonal sales, which happened 3-4 times a year. I bought my copy at one of these sales for around $60. This is an excellent, authoritative resource on the subject.
- blacksmythe 15y ago>> most learners learned more Chinese from overseas residence than from taking university courses in Chinese No surprise there. It is hard to learn a foreign language to a high level of fluency without constant background exposure.
- dextorious 15y agoMost Europeans learn English (as a foreign language) without a "constant background exposure". And in my country, most people learn German and French (two popular choices for a second/third language) without constant background exposure, too. So the fact that "most learners learned more Chinese from overseas residence" is a surprise.
- jff 15y agoSimply living in the modern world gives you a constant background exposure to English.
- dextorious 15y agoNot really --you have to tune in to that, too. I personally met people in California that speak spanish (mexican immigrants), who don't seem to care about learning english all that much, despite living in the US for a decade or so. That is because of the large spanish speaking community there. Even more so in a country where english is not the native language. You can just ignore the "constant background exposure". It's not like Lady Gaga being in the charts means people also pay attention to what exactly she sings. Even for US movies European countries either use subtitles or have the dialogs spoken in the native language (the second option sucks, btw).
- jerf 15y agoYes. I "learned" French for four years in high school with no constant background exposure. Of course, I can't actually speak it, or read it, or write it, or understand more than very basic conversation in it (though as it turns out I have actually understood a smidge of French "in the wild"). But I did pass a test in it, once. On my eternal TODO list is to use a spaced-repetition drilling program to buff up my French vocabulary since I do pretty much have everything else I need to at least read it, but, well, like many around here my TODO list is quite long....
- pradocchia 15y agoAha! "The World's Writing Systems" looks suspiciously like another book I have, "Grammatology" (not the one by Derrida). Published in the 90s and similarly priced, but out of print as far as I know. Who wrote the chapter on Chinese?
- tokenadult 15y agoWho wrote the chapter on Chinese [in The World's Writing Systems]? http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Linguistics/?view=usa&ci=9780195079937#Product_Details http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Linguistics/?v... I'm pretty sure it's by William G. Boaltz http://depts.washington.edu/asianll/people/faculty/boltzwm.html http://depts.washington.edu/asianll/people/faculty/boltzwm.h... whose papers about ancient Chinese are full of surprising details, with insight into how the current writing system developed historically.