4 ms·
> Your data is (mostly) safe from advertisers because that's not their business. I beg to differ. Apple is becoming an ad company despite privacy claims http
by satvikpendem 4y ago
> Your data is (mostly) safe from advertisers because that's not their business.
I beg to differ.
Apple is becoming an ad company despite privacy claims
https://proton.me/blog/apple-ad-company https://proton.me/blog/apple-ad-company
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33736259 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33736259
- marricks 4y agoBoth your links go to the same Proton article and the heart of it seems to be this: > Apple monitors your every move in the App Store and its News and Stocks apps and then uses that data to sell ads targeting you in those same apps. To meet its growth forecasts, experts expect Apple to start selling ads in its Maps, Podcast, and Books apps, meaning it could replicate this model across more of its services. Much more of your activity could be monitored in the future. Tracking every click in the App Store/News/Stocks is not great but it is in NO WAY similar to tracking every website I view and reading every email I send.
- satvikpendem 4y agoWhy do you assume Apple doesn't also track every website and email you read (especially if you use the default Apple-made apps)? After all, they make the OS, they can track whatever they want.
- majormajor 4y agoNobody's reported seeing that sort of network traffic sent off of iOS devices. It's trivially easy to spot it, and it's well documented, going to Google and others across the web, though.
- mortehu 4y agoOn my iPhone, Safari browser history synchronization to iCloud was enabled by default.
- musicale 4y agoAccording to Apple, Safari history and bookmarks are end-to-end encrypted and Apple cannot read them: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 Is there any evidence that Apple is lying, and is actually decrypting them somehow and using them for advertising purposes, rather than for the "coherence" feature? I don't actually want browsing sessions to be unified across devices, so I do wish that it was turned off by default. (Though being able to close tabs remotely is a sort of interesting capability.) However, it doesn't seem to be actual spyware used for advertising or tracking purposes.
- pyuser583 4y agoThat’s not what your link says. The link says browsing history is end-to-end encrypted, but Bookmarks are not.
- acomjean 4y agoSafari on iOS is auto-completing stuff as you type. The option to search with google comes up if you get far enough. And it’s not going to google first. If you type an address the “link” at the top is to Apple Maps. They seem to do a similar thing with place names. I’m not sure but one can be fairly certain they’re using the phones location to help….
- heavyset_go 4y agoYou will have no idea what is being carried via encrypted channels to Apple's opaque backend servers.
- manigandham 4y ago> " It's trivially easy to spot" Is it? How exactly are encrypted payloads to a secure, opaque and generic endpoint easy to distinguish?
- majormajor 4y agoIt's trivially easy to spot it going to Google/FB/whoever if you visit a page with a GA or FB or whatever pixel. That's part of the second sentence, not the first. For spotting it going to Apple you'd have to do more fancy correlation over time and such, but you can find people out there who are researching this stuff... so that's who I'm waiting for to hear more from.
- chrononaut 4y agoBurden of proof fallacy
- piyush_soni 4y agoPeople keep saying Google reads your emails (even when Google explicitly says otherwise), but have no proof, and trust Apple's words as the gospel of truth - how strange. It's almost as if it's fashionable to criticize them. This is on Gmail's homepage: "We never use your Gmail content for any ads purposes. Gmail uses industry-leading encryption for all messages you receive and send. We never use your Gmail content to personalize ads."
- roody15 4y agoInteresting.. I just saw an add in my Apple Maps yesterday and I was really confused at first. Had no idea they are considering moving in this direction and must already be testing it. On a different note I attended an apple event for IT Government and Education in Chicago. Eye opening.. Apple's "privacy" stance is all just a horse and pony show for marketing. Unbelievable how open they were about tracking everything at the event.
- davidlumley 4y agoMy understanding around how this works (and I might be wrong!) is that Apple tracks a variety of usage on device and your device itself knows which ad to serve, versus say Google or Facebook collating your data on their own servers. I'd not be surprised to learn there was some level of phoning home though.
- bb88 4y agoI have no idea if this is true, but let's say it is. The ad still has to come from a server, unless the phone downloads all possible ads the person might be interested in (which I doubt). The transfer would at a minimum include the IP address of the phone.
- 7e 4y agoUse a shuffler.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoThere’s a common misconception that ad tracking is all about targeting ads. That’s part of it, but the truth is that tracking conversions is a more important differentiator for advertising platforms. A conversion is where the user clicks on the ad and then makes a purchase. The top digital ad companies (Apple, Google, Meta, Amazon) all charge for conversions. There is no way to charge for conversions without sending data about the user’s behavior off the device (which ads they saw, and which purchases they made).
- 7e 4y agoThat’s not true. They could use differentially private on-device joins using anonymously downloaded ad data. Or they could securely aggregate the results. Or both.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoCan you elaborate? I see an ad in the News app, then click on it and make a purchase from Clash of Clans in the App Store. Apple needs to charge Clash of Clans for the conversion. How do they do it? Apple knows that I bought the app (they charged me for it). In order to charge Clash of Clans for the conversion, my phone needs to connect to Apple and send them a record of the ad click. What if clicking on that ad and buying the app are the only thing I ever did on the phone? There’s nothing to aggregate locally, and Apple knows they got the conversion data from me. Perhaps the claim is that my phone is going to send all these records to Apple, and Apple is just going to do the right thing and run programs that do the business without letting any of their people look at anything they aren’t supposed to look at (they could internally accomplish this by differential privacy, rigorous internal controls, etc). That’s the same claim Google and everyone else is going to make.