5 ms·
While I'm sure no one will care to enforce it, such an arrangement still puts you in violation of your visa status. If you aren't working full time and don't ev
by paxys 4y ago
While I'm sure no one will care to enforce it, such an arrangement still puts you in violation of your visa status. If you aren't working full time and don't even have network access, you are out of H-1B eligibility, regardless of whether you are on someone's payroll or not.
- mynameisvlad 4y agoYeah, unless they're trying to get a specific person out and using it as an excuse, nobody is going to look any further than that end date.
- bee_rider 4y agoI don’t know anything about this, so I bet you are right (and hope you are!) I do have to wonder if it would have been better to just not mention it, though. Could highlighting their (light, and well-intentioned) rule breaking invite enforcement?
- mynameisvlad 4y agoI don't think agents are paid well enough to care this much about any particular company unless one of their higher ups told them to. And the higher ups aren't going to care about what will likely be less than 100 people, at least some of which will get jobs within 60 days, and who overall are not trying to game the system even if it's technically what they're doing. In other words, I'm pretty sure they all have better things to do.
- 22SAS 4y ago>While I'm sure no one will care to enforce it Pretty right. In the HFT world, we have people going on non-competes all the time. During that time, most firms do not pull their visa petition from USCIS, pay continues every two weeks and the employee is still technically an employee of the firm, just that they're on garden leave. This is done by firms so that the employees do not have to leave the US during their non-compete. They're not doing any work, so technically still counts as a visa status violation.
- triyambakam 4y agoWhat does it mean to go on non-compete or garden leave?
- 22SAS 4y agoA lot of the stuff in trading firms is proprietary and pretty secretive like trading strategies, how their systems achieve some level of latency, if they have FPGA/HW teams then what are their capabilities like. When an employee resigns to go to another trading firm, to ensure that they don't leave right away and use the secret sauce at their new firm, they put that employee on a non-compete or a garden leave. Basically, for a period of time, could be as little as 2-3 months to 2 years, that employee can either sit at home or go work in an industry that is not trading but for that duration they cannot work in the same industry. The logic is that strategies and systems change pretty frequently, so in that time whatever knowledge that employee has, becomes outdated. If they decide to sit at home, to make it lucrative, most firms will pay their base salary for that period, or some percentage of total comp (base+bonus). Since the employee is getting paid to do nothing, almost nobody in trading has any issues with non-competes. While this is pretty awesome, it is a pain in the butt for a visa holder making such a transition. Technically, to remain in status a visa worker has to also be performing the duties on their petition, so even if they get paid during non-compete it can lead for them to leave the US. Since this is not as simple to enforce and not rigorously checked, their previous employer does not revoke their petition till they start at their new firm. Since the workers petition is still active with USCIS, they're getting paid and have benefits still active, it just appears that the employee is still working.
- version_five 4y ago> Since the employee is getting paid to do nothing, almost nobody in trading has any issues with non-competes. That's surprising to me, I assume these are mostly ambitious people who would not want the gap in their work record that came from spending a year being paid to do nothing. Obviously there are other things one could do, but they probably don't advance the career the same way a year of real work does
- ergocoder 4y agoWe are lucky that US is not ripe with corruptions. They either enforce it uniformly or they don't. In some shady countries, you can bet that this would be enforced selectively. It's sad that, for a company like Stripe that wants to do things by the book and/or needs to do things by the book (because they are in the financial sector), they will not extend employment date like this and will be criticized for it. To no one's surprise, Stripe didn't offer this in the latest layoff.
- diebeforei485 4y agoActually, this is up to the discretion of the USCIS officer. It is not uniform.
- ergocoder 4y agoIt's uniform enough that we don't hear about the selective treatment.
- saagarjha 4y agoUniform enough that you don’t hear about it.
- tedunangst 4y agoWhere would I go to hear about it?
- nsonha 4y ago> If you aren't working full time and don't even have network access, you are out of H-1B eligibility How so? How is “working full time”, or whatever the eligibility criterion defined, legally? Not the employment agreement? Do you actually know this stuff or you just speculating?
- ergocoder 4y agoIt's an uncharted area. This happens all the time. We won't know until someone tries to push the limit. Some more similar examples: - Green card holders can't leave the country more than 6 months. Many have stayed outside of US for 6 months with no issue. One of green cards' goal is for you to settle in US as home country. So, the general consensus is that, in a year, if you stay outside of US more than 6 months, then US is not really a home. - RSU expiring in 7 years in order to avoid upfront tax. No one know why it is 7 years. Can it be 8 years? - This layoff thing as well. H1B workers are on the payroll until 31 of March. Well, can it be 31 Dec 2023? Nobody knows. If you went to court, can you claim that this H1B worker respect the intention of the law? probably not.
- nsonha 4y agosorry that's very lousy and irrelevant, nothing uncharted about what defines employment in immigration laws. Or that immigration cannot dictate how private companies hire people (can't have people on the payroll while doing nothing? Who tf are you to tell them?)
- ergocoder 4y agoUSCIS literally dictates how company uses H1B. OPT and H1B have to submit a document, signed by manager, explain their responsibility. I'm pretty sure if that says "im doing nothing. I just get paid". They will be in trouble. This case is uncharted because nobody knows how long on the payroll is wrong. We can all agree 2y is wrong. But 3 months, 4 months, 3 months 2 days? Nobody knows. I gave you a few other examples where the lengths of periods are also arbitrary. One of them is even around immigration.
- iamcreasy 4y agoI can confirm that. Employee need to work at least 20 hours per week to maintain valid status - being on payroll is not enough.