4 ms·
HN is terrible at interpreting sarcasm or jokes, partly because people will say the most extraordinary things with apparent sincerity.
by pjc50 4y ago
HN is terrible at interpreting sarcasm or jokes, partly because people will say the most extraordinary things with apparent sincerity.
- chris_wot 4y agoOn HN, it’s probably best to avoid sarcasm. I’ve used it and it didn’t work out well.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoSarcasm on HN is exceptionally difficult. The closest I've been able to get us deliberately playing around with Poe's Law. The issue with doing so, however, is not being entirely sure if you're getting up votes because people are in on it or think you're serious. And if you let the cat out of the bag and confess to it, it ruins the joke! Both the reader and the writer are left in this nebulous liminal space of perpetual standoff with no one able to make a move. I quite like it, but it's an acquired taste for sure.
- dvaun 4y agoAs do people in most internet forums. Poe’s law: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law
- bee_rider 4y agoThe whole point of sarcasm is that there’s a chance somebody won’t get it. It is the author trusting the reader in the hopes of making a little connection when the reader gets it. If there’s no chance of failure, the reader doesn’t actually have to get it, so there’s point to the whole exercise. It just becomes a joke in a stilted format. If you ever feel the need to include a /s, just make a normal joke it will be funnier. Read /s as “NOT” in Borat-voice.
- smw 4y agoWhat a strange contention. I don't think I've ever used sarcasm without meaning my audience to understand me. Most movie tropes around it don't seem to be deliberately deceptive either. I wonder if this is a generational thing?
- bee_rider 4y agoIt isn’t so much that the other party is expected not to get it, just that there must be some possibility. It is like a trust fall. You don’t expect to land on your butt, but you have to engage in the possibility.
- pfoof 4y ago> people will say the most extraordinary things with apparent sincerity. But the level of extraordinary is still far from what 4chan can produce
- ubercore 4y agoSarcasm is also really hard to deal with in text, even for native speakers. And super hard for non-native English speakers.