37 ms·
Could you give examples of how quality has declined? I'm scared if a rag like Jacobin is in the running. When people say that the quality of a publication has
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
Could you give examples of how quality has declined? I'm scared if a rag like Jacobin is in the running.
When people say that the quality of a publication has declined they often mean they disagree with things that are published. Many also say that they seek out blogs and other sources that I assume they agree with.
I read these publications because I often disagree with their opinion pieces. It's a value add. Why would I pay to read my own views regurgitated? It's a danger inherent in trying to micromanage and curate a very narrow source of information. You end up only ingesting things that you agree with.
My 2 cents. Sorry for the big edit
- Aromasin 4y agoI've discussed how I think the quality has decline elsewhere in the thread, but in short, they flip-flop so as to be on the "correct" side of the conversation too often instead of admitting fault, their UK/EU commentary has been of such a low quality I could find it in a tabloid newspaper if I wanted, and their general Anglo-centric view of the world is not valuable to me explicitly for the reason you describe; I'm British, I don't need more of a pro-UK narrative. I put the Jacobin explicitly because I wanted to make it clear that I'm open to the whole political spectrum. I've read some good articles on there, as well as bad. I'm happy to be convinced out of subscribing to it. I've had a lot of people say it's a rag, but not explain how. Is it because it's poor journalism, or is it because it's socialist? And no, it's not that I'm looking for validation of my own opinions. That's why I've put it out to a forum and not just picked the one most appealing to me.
- chipotle_coyote 4y ago> I've had a lot of people say [Jacobin is] a rag, but not explain how. Is it because it's poor journalism, or is it because it's socialist? Anecdotally, I'm in sympathy with a lot of Jacobin's political viewpoints (even though I'm not as anti-capitalist, or at least anti-market, as they seem to be), but I have a lot of trouble really clicking with their style. They're far more opinion-driven than The Economist or even The Atlantic, and there's what I can only describe as a sneering subtext to much of the work by them I've been pointed to, e.g., "this premise is plainly true to anyone who isn't stupid and/or evil", when I'm sort of mentally raising my hand and going "wait, you are skipping work you really need to dedicate at least a few paragraphs to." It's the leftist version of the feeling I got reading C.S. Lewis decades ago.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> "this premise is plainly true to anyone who isn't stupid and/or evil" You are dead on. I often sympathize and appreciate the core of their message but the presentation is off putting, to me anyway.
- rainingmonkey 4y agoI've found Tribune Magazine (https://tribunemag.co.uk/ https://tribunemag.co.uk/) a good source of well-written leftist opinions without the tone and US focus of Jacobin.
- jdgoesmarching 4y agoJacobin’s editorial philosophy focuses on conversational writing to make the articles more accessible. This is intentionally different from the didactic style of The Economist or what I’d call the philosophical ramblings of the NYT or Atlantic. It isn’t trying to be a publication that sounds smart or pretends to be unbiased, but that is the expectation most people have from economic and political writing. That plus the obvious political position makes it unpopular, but I’d argue the quality is just as good as any other major publication. I’d say it’s important to keep it in your mix because you’re just not going to find views or analysis from that perspective otherwise.
- pydry 4y agoReading the piece on how github copilot will automate developers out of a job made me chuckle. The reporter knew fuck all about copilot or AI, clearly hadn't talked to a developer who did. It was essentially regurgitated, reconstituted investor pitch. This is pretty standard. If I wanna know what investors or beltway insiders are excited about or afraid of I read the Economist to see what kind of kool aid they're drinking.
- maybelsyrup 4y ago> When people say that the quality of a publication has declined they often mean they disagree with things that are published. > a rag like Jacobin
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoJacobin often uses flame bait writing style which I don't like even if it's something that I agree with. It's insulting to the reader.
- tootie 4y agoJacobin isn't just biased, it's agenda-driven. They're cheering specific outcomes and jeering others. To the parent comments' point, Jacobin is just an echo chamber for Socialists who want to hear Socialist opinions from other Socialists. That's different from wanting to read factual news and rational analysis from sources who believe climate change is real.
- jdgoesmarching 4y agoEvery publication is agenda-driven, and nothing is more echo chambery than believing only your favorites are presenting “factual news and rational analysis.”
- tootie 4y agoNo they aren't. That's cynical. Jacobin puts it right on their About Us page that they're Socialist news. I've been around a few newsrooms and most of them would riot if they were ever directed to represent an agenda. Even when there was a predominant political leaning.
- jdgoesmarching 4y agoHow many of those newsrooms rioted during the decision to invade Iraq? One doesn’t need to be “directed to represent an agenda” in a competitive news environment, you don’t make it through the door without being a certain type of journalist to begin with. One of the most frustrating obstacles in this conversation is people believing that being in the middle of the Overton Window makes you non-ideological. The idea of being ideological is offensive to people who believe that their view isn’t, which ironically is the hallmark of successful ideology. I’d point to Capitalist Realism by Mark Fisher for further elaboration. This reminds me of the David Foster Wallace joke of the fish who reply to “How’s the water?” with “What the hell is water?”