> This is imprisonment without conviction, no matter how you gussy it up. This is begging the question. You have to explain why you think that's bad, not merel

> This is imprisonment without conviction, no matter how you gussy it up. This is begging the question. You have to explain why you think that's bad, not merely describe what's happening. Obviously you're assuming a shared sense that it's illegitimate to intern someone without a trial, but the whole point here is that some people think an exception should be made in this particular case. You're just reiterating the controversy.