22 ms·
> The effort will involve hospitalizing people involuntarily, even if they do not pose an immediate risk of harm to others. >“The common misunderstanding persi
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> The effort will involve hospitalizing people involuntarily, even if they do not pose an immediate risk of harm to others.
>“The common misunderstanding persists that we cannot provide involuntary assistance unless the person is violent,” Mr. Adams said. “This myth must be put to rest. Going forward, we will make every effort to assist those who are suffering from mental illness and whose illness is endangering them by preventing them from meeting their basic human needs.”
How does this work with federal US Supreme Court rulings such Connor Donaldson and Addington Texas:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O%27Connor_v._Donaldson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O%27Connor_v._Donaldson
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Addington_v._Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Addington_v._Texas
Some more cases:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_Supreme_Court_cases_involving_mental_health https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_Supreme_...
- mwint 4y agoIt works like this: there are no Constitution Police. No one gets arrested for making an unconstitutional law. NYC especially is pretty good at this: they make a law, it works through the system and gets struck down by SCOTUS, then they immediately make a slightly different law which has to work through the system and be struck down. It’s way quicker to make a law than it is to strike it down. Ultimately, if the people of a region keep electing lawmakers who make unconstitutional laws, that region will have unconstitutional law most of the time.
- mdorazio 4y agoCalifornia loves doing this as well, especially with gun laws.
- standardUser 4y agoMany states did this habitually for decades with restrictive abortion laws.
- DataOverload 4y ago
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt does not seem like New York City or New York State enacted any laws in this case.
- mwint 4y agoLaw, policy, directive, order, emergency action, etc. All boils down to “government is doing something with force of law” and is reviewable by SCOTUS.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoThank you for explaining this to everyone. As someone who is disabled with Schizoaffective Bipolar Disorder and suffered the horrors of today's for profit psychiatric hospitals this is not only unlawful but is a disgusting money grab that Adams no doubt will profit from at some point.
- singleshot_ 4y agoIs a law that will, in the future, be found unconstitutional by the Supreme Court unconstitutional before they find it to be so? Wouldn’t it be more reasonable to view this phenomenon within the context of the balanced powers of government? The Supreme Court has the final say in the constitutionality of a certain law, but that doesn’t make them the most powerful branch of government. They lack the power to try again, and the legislature and the executive have that power. To me, the system is working as intended when the people elect representatives who repeatedly force the judicial branch to strike down laws the people want. This seems to be a way to redirect this type of question into a political solution, i.e., a way to force people to recognize that what they really want is not a particular law, but a better judiciary or a center Constitution. After all, the chain of events you’re describing is one that never departs from the mechanisms considered by the Constitution (and the Marbury court, of course, but that ship has sailed).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- setr 4y agoThe problem is that there’s no disincentive to creating laws that are eventually found unconstitutional — a malicious actor is capable of producing ill-formed laws faster, cheaper and with less effort than it takes to identify and remove them. So responsibility isn’t really the issue — the problem is that you can simply overwhelm the other party to make them impotent, and impossible to execute on that responsibility (because if they double their resources, you produce 4X the garbage). Ideally you would have lawmakers incentivized to produce laws, that upon review, are constitutional, but it remains the supreme court’s jurisdiction to determine that constitutionality. Like try spamming the FDA drugs unlikely to pass scrutiny — they’ll just shut you out — so you’re incentivized to try to submit something reasonably likely to pass.
- singleshot_ 4y agoI get what you’re saying but I think we approach this from different philosophies (which is fine). I agree that there is no disincentive to passing laws that the judiciary will nullify (other than the fact they get nullified and have to be replaced). The “malicious actor” of whom you speak appears to me to be the representative of the populace, from whom all power derives, and accordingly I see this as a feature, not a bug. The only incentive they should need to pass useful laws is re-election. My ideal would be that the courts would interpret and make law, but that political questions like “what comports with the Constitution” would be solved at the ballot box, in the legislature, or with the veto pen, as was intended. The idea that the judicial branch could be made “impotent” via repeated passing through the duly empowered legislature of bills signed by the duly empowered executive seems like exactly the right amount of power for what was considered by Article III. The courts are, after all, currently the strongest part of our constitutional system.
- notch656a 4y agoAFAIK in new york the wards were closed largely in response to abhorrent conditions exposed in a documentary at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willowbrook_State_School https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Willowbrook_State_School and other locations.
- infecto 4y agoI don't know much about case law but seemed that in both cases there must be burden of proof that they are a harm to themselves or others. From my time in SF I have seen more people than I can count walking around with blood and feces caked on their legs. I could see someone like that requiring instituional help.
- gpm 4y agoO'Connor v. Donaldson (per wikipedia) > ruling that a state cannot constitutionally confine a non-dangerous individual who is capable of surviving safely in freedom by themselves or with the help of willing and responsible family members or friends. The non-paywalled portion of the article > Mayor Eric Adams directed the police and emergency medical workers to hospitalize people they deemed too mentally ill to care for themselves, even if they posed no threat to others. These seem to be the same standard, they are confining people who incapable of caring for themselves, which O'Connor v. Donaldson apparently allowed.
- bombcar 4y agoThe only difference might be "with the help of willing and responsible family members or friends" but the reality is if someone has help and is accepting it, the police won't even know about it. They only get involved when those family members and friends call them directly, or the person is found wandering around.
- gpm 4y agoYeah. I'm also willing to give the city the benefit of the doubt and assume that that small caveat is being taken care of properly and just wasn't included in the quote in the subtitle of the NY times article...
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf NYC can pull this off, I wonder what has been stopping it and all the other US cities for all these years.
- panzagl 4y agoIt's expensive and no one wants to pay for it.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoSame thing stopping NYC. They don't have the psych beds available to put these people in.