9 ms·
American EVs reduced gasoline consumption by just 0.54% in 2021
- rogerkirkness 4y agoCompounding curve, reducing gas consumption by 1/200 units of gas consumed is good, and over time this amount will increase until the point at which EVs are economically cheaper than gas, at which point it will experience takeoff.
- proc0 4y agoThe electric grid is a big bottleneck that I don't think has a solution yet. At some point EVs will create stress on the grid, slowing down the adoption and leaving the state of this transition in the worst of both worlds--costly electricity but many people still using gas. IMHO, the #1 priority should be cheaper electricity. Everything else follows from that, like more demand for EVs. It seems focusing on EVs too much is putting the horse before the cart, or w/e that saying is.
- bombcar 4y agoPlugin hybrids would bridge that gap pretty effectively- especially for short trips where it could go battery only.
- proc0 4y agoYeah, I agree, hybrids could be a good transition while the grid is upgraded.
- bombcar 4y agoWhat I'd like to see is a special panel (say when replacing your 100 amp service) that has one side defined as "always available" and another side defined as "utility brownout" and you could put things like the fridge and lights on "always available" and the AC and car charger on "utility brownout". They have these devices for AC units already, but it could be so much smarter.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoEV's mostly charge at night, and the grid is sized to handle air conditioners during the day time. So if the grid can handle air conditioning during the day time, it should be fine.
- CobaltFire 4y agoThis is not the full story; the grid is sized to allow peak load heat shed during the cooler night hours; if we do not have those hours to cool it we start seeing a drastic increase in failures. I've heard some talk that some of the PG&E caused fires are due to the grids not getting enough time to cool and accelerating failures. Note that this doesn't excuse their lack of investment in infrastructure. Basically, we need to hugely over provision the grid to handle 24/7 loading without the current failure modes. That will require a complete rethink on what constitutes the base load, how solar can help and how it can't, etc.
- KingOfCoders 4y ago"I've heard some talk that some of the PG&E caused fires are due to the grids not getting enough time to cool" Source?
- CobaltFire 4y agoNothing that I could reference or I would have put it in there. I have family in some of the effected areas (Marin and Navato) and that's one of the discussion points. It seems plausible but I have nothing more than that. Edit: I don't think the grid being hot would cause a fire, to be clear. I'm under the impression that it causes the lines to sag, increasing the occurrence of the primary mode of wildfire cause, vegetation contact. Further, running the transformers hotter shortens their life (as it does with most electrical equipment).
- 0cf8612b2e1e 4y agoDo renewables also require cooling times or is that restricted to natural gas/coal plants? If we continue on this pace of installing so much solar will the peak plants get used less frequently? Or was that just sloppy language on peak vs base loads? I have not seen anything near-term realistic on removing fossil fuel base load generation.
- bunabhucan 4y ago"If they perform scheduled charges for times in which electricity is cheaper, the US power grid could deal with 65 million EVs." https://insideevs.com/news/436665/24-million-evs-limit-current-power-grid/ https://insideevs.com/news/436665/24-million-evs-limit-curre... 2021 sales were less that 1% of that. At what point does the bottleneck kick in? I would imagine electric utilities have a huge incentive to make this work given that demand has been flat at ~4 trillion kWh for over a decade.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoYes + people always forget second order effects. Increasing EV numbers will lead to changes in the power grid. It's like saying in 1886 "If all horses would be replaced by cars, the petroleum industry would collapse".
- asdff 4y agoThat's a little concerning that its only 65 million. For comparison there are almost 300 million cars in the U.S., so this would be just a 20% adoption rate we are capable of. The reason why I am concerned is not for lack of power, its that I know for a fact the red states in this country will favor making up the slack with fossil fuel based power, because that's significantly faster and cheaper to construct than the best alternative, nuclear power. Even in california nuclear power can hardly catch a break, diablo canyon is limping along, they've already closed san onofre, and I don't think any new power plant is in the pipeline currently.
- kevinpet 4y agoI think your arguments would be more effective if you removed the tribalism from your politics. Leftists are not consistent friends to nuclear power and in fact nuclear power generation does not seem to have any relation to a states partisan lean: https://www.statista.com/statistics/187270/us-nuclear-power-electricity-generation-by-state/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/187270/us-nuclear-power-...
- asdff 4y ago
- eldaisfish 4y agoYou make a good point but this sort of thinking is unfortunately dismissed here by those who view technology as the solution to all problems. Your observation is correct - the grid as designed is indeed a bottleneck and this will become increasingly obvious in northern climates as more services switch to electric - heat and transportation are good examples. An excellent case in point is the trans canada highway which has failed to electrify large sections due to insufficient grid capacity. Before people point to a map from an auto maker, do those maps show instances where the power feeding EV chargers has overloaded a circuit causing multiple hours of no charging? Cheaper electricity should indeed be a short term goal.
- bluGill 4y agoThe grid operators are watching EVs coming and making plans. The limit is regulation, not technical. Often the law doesn't allow them to build the lines where they need to.
- eldaisfish 4y agothis is not complete. the limit is often technical because EVs and electric heating increase the energy and peak power demands on the grid. Grid operators also do not have infinite capacity to retire entire neighbourhoods to support the increased power demands of increased HVAC capacity combined with EV capacity.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoEVs that are not used acting as local batteries decrease the demand on the grid. If every car in Germany would be an EV the battery capacity could power all of Germanys electric power needs for two days. Things are more complex than they seem to be at first sight.
- eldaisfish 4y agoEVs = grid storage gets thrown around a lot. There is currently no viable pricing model for these services, they have not been trialed at any scale and there is little to no legal framework with either vehicle manufactures or battery suppliers in terms of the warranty. Your claim of batteries powering a gigawatt scale grid for two days does not pass the smell test. Something is off so it might help to show calculations or sources.
- KingOfCoders 4y ago"Your claim of batteries powering a gigawatt scale grid for two days does not pass the smell test." What smell test? What doesn't specifically sound right? I might have miscalculated of course, 50M cars x 50kwh = 2500Gwh = 2.5Twh Germany Electricty usage: 561,8 Twh/ year -> /365 = 1.54Twh / day So two days ~3TwH, Battery capacity ~2.5Twh I would be interested in any corrections, especially as you are a renewable energy researcher and I'm just a coder.
- benj111 4y agoAs discussed in the article these EVs only added 0.15% to electricity demand, so at 100% EVs were talking 30% extra demand. I don't know about the US, but in the UK electricity demand has dropped ~20% in the past 10 years. (10% in 7 years if you want to avoid covid etc) Adding in the fact that EVs are more likely to be charged off peak and I'd be surprised if it made any appreciable difference.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> the point at which EVs are economically cheaper than gas From a fueling standpoint, EVs are already far cheaper than gas. So much so that many people are already jumping to EVs despite having to make compromises when road tripping.
- kevinpet 4y agoBut not from a total lifecycle perspective. 100000 miles at 25 mpg at $5/gal is $20,000, and that's spread out over the ten years you drive those 100,000 miles. Add in another few thousand in extra maintenance costs for gasoline, subtract out a few thousand for the cost of charging at home, subtract out a bit more to get the charger installed, and for a full size car the fuel savings are about $12,000 up front. For compact cars comparable to cars that get better mileage, that's less.
- rootusrootus 4y agoFor compact cars it's a bit easier to win on TCO. You just get a Bolt and call it good. Pretty tough to beat the TCO there. I do agree that EVs have more coverage on the premium end of the market than in the low/mid tier. Though a Model 3 at about 40K is reasonably competitive in that segment.
- jotm 4y agoWhere does the math work out? In much of Europe, charging instead of fueling is around 2x more expensive per KW of useful energy and that's with diesel/petrol being 2 Euros/Liter. And we're not even getting into the reduced range, availability of (fast) charging stations, availability of electric work vans, the cost of EVs, cost of repair/batteries, etc. Right now for the vast majority of people, EVs are frankly, ridiculously unaffordable.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Where does the math work out? I cannot speak for Europe. But in the US, gasoline is $3.51/gallon, electricity is $0.166/kWh. The average car gets 24.2 mpg. The average EV goes 2.9 miles/kWh. The average miles per year driven is 14263. So the average EV driver will spend about $100 per month less on fueling. But there's a lot of variability to that. You can buy a Chevy Bolt for $26.5K, it consumes 3.44 kWh/mi, and in Portland you can charge at night for $0.042/kWh. The lifetime fueling cost is less than one average new car payment. A quick google search suggests gasoline is approximately twice as expensive in Europe, electricity three times as expensive, and miles driven about half. The fueling cost will be much closer, but the EV still comes out ahead.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI'm not sure the "just" is warranted, they appear to be punching above their weight. > But it should be clear now that EVs on their own are not a panacea to our transport-related climate problems, and the future will require many more people to walk, cycle, or take the bus to get to where they're going. I think this claim is true (and a good thing) but it's not really supported by the evidence presented, which mostly says "the US needs less ICE cars".
- abracadaniel 4y agoHaving trouble finding a primary source, but it looks like EVs are only 0.43% of operational cars in the US. So, something on the order of a half percent decrease in fuel seems reasonable. Likely hitting above their weight as 2 car families opt to drive the new EV over the older gas car. https://www.experian.com/blogs/insights/2021/10/ev-registrations-grow-first-half-2021-non-electric-remains-dominant/ https://www.experian.com/blogs/insights/2021/10/ev-registrat...
- melling 4y agoYes, I remember when only a handful of people had the iPhone too. Why do we have these silly discussions? Six years ago Tesla was going out of business and the stock price was going to tank. When that didn’t happen, we started having other silly conversations. If everyone in LA and New York drove an electric car they’d sure have much cleaner air. Not sure why the EV Bus Revolution hasn’t started in the United States. https://chargedevs.com/newswire/the-vehicles/byd-delivers-over-70000-electric-buses-almost-all-in-china/ https://chargedevs.com/newswire/the-vehicles/byd-delivers-ov...
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- cnntth 4y agoTransit companies get shafted in municipal budgets politically. Increasing ridership by increasing frequency (more drivers / more cheap diesel or lng buses) is a better investment of limited budgets than electrification. But also sometimes transit agencies just do dumb things (see, Boston de-electrifying a few bus lines).
- jdsully 4y agoThey're including plugin hybrids which apparently saw a massive efficiency drop. I don't think we should consider these transitional technologies anymore now that battery vehicles have become "good enough" in most population centres. Even if you can't charge at home there is now a good network of chargers here in Toronto.
- bombcar 4y agoQuite a few non-plug-in hybrids are still being sold, and transitioning those to plug-in would be an improvement.
- hnav 4y agoNon-plug in hybrids are becoming the norm, almost everyone is going to at least a 48v mild hybrid, which is a 10-15% improvement over a normal ICE. Something like a Prius, Insight or Ioniq get 50+mpg combined. If everybody switched from godawful crossovers to hybrid econoboxes (comparable utility and price), we'd see a 30% reduction in gas usage.
- Imnimo 4y ago>This report is not an argument against people buying EVs, of course; any gas savings is an improvement on turning that gasoline into atmospheric pollution that worsens climate change. But it should be clear now that EVs on their own are not a panacea to our transport-related climate problems, and the future will require many more people to walk, cycle, or take the bus to get to where they're going. I don't understand how the 0.54% statistic has any bearing on this conclusion. Like if all miles were driven by EVs, then it would be a 100% reduction in gasoline (using the metric in the study). Would that make EVs a panacea?
- supergeek 4y agoFuel consumption is only a portion of the transportation related emissions. Road construction, vehicle consumables like tires, and car related infrastructure like parking lots and garages all contribute. There's also some cost to bear with the huge numbers of vehicle accidents and deaths each year from driving.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoThat would be good journalism.
- rascul 4y ago> Like if all miles were driven by EVs, then it would be a 100% reduction in gasoline (using the metric in the study). It wouldn't be quite 100%. Generators, mowers, ATVs, and some other things are also using gasoline. I don't see in the article if that was accounted for. I doubt it would be much more than a few percent at the most, though.
- Imnimo 4y agoWell, but the metric in the study doesn't count those anyway. It's just about gasoline used by cars, and they get their number by considering how much gas would have been used if all the miles driven by EV had instead been driven by a similar gas-consuming vehicle.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoIt seems the right thing to look at is how much energy was saved/added/shifted and from what sources. Less gasoline is good unless the alternative is coal-fired electricity.
- codepoet80 4y agoThis. We bought a small EV a little over a year ago, and I expect our personal gasoline reduction is close to 50% -- easily more than half our trips are now in the EV. However, the grid in our area is primarily coal-based, so I'm aware we're just shifting. I've begun my own solar charging project to address that, but its expensive and will take multiple years to get ROI, and is clearly not for everyone. My thesis is diversification -- having 100% of the average family's transportation needs dependent on gasoline creates (or creates potential for) lots of problems. Frankly the infrastructure is not there (in my area) for everyone to go 100% EV, but I'm in favor of experimentation and diversification.
- ThrowawayIP 4y agoYou are shifting the reduced amount of energy that your car consumes. So even with a coal-based grid, it is a net-positive. The MPGe rating is a great indication of this.
- bdamm 4y agoIf you took the gasoline that powers one car and put it in a power plant that powered EVs, you could power maybe 4 or 5 EVs with that gasoline. So even that is a net positive. Why? Because converting gasoline to electricity in a large-scale plant is far more efficient than converting gasoline to motion in little engines scattered about in the environment. Once the power is available as electricity, the downstream losses are really quite small (10%? 5%?) compared to the downstream losses for gasoline - 85% just in the car itself, and that's not even including delivering the gasoline to the gas station or the energy required to pump it into the car etc.
- asdff 4y agoIf we want to prevent a future of EVs being powered by fossil fuels, we need to start building nuclear powerplants like right this instant. This will be tough considering even the most forward thinking state, California, has hardly an interest in nuclear power. The federal government had to bail out diablo canyon before the state was going to let it die like they let san onofre die to replace it with a natural gas plant that produces less power.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoWhen does the deluge of electronics waste begin? Are there any studies about the carbon footprint of recycling these things?
- senko 4y agoAll modern cars have tons of electronics already. My new (medium class) ICE car has a bunch more than a small second-car EV I recently drove (Renault Twingo). Car batteries meanwhile, are likely to be recycled as much as possible, as they are the priciest single component of the car.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoTons? The Tesla Model 3 has over half a ton of electronics. Just the battery is 1000+ lbs.
- senko 4y agoAs in "a lot". Modulo the battery (which I mentioned separately), I don't think Model 3 has much more electronics than modern ICE cars in its class. A modern car isn't even a computer on wheels, it's network of many computers, on wheels.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI'm aware. Saying a gas vehicle and an electric vehicle have practically the same amount of electronics if you ignore the battery is silly though. I just have to ignore the 1000+ lb battery. > they are the priciest single component of the car. What's the lifespan on that battery?
- Tagbert 4y agoIt is not silly. The recyclability story is different for batteries vs general electronics. Electronics in general are not well recycled. The batteries can be once the programs are setup.
- wiskinator 4y agoI think the simplest way to express my concern with this article is that I would like to have "just" 0.54% of Elon Musk's wealth direct deposited into my bank account tomorrow.
- timeon 4y agoGood for him but is the point of article about Musk?
- rootusrootus 4y agoI think that's fantastic, actually. It's only been a few years. I'm starting to see EVs everywhere, more each day.
- taolegal 4y agoI basically just see them in snobby rich areas. Same place as the virtue signal yard signs with luxury shops everywhere.
- Tagbert 4y agoThat is a very snobby attitude. Do you assume that only poor people are earnest? You do a disservice to the whole income spectrum by prompting the stereotype of the “honest working man vs the rapacious rich man”.
- taolegal 4y ago> Do you assume that only poor people are earnest? I don't assume, in my experience I've seen that highfalutin self-advertising of progressive ideals is concentrated in wealthy areas. It's sanctimonious and always among people who are insulated enough from reality to pretend they actually believe in those ideals.
- rootusrootus 4y agoHilariously, in my circle of friends none of the die hard progressives own an EV, it's the three firebreathing Trump supporters that are all-in on electric vehicles. They drive a lot of miles and appreciate the tremendous cost savings. None of them strike me as particularly sanctimonious. I think you're just extremely ideological and you see what you want to see.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- samstave 4y agoWould this be related to the massive fossil fuel consumption is in logistics; shipping and semi trailers?
- creeble 4y agoI’d like to see the results for just California, where EV adoption is highest. What has happened to gasoline use in the state where 18% of new car sales are EVs?
- obblekk 4y agoSales of EVs are growing linearly so the displacement effect of EVs grows quadratically (at least for the first 10 years before any significant number are taken out of service). Quadratics aren't quite exponentials, but they're still pretty fast for a society. US gasoline consumption grew only 5% from 2010 to 2019, so by 2023, EV sales will be offsetting all growth in gasoline demand. By 2024, gas demand will be less each year than before. By 2030, significant numbers of gas stations will be reducing/converting pump counts. That sounds like a pretty awesome arc for the 2020s compared to the 2010s. And the linear sales growth constant seems decently high too: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1231872/battery-electric-vehicle-sales-in-the-united-states/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1231872/battery-electric... Gas consumption: https://www.statista.com/statistics/188448/total-us-domestic-demand-for-gasoline-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/188448/total-us-domestic...
- robomartin 4y agoIn every single one of these discussions people always fail to look at reality in the proper context. Baselines are important if the objective is to evaluate the merit of any proposed solutions. There are many reality-check baselines one can refer to in the case of the planetary-scale problem we are discussing. Here's one: https://i.imgur.com/wbHptnf.png https://i.imgur.com/wbHptnf.png A very simple chart that speaks loudly. Among other things, it says that electric cars do not matter. At all. What? OK. In case it isn't obvious, I'll walk you through it. The argument presented is that a full conversion of the US into electric-powered ground transportation is crucial in the fight against climate change. Some say this can actually start to roll back atmospheric CO2 concentration levels. This, of course, is preposterous. Let's take it a million times further than just converting the US to electric power: Let's completely erase the US from this planet. We go from 300 million people to zero. All buildings, factories, vehicles, power plants, trains, planes, etc. evaporate overnight. Gone. Beamed into space by Captain Kirk. What effect would that have on global atmospheric CO2 concentration and climate change? Well, the simple answer (refer to the chart) is the planet would see a reduction in annual contributions of 14%. This is NOT a reduction in atmospheric CO2 concentration. This is a reduction in annual inputs, that's all. Instead of 32 giga-tons of CO2 per year contributed by humanity we would contribute 28 GT. Which, in turn, means nothing whatsoever would change. Atmospheric CO2 would continue to accumulate and increase at about the same rate. Therefore, electric cars do not matter at all. Their potential impact is dwarfed by comparison to the absolute elimination of an entire nation from the planet. It is, at best, a rounding error. I know people won't like this. Well, rather than being offended, how about explaining how electric cars would do any better than eliminating the entire US from this planet? Here, I'll help with a fill in the blank exercise (using current White House estimate on impact of full ground transport electrification to be 1 GT per year): Ten years from now if we change nothing: 32 GT * 10 = 320 GT more than we have today If the US didn't exist at all: 28 GT * 10 = 280 GT more than we have today Best case if we convert all cars in the US to electric power: 31 GT * 10 = 310 GT more than we have today So...310 GT instead of 320 GT added to the atmosphere in ten years if we go full electric. That's assuming the 1 GT savings per year is real. Given the massive required increase in energy generation this remains to be seen. BTW, this also assumes all other nations will remain at their current emissions levels. That is unlikely. China and India are likely going up before they come down, if ever. Comparing our ideas to reasonable baselines is of crucial importance. In this case we learn a very harsh reality. Electric cars are great, yes. However, we really need to stop painting them as a "save the planet" technology. That's nothing less than laughable given the data. Again, refute the data before being angered by an argument you do not like. After all, reality does not care about your emotions. Are you actually arguing that full-electrics will have a greater impact than erasing the US from the planet? If you can't do that, you really need to re-evaluate how you see this problem.
- Tagbert 4y agothe argument that makes the most sense to me about why EVs with slightly less than 1% have “only” reduced CO2 by 0.54% is that until recently the available EVs were mainly replacing relatively gas efficient vehicles: hatchbacks, sedans, and small SUVs. The owners of less efficient trucks and large SUVs have not seen EV equivalents to switch to. that is starting to change with the introduction of the Ford F150 Lightning and the upcoming Silverado and other larger EV SUVs. Also the number of PHEV SUVs has increased in the last year or so. As EVs become available to replace vehicles across the range, that impact number should correct and more closely track market penetration.