4 ms·
The Only U.S. Territory Without U.S. Birthright Citizenship
- atdrummond 4y agoInterestingly, the American Samoa recruiting office has the highest recruitment rate of any such center for the entire United States' armed forces. One bizarre side effect of this massive recruiting drive is that American Samoan enlisted men and women retire to the mainland and then are unable to take up jobs they are more than qualified for, such as sheriff deputy or police detective. (These roles require US Citizenship which they obviously lack.) This situation has led to a number of lawsuits, none of which have satisfactorily solved the issue. It seems the courts are mostly content to let Congress and American Samoa eventually solve the incongruence, even if the present situation is somewhat without parallel and extremely inconvenient for those caught in the edge cases.
- diebeforei485 4y agoWhy can't they fix this by sliding it into a big omnibus bill? Who is actually opposed to this?
- atdrummond 4y agoI wonder if originally the only way to preserve the familial land ownership laws and clan leadership rules was to have American Samoans as legal residents but not citizens. Such a kludge is the only reasonable justification I have ever found convincing, outside the arguments used at the time that were clearly farcical then and even moreso now.
- nwah1 4y agoHalf the world uses only Jus Sanguinis. It has some benefit in terms of clarity and incentives. If you want to be generous and welcoming, that is fine, and could work perfectly well in that framework. All such liberal values would just need to happen through a legal naturalization process. Under Jus Soli, we encourage people to violate the law and create situations where some members of families are citizens and others aren't. Nationality in general is a pretty arbitrary concept, of course. But if we are going to have it, my programmer brain likes the idea of minimal ambiguity.