6 ms·
The EV Transition Explained: Can the Grid Cope?
- Trouble_007 4y ago>create an excessive peak load that would overload or blow out a transformer, especially when they *(the transformer)* are toward the end of their lives, which many already are.* This is a failure to infrastructure investment.
- falcolas 4y agoIt is. It's also the reality we in the US have to deal with. All of our infrastructure is in trouble, because nobody wants to invest billions of tax dollars into mere maintenance. Also, a fair bit of the infrastructure is maintained by the individual states, making any country-wide coordination of investment or fixes neigh impossible.
- leereeves 4y ago> more than 95 percent of residential transformers would be overloaded if Palo Alto hits its EV and electrical-appliance targets by 2030. sounds like a capacity issue, not a maintenance issue. Who would invest in more capacity for which there was no demand?
- iamwpj 4y agoYes, I noticed this too. Also note that throughout the 80s and 90s the grid handled the new transformer upgrades without any sort of national catastrophe. In my mind this hand wringing serves to provide arguments for the anti-EV crowd. The bigger issue might be the climate change demands of additional days for cooling, reduction of hydro electric, etc.
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> Converting a gas appliance to a heat pump, for example, would draw 4 to 6 kW, while an L2 charger for EVs would be 12 to 14 kW. A This article has an issue with numbers here clearly. A heat pump isn’t really going to consume more electricity than the AC it replaces (and hopefully it is more efficient than the cool-only-AC it replaces as well so electricity uses decreases in the summer). For electric cars, no-one needs 48A (11.5kw) charging (unless you bought a hummer EV and then you’re an idiot). The city can start denying permits for charging at more than 24-32A unless you have enough battery storage to cover it up. Palo Alto also does not have TOU plans, and no demand charges.
- falcolas 4y agoFWIW, if you use 2.4kw charging (Level 1, typical for a household) , it may take multiple days to recharge your 80kwh battery. Charging overnight, for example, it would require three full nights to get back a complete charge. While this wouldn't be a problem for most folks, there are definitely many who could easily outstrip the power provided by a Level 1 charger (in my area, construction workers who are driving around 100 miles per day to their worksite is an example). Also, you need a minimum of level 2 charging to support long distance travel by road, where a full battery can be consumed in about 3 hours of highway driving.
- _ea1k 4y agoDid you reply to the wrong comment? OP said nothing about L1?
- falcolas 4y agoNope, right comment. > or electric cars, no-one needs 48A (11.5kw) charging refers to L2 DC fast charging. The next level down (which is implied by "nobody needs L2") is L1 charging, which is done on a household 120V or 220V circuit. In other words, if you don't supply L2 (and L3) DC fast charging for customers who need it, EVs will never replace ICE.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoNo, he's saying that 24-32A charging is enough. > The city can start denying permits for charging at more than 24-32A unless you have enough battery storage to cover it up.
- falcolas 4y ago32A at 240V (the standard for DC fast charging) is ~8kw, so you'd still be looking at 10 hours for a battery charge. Sufficient for my construction workers, insufficient for supporting long distance driving.
- UltraViolence 4y agoObviously the grid can cope if you size it accordingly. In France they heat their homes with electric central heating and the system can cope. So EV's shouldn't be a problem.
- throw827474737 4y agoWhat has become of the thoughts to let the grid not only cope with it but actually make the cars part of the battery system to support the grid for peaks?
- cagenut 4y agoV2G is mostly relegated to "someday, hopefully soon", but there are two incremental steps that are already getting traction in the market today, V2H and V2L.
- jmnicolas 4y agoFrench electric grid won't cope this winter: our nuclear powerplants are at the end of their life (50+ yo), more than half of them are in maintenance. We're now a net importer of electricity, cuts are already planned for January. Most people (myself included) that want to reduce their energy bill go with something else than electric.
- UltraViolence 4y agoThe grid can cope but there simply isn't enough power being supplied to the grid. The power companies should've planned the maintenance more prudently.
- pydry 4y agoThat isnt a problem with the grid though thats a problem with the nuke plants.
- iggldiggl 4y agoRome wasn't built in a day, and neither was the French grid. So the problem isn't the new end state of the grid as such, but rather how quickly you can get there.
- liampulles 4y agoI'm not an electrician so this random idea might be stupid: could one disperse large batteries around the grid, such that at peak load these large batteries can drain to meet the demand, then charge during off peak hours?
- jmnicolas 4y agoI'm not sure even more batteries is environmentally friendly.
- cagenut 4y agoyes but the upgraded/replaced transformer will be much cheaper than the battery, so it would take some other circumstance (an impossible to upgrade transmission/distribution line) for it to make sense. our grids will start to grow batteries at pinch points, already are, but it will be an exceptions/corner-cases thing, the economics don't work for the broad-average.
- jpm_sd 4y agoYes. Lots of people and companies working on this problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage NREL FAQ https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy19osti/74426.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy19osti/74426.pdf Tesla's approach https://www.tesla.com/megapack https://www.tesla.com/megapack Form Energy, one of the best funded startups working on novel grid storage batteries https://formenergy.com/technology/battery-technology/ https://formenergy.com/technology/battery-technology/
- silviot 4y agoV2G [1] sounds relevant: > Vehicle-to-grid (V2G), also known as Vehicle-to-home (V2H) or Vehicle-to-load (V2L) describes a system in which plug-in electric vehicles (PEV) sell demand response services to the grid. Demand services are either delivering electricity or by reducing their charging rate. Demand services reduce pressure on the grid, which might otherwise experience disruption from load variations. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle-to-grid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle-to-grid
- 4y ago
- cagenut 4y agohaving worked on globally distributed caching for the last decade, the absurd abundance of low-hanging-fruit here is genuinely exciting. the system has as closed to zero 'intelligence' (software) built in as can be right now, so there's almost nothing but green field ahead. for example, it would be technically trivial to implement a kind of "lock acquisition" handshake where all the meters downstream of a bottleneck (transformer in this case) request their incremental kW and the utility does basic fair- queuing. even if only new meters and cars did it, it would still help immensely.
- sandos 4y agoYeah, Iv'e also read about packetizing electricity so that you need to sort of allocate units of energy before using them: https://spectrum.ieee.org/packetized-power-grid https://spectrum.ieee.org/packetized-power-grid
- ec109685 4y agoIt doesn’t need to be that smart. Just spreading the charging time across the full evening always would reduce load significantly without transformer level coordination or smart transformers. Kick off charging when grid capacity is lower than a certain threshold, and trickle into EVs based on how much charge is needed. EVs already let you specify when you want to leave in morning, so it’s a small extension to that.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAny grid that 1) can handle peak air conditioning load AND 2) has time of use pricing to encourage EV's to charge at times other than peak air conditioning load. Can handle EV charging. Palo Alto satisfies neither of those two conditions. That's the problem, not the EV's.
- lambdasquirrel 4y agoAren't EVs just big batteries? What's so hard doing 2, and then using them to stabilize the grid, now that they support bidirectional?
- dahfizz 4y agoI don't know of any technical reason why #2 is hard. Its just a matter of getting the power company to do it and setting up incentives so that EV owners will use it.
- frumper 4y agoMy electric company had me install a separate meter for my EV charger to manage time of use. Benefit is that only my EV costs more in the day, downside was the cost and time to have it done.
- kkfx 4y agoIt's hard because those who design EV, PV etc do not own them, do not understand them. They simply execute some order "do so", ignorantly. That's why only few weeks ago we have seen an initial standard for biderectional DC support. That's why there is still NO PV inverter who actually output 400V DC for stationary batteries who happen to be the same in EVs avoiding wasting 25-30% of energy in useless multiple transformation. That's the issue of private led initiatives: public research propose visionary solution, implement them, give them to the public with some standard concepts. The private sector then pick and implement. Like we do now, anyone try to offload research costs to customers, push their own standards and nothing really work.
- clintonb 4y ago
- falcolas 4y agoI did the math for California awhile back, assuming a complete replacement of ICE vehicles with EVs, given the current state of the EV art. We would need 43,000 GWh/y of new electricity generation for CA alone (15m cars * .24 KWh/m * 12,000 annual miles). For reference CA has a yearly electricity generation capacity of just under 200k GWh/y, and imports another 100k GWh/y. So it's not just rapid charging load concerns, but overall generation capacity which will need to be addressed. ref. https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/california-electricity-data/electric-generation-capacity-and-energy https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/energy-almanac/califo...
- ericmay 4y agoWe are just going to have to move away from car-only infrastructure. Costs are way too high for negligible benefits. This doesn’t mean you can’t have a car or a big truck. But driving will not be your main form of transportation for daily life. The question isn’t if this will be the case, it’s whether we will manage how it occurs or how much of a shock it will be if we don’t.
- falcolas 4y agoIt's much more realistic, especially in the US with its absurdly low average population density, to switch to EVs than it is to retrofit the entire country to not rely on vehicles. I don't think the "change all of our infrastructure" option is even realistic, to be honest. We can barely maintain our existing infrastructure in too many cases, let alone rebuild it all.
- _ea1k 4y agoTBH, this article is full of weird quirks: > For instance, Marshall stated, it is not unusual for a 37.5 kilovolt-ampere transformer to support 15 households, as the distribution system was originally designed for each household to draw 2 kilowatts of power. It wasn't that long ago that 10 light bulbs would consume about half of that. So, lets assume 60 watt bulbs with 4 in the living room, 4 in the kitchen, and 4 in a bedroom all on. Now someone turns on a couple of floodlights outside. We are at ~1KW with no TVs, computers or air conditioners running. At that point, do we just hope noone turns on a hairdryer? :) Someone has messed up something fundamental in this article. Remember the early days of the internet when "experts" predicted it'd collapse as the user base grew? Much of this article reads like those.
- mikeyouse 4y agoThe grid runs on averages.. If all 15 houses connected to that transformer were drawing 1kw for lighting, and it was spec'ed to allow for 2kw each, there are 15kw available for peak loads as people blow dry their hair or run their AC. It's not saying that houses are limited to 2kw, just that the system was designed for them to average 2kw. The article gets this right and it's a completely normal part of utility design and distribution, which is unsurprising because the person quoted is a PE-licensed electrical engineer with the title "Director of Utilities".
- _ea1k 4y agoNo it doesn't, and you aren't think about it much at all if you think it does. 15kw gets real small when spread across 15 houses that each have 3kw air conditioners. It doesn't even take a hot day. The average oven can easily pull that too. Someone picked the wrong numbers. Even older homes tend to have 100A panels, in newer homes 150A and even 200A are more common. It sounds like he's presenting a real edge case but not making it clear that its an edge case.
- mikeyouse 4y agoOf course nobody is using 1kw in lighting any more, so the contrived example is already out of date. I don't know what to tell you, the utility engineer is exactly right and 37.5kv transformers serving 15 houses was a completely standard amount of power to be delivered in the past -- which is exactly his point. All of the heat pumps and electric cars are going to require massive infrastructure upgrades because many neighborhoods are still served by the old infra.
- pornel 4y agoHas our civilisation forgotten how to build things any more? Imagine if in the 20th century we stopped at "Automobiles are doomed. Who's going to build all these highways and gas stations!?" or "The lightbulb is a nice idea, but we have no power plants, an they're super expensive!"
- matthewmacleod 4y agoHas our civilisation forgotten how to build things any more? No, we frequently build things. Imagine if in the 20th century we stopped at "Automobiles are doomed. Who's going to build all these highways and gas stations!?" or "The lightbulb is a nice idea, but we have no power plants, an they're super expensive!" This happened literally all the time.
- iggldiggl 4y ago> This happened literally all the time. 1. That ↑, but also… 2. … the spread of lightbulbs or automobiles happened organically, simply because people perceived them as better than what was there beforehand and wanted them. There was no big centralised push like "We must switch from horse carts to 100 % automobiles within two years in order to avoid the big horse dung apocalypse", so the spread of those new technologies simply happened at whatever speed was feasible and sensible. If it turned out that building the required new infrastructure for lightbulbs or automobiles was a little harder than initially estimated, the buildout simply happened a little slower and that's that. Whereas now there are external goals attached to the process (must have X % electric cars by 20xx in order to avoid the apocalypse), so if it turns out that reaching that goal is harder then expected, there's immediately much hand-wringing.
- mbloom1915 4y agosadly utilities are both run inefficiently AND slow to adopt new technology. If you cut their budgets they still print money and come out profitable. Since many utilities are beholden to their shareholders, there are incentivized to NOT upgrade and sweat assets until end of life... Although critical to safety, much of the clean energy transition is in the hands of utilities to move quicker. With a 50+ year track record of not doing so I'm curious what government and/or private sector can do to remove the utilities involvement or red tape. Level 2 chargers have been easier to install but the DC Fast Chargers backed by big IRA bucks will be a tough slog. Utility transmission line drops (12 months), battery storage, installation/engineering (3 months) trenching, concrete pouring, permitting (3-6 months), union labor, DOT involvement (6 months). The day is soon approaching where we have far more EVs than charge stations ready to install.
- WallabyEV 4y agoSee, this is why the NEV class of vehicle was legislated into existence before the technology was able to capitalize on the potential. That's how I pulled disparate parts together and also solve a lot of problems relating to transition. First, smaller cars, smaller batteries. Still can have ICE vehicles for range. Smaller cars help density, 2 Wallaby EV cars are designed to fit in one US garage space (other models may be larger). Second, the UTV class will employ upgradeable solar panels for replacement as technology mandates - no OTA stuff, just a few hex screws probably and some plugs. Like modifying an RC car. Third, we can't get away from energy density problems at scale with EV even trying to supplement with solar, and I'm thinking about making EV UTVs that are off-grid self-supporting as long as the generator system (sold separately, also useful in other applications) is brought along. Fourth, the Wallaby EV system is not aiming to penetrate high-dollar households with the discretionary income to make changes of this nature - the transition clients need to save money on gas, car insurance, and then they can afford electricity and heat and maybe some school supplies. This is the real world and these folks need help and are #1 to benefit from getting away from petroleum. Cost fluctuations, being in a ghetto where the gas is a dollar more than 2 zip codes away, food desert issues, urban density...all these are the natural habitat of the Wallaby EV. Fifth, the grid in Texas recently had trouble coping with a giant storm which fortunately my hospital grid location saved me from freeze issues, and it's still an issue. Until mentally incompetent grand-sitters get out of the way, it's not even worth talking about potential fixes. This has to be grassroots, not top down. Tesla already tried top down. The build quality is embarrassing. Also on the top end a Focus ST will catch a Model S easily at anything starting over 90 mph. Smoked by a $15,000 used car. The Wallaby EV racer on the other hand will likely require a fighter pilot G-suit because of the active aero and tricks I have up my sleeve (all thanks to EV plug and play type concepts). I am so excited about the future I actually spent real money for a change to setup the structure to house the pages and pages of business plans, roles, materials, and logistics to make it work. Great USA jobs for USA employees making something start-to-finish with USA materials. My ultimate middle finger to the legacy of Steve Jobs.
- mbloom1915 4y agoVery related and timely: “Installing, wiring, and connecting the pieces of a traditional post-and-frame switchgear takes about 50 hours of on-site electrical labor,” Seitz said. “And that doesn’t take into consideration the time, costs, and difficulty of sourcing components from various manufacturers and supply houses.” Traditional switchgear is composed of electrical panels that are tasked with receiving, distributing, and protecting the site’s power. The components include a power disconnect panel, a current transformer (CT) cabinet, utility meter, distribution panels, and a transformer. “Just measuring, cutting and assembling the typical post-and-frame structure for these panels takes two days,” Seitz said. “That’s before the electrician even begins handling the electrical components.” Next steps include: Removing all dead fronts from tubs panels Mounting the panels, cabinets and enclosures Removing all the conduit knockouts Installing conduit fittings and conduit Mounting all breakers and internal equipment to bus bars Running wire through conduit Terminating all wires Making the external field wiring conduit connections source: https://www.utilitydive.com/spons/ev-charger-deployments-must-overcome-electrician-shortage/637319/ https://www.utilitydive.com/spons/ev-charger-deployments-mus...
- incomingpain 4y agoThe problem with 'grid cope' is the basic reality that environmentalists have argued for decades against nuclear. Proposing obviously renewables. But for every 1 MW of renewables you have, you must have 1 MW of not-renewables. Generally speaking this ends up being natural gas. Meanwhile, as we adopt electric cars... and practically every manufacturer is moving this direction and is far behind or is there already. Tesla, Ford, GM, VW, Hyundai/Kia all have fantastic electric cars. But its not just this. Another major consumer of power is greenhouses; also coming online and expanding now. They tend to be going very high power HPS. These lamps are so bright not even sunglasses are good enough. Your skin burns far more than any beach has ever done. So we have several new high energy consumers. We dont have any new nuclear plants built. We are shutting off coal plants. The grid cant cope because it's bipolar and dumb. Why is nobody building gridscale batteries? Why does nobody have huge hydro pumped setups?
- kkfx 4y agoLong story short: BEVs was designed with a specific target, even if no one formally state that in such crude terms: to keep a grid with significant amount of intermittent sources (like p.v. and eolic) we need something fast enough to compensate their peaks and drops, witch happen to be batteries. They are too expensive respect of their limited service life so better offload such costs to private Citizens to keep company profit. Private cars are actually batteries on wheel, cars are already not that cheap stuff, people do not use them for more than 8-10 years anyway, due to limited range they got plugged in frequently like when you stop traveling anywhere. The above paragraph was initial theory. But while people have bought a bit p.v. because it's already interesting in vast areas of the world far less interest happen for EVs and since many people even if casually do travel for longer range they need quick charging witch means a hyper big peak loads for the grid. EVs adoption was forced with laws (emission limits, travel limits in cities etc) and got pushed by soon to happen frequent blackouts, for some reasons people decide to buy them en masse recently but there is still NO SOLUTION for the grid: actual p.v./eolic volume is grown, but far less than the skyrocketed energy demand, quick charge need to be more widespread, fast (3-phase 7.3kW / 22kW) chargers need to be FAR more widespread etc so grid operators, aka private scammers are still in trouble...
- nextweek2 4y agoWhat isn’t factored in, is the money shifting. People are no longer spending money on gas, it’ll be going to the electric companies. They’ll have more revenue for investment in capacity.