28 ms·
An extensive tutorial on how to setup a Pi-Hole
- alias_neo 4y agoPi-Hole is a great starter DNS-blocker, but for anyone that isn't interested in the pretty graphs, and wants more advanced control; I switched to AdGuard Home and found it more capable.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoSo here is a real question. Is pihole ( or its equivalent ) enough in today's adversarial environment ( everyone wants to track your internet moves )? I have my thoughts on the subject, but I am curious how everyone's setup evolved.
- Brajeshwar 4y agoI'm, honestly, not so much as trying to avoid being tracked entirely. However, I have moved from Pi-Hole to NextDNS to Adguard/DNS/VPN with Apple Private Relay (ON). One day, I want to revamp and setup a better infrastructure but this works for now. I'm OK with paying for services that the family uses and get returns out of them, such as the YouTube Premium. So, I'm not fighting tooth-n-nail to avoid ads where I can just buy it out. I have seen and have even tried browsing the Internet without these basic tools (AdBlockers), and I'm stunned how the world had evolved into and how are people are on the Internet without these basic safeguards. The only problem I have is with a few government/banks/insurance website that I have to strip out and go in naked to get things done.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<< I'm not fighting tooth-n-nail to avoid ads where I can just buy it out. Agreed. As long as there is an option to avoid it, I am ok with paying for it ( Hulu adfree tier comes to mind ). << not so much as trying to avoid being tracked entirely. Agreed. That might be overkill for the benefit it provides. << I want to revamp and setup a better infrastructure I keep talking about it with my friends, but I can't find enough motivation ( and there is always an excuse not to ).
- t0bia_s 4y ago"...and I'm stunned how the world had evolved into and how are people are on the Internet without these basic safeguards." World is ruled by money. Advertising is big. Anything that ruin this business will never be advertised publicly. Just imagine huge posters or ads in TV in prime time for pi-hole or AdGuard. That would be paradox not just for advertisers but also for product that is mean to work against advertising.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoNo, but it’s a lot better than nothing. I also browse with JS disabled by default, only enabling it on the sites where I need to and am willing to.
- totalZero 4y agoNo, but it reduces the % of your bandwidth that gets used for loading ads and other junk that clutters and/or slows down your internet experience.
- squarefoot 4y agoPi-Hole does a lot but it acts against DNS queries, that is, requests done in the open through normal name resolution. If a malicious software or piece of hardware wants to pester the user with ads, or spy on them, through connections to hardcoded IPs without using DNS queries then only a properly configured firewall can be effective. At least until said malware decides to use a well known service nobody would block to phone home, for example by having a mail client buried in the code that exchanges encrypted blobs with user data and/or ads through a gmail address; who would ever block gmail? In that scenario, if that is a device that doesn't need mail functionality, for example a Smart TV rather than a PC, a dedicated firewall that blocks any non essential connection to the outside would be mandatory just for that device.
- alias_neo 4y agoPi-Hole is just one step in multiple layers when it comes to protecting yourself; I'd say it's main benefit is twofold; ad-blocking, and related benefits, and secondly script/malware blocking. If also recommend browser based blockers for desktop and mobile, uBlock Origin bring the best in my opinion and couple that with others as required. Find and use a few different upstream, privacy conscious and providers. I'm not convinced of the efficacy of paid VPNs, but by all means obtain and use one under your own control for when you're out and about on "hostile" (read; not home) networks.
- Brajeshwar 4y agoHere is the Video of the article - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cE21YjuaB6o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cE21YjuaB6o
- ignoramous 4y agohttps://ghostarchive.org/varchive/cE21YjuaB6o https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/cE21YjuaB6o (for where youtube is blocked)
- mabbo 4y agoDoes anyone know of a solution that would let me slow down access to certain websites, ideally just for certain devices? I feel like I wouldn't just default to opening HN and reddit all the time on my phone if I knew it was bandwidth capped to dial-up speeds. But if there was something critical there, I would still have access.
- hunter2_ 4y agoA traffic shaper can do that, but it would most likely be making decisions based on layer 4 (assuming it's not an SSL decrypting proxy) so it would affect any sites which have the IP addresses you specify. As long as HN and Reddit don't share edge servers with things you want unshaped, it should be straightforward. The "only for certain devices" part would probably mean putting those devices in a VLAN and only shaping that VLAN's uplink. A router like pfsense should be able to do all of that. But I am far from a network engineer, so don't quote me...
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> but it would most likely be making decisions based on layer 4 (assuming it's not an SSL decrypting proxy) so it would affect any sites which have the IP addresses you specify Not necessarily...if you're not using ESNI, then the traffic shaper could sniff the server name from the client hello message, then use the TCP sequence numbers to track the individual TCP connection.
- hunter2_ 4y agoOh nice. I knew about SNI but didn't realize there would be a perfectly persistent trail from that packet onward. If a site being shaped and a site not being shaped shared an edge server (say they both use Cloudflare or something) there's no chance that the TCP connection gets shared for both? Not disagreeing, just thinking out loud naively.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> there's no chance that the TCP connection gets shared for both Not a chance. There is a possibility that the TCP sequence numbers between the two connections overlap, but it's so unlikely as to be negligible.
- syntaxing 4y agoNextDNS has been a game changer. I highly recommend it if anyone wants something similar.
- stranded22 4y agoI agree with you. I had nextdns, moved to pihole but the maintenance was frustrating- and I couldn’t use it outside of my home network (without more work with setup). So went back to nextdns - I have set up different profiles depending on who is using it (so my wife is on a light version, no logging whereas my 9 year old son is on a lockdown down version with logging). It just makes things simpler and is very reasonably priced
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> I had nextdns, moved to pihole but the maintenance was frustrating- and I couldn’t use it outside of my home network (without more work with setup). Maintenance? What maintenance? I set up my PiHole a couple years ago and haven't touched it since. Granted, I didn't set mine up on a Pi, I set it up on my EC2 box in AWS. That way, I could have ad blocking on my phone without needing to expose my home network.
- cshokie 4y agoI made the same pihole to NextDNS transition. My pihole worked well for 3 years or so. Well enough that I allowed it to become inaccessible without moving lots of furniture. Then the SD card died. Instead of digging it out to fix it I tried NextDNS and found it works as good or better while also being less work. Well worth $20 to me.
- jorge-d 4y agoWorth mentioning that the free plan is well enough, been on it for the past 2 years on all my devices and never reached the paid quota!
- 4y ago
- lokimedes 4y agoA thing that is needed when combining RPi with Unbound, is a way to resynchronize the system time after power cuts. The standard NTP setup is driven by DNS hosts, and Unbound, at least with DNSSEC validation is time sensitive. The ballet of NORESOLVE is a nightmare. This happens easily due to the lack of a realtime clock on the Pi. A local GPS with PPS, a dirty ip-based set of NTP hosts or a shell script can solve it, but this should be part of an extensive guide, in my pained opinion :)
- totalZero 4y agoThe easiest solution for 90% of unexpected rPi power-down cases is a small uninterruptible power supply.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoAnother option is to try to find an old and super cheap laptop and use that instead. Maybe find one with a broken screen or busted keyboard or something that you won't care about. Laptops basically have a UPS built-in.
- hoherd 4y agoBetter still, do both. Power your Pi off of your laptop server to get the benefits of its built-in battery acting as a UPS for both devices.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoIf your laptop's USB ports will provide enough amps, that could work. Doesn't the Pi 3 expect up to 2.5 amps? I imagine some of that is for powering USB ports, so you could probably get away with 1.5 amps if you're not using them, but even that's a lot for laptop USB. I'd be surprised if any offered more than 1 amp.
- dylan604 4y agoThis is essentially what my MBP with butterfly keyboard has been relegated to in life. The keyboard is unusable, it's too expensive to repair, but it's not a shitty enough computer to just throw away, and there's practically no trade-in value either. So, there it sits in a closet, on a top shelf, just acting as a remote device doing random things as I assign it tasks. However, cheap is not how I would have described it ;-)
- eiiot 4y agoI’ve had AdGuard Home running on a raspberry pie for about a year, and it’s great. It’s basically a set & forget system, meaning you almost never have to visit the dashboard unless you want to whitelist or blacklist a site. And, I’ve found it to be reasonably effective for blocking ads where ad-blockers can’t, at least on iOS
- bippingchip 4y agoI can confirm. Set and forget all the way. Works very well on iOs and also on Samsung smartTV (those are evil without some form of Adblock!) Hardest part for me in the set up was that ad guard should query my router for local domain, because that one keeps track of which dhcp IP address is owned by which host. (This way I can always use host names on my internal network even for devices that get an address via dhcp. Very convenient if you play with Pi Zero and other toys)
- mattrighetti 4y agoI've used both, and I have found AdGuard Home to be slightly more reliable. These are the major things that made me switch to AGH: 1. Incredibly fast and easy to install compared to pi-hole 2. It's easier to update because you don't have to ssh into the raspberry, you can just update the thing through the user interface. 3. From time to time, it happened that the pi-hole hanged up, dns resolution did not work and I needed to reboot the thing to make it work again. I am not sure how widespread this is but I've seen many other users complain about this particular issue (even though it's a once-per-month thing). (4. Better APIs) For an in-depth comparison between the two you can take a look at the AGH GitHub Page[0] [0]: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome#comparison-pi-hole https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome#comparison-pi-hol...
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI can't figure out from their site if it is free or do you need a registration key for it to be able to access their white/black lists?
- anthropodie 4y agoAdGuardHome is free but AdGuard is not. What you are looking for is https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome
- COGlory 4y agoDoes anyone know how to get their hands on a Pi at the moment? Even Pi 3s are going for $100+ on eBay. rpilocator shows everything always out of stock.
- ghastmaster 4y agoI do not know about a Pi, but you can run Pi-hole on old(cheap) hardware with linux. You do not need a Raspberry Pi. I have Ubuntu Server running it. It is quite simple(two commands?) and there are plenty of tutorials out there. Odroid is a good alternative to Pi that can run Pi-hole.
- jrmg 4y agoBe aware that that will consume substantially more power than a pi. Even my old MacBook seems to consume about 6W idle with the screen off compared to 1W for my cubieboard (~pi 1 equivalent). A PC is probably closer to 10-30W.
- ikinsey 4y agoThe Libre Computer is a reasonable alternative if you're okay with other brands. https://libre.computer/ https://libre.computer/
- neurostimulant 4y agoSecondhand thin clients are pretty cheap. Something like hp t620 is ~$50 and uses <10W of power. Runs pi-hole just fine.
- mngnt 4y agoI have been running pihole for quite some time (coupled with wireguard, that's a great way to stay ad-free on the go as well), but a question is nagging at my brain the whole time: What's stopping the bad guys from circumventing DNS entirely by calling their ad/data collection/malware C&C by IP rather than FQDN? Provided it's a public IP, that should slip through all the DNS based filtering, wouldn't it?
- Spivak 4y ago- Getting certs for ips is possible but not turnkey. - Not that many people run Piholes so the return on investment isn't good. - More complicated integrations with webmasters. [a secret 4th thing] - I think the people who build these systems want to have this escape hatch for themselves.
- irrational 4y agoI’ve wondered about the fourth thing. I imagine it is the marketing/sales/business people who love ads, while the techies don’t particularly like ads, so the techies, who probably are aware of ad blockers and pi hole and the such, avoid telling their business overlords about them.
- hunter2_ 4y agoWe certainly wouldn't want them to know that if they just replace their main app web server ("www" for example) with a reverse proxy such that some paths ("/ads/" for example) are proxied to the ad server while all other paths are proxied to the app server, ads would make it through to users with no way to use DNS nor IP filtering, leaving only browser extensions! Oops, did I spill the beans?
- Spivak 4y agoYou don't have to resort to just browser extensions but you do have to MTIM yourself. Also browser extensions are far and away the most popular ad blocking method so if it doesn't block them there's no reason to bother.
- jollyllama 4y agoWhat's the easiest way to do this while using the Pi to route all of my outbound traffic to a VPN provider? Something like OpenWRT on a Pi https://github.com/wulfy23/rpi4 https://github.com/wulfy23/rpi4 ?
- alar44 4y agoThat's not easy in any sense of the word. You'd need to provide a network diagram at minimum to even try to answer that.
- jollyllama 4y agoWAN <-> VPN Provider <-> WAN <-> Cable modem <-> Pi-Hole/VPN <-> Home router <-> PC's, phone, etc added VPN provider
- alar44 4y agoSo you'll need to set up a VPN service on your Pi, then set up iptables for allowing traffic to flow through the Pi, and use DHCP to set the Pi as your gateway. You'll also need to point the Pi to your home router as a gateway. Note that your overall throughput will be limited to the NIC on your Pi. The specifics here depend on your VPN vendor.
- haunter 4y agoAre there any solutions that still works with Youtube ads? Pi-Hole doesn't work for some time (and most likely won't ever again)
- tempest_ 4y agoUblock on a PC and whatever replaced Vanced (ReVanced?) on android. Have not figured out the smart tv yet.
- haunter 4y agoOn my Android TV SmarTubeNext works perfectly, 0 ads https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext
- skyyler 4y agoHaunter mentioned SmartTubeNext, but if you use an Apple TV, there's yattee: https://github.com/yattee/yattee https://github.com/yattee/yattee
- mattrighetti 4y agouBlock Origin is the only thing that works for me, on Firefox. You can't block YouTube ads with DNS level tricks because YT serves videos and ads from the very same domain.
- bityard 4y agoAnd sponsorblock to skip ads for VPNs, mattresses, and razor blades.
- kingsloi 4y agoI used a Pi-Hole for all devices in my house, including my work MacBook. They manage their MacBooks with JamF, so most things are pretty locked down (including DNS settings in System Preferences). Sudo access is only possible if you open up the Self Service app, login, and issue yourself sudo/admin access for 6 hours. Once it expires, you have to issue yourself admin/sudo access again. No sudo = no changing DNS. I set it and forgot it, until I went to Estes Park, Colorado over the Christmas holidays one year. I travelled with my MacBook just in case anything popped off... and it did. I logged into my MacBook, but quickly realised although I could connect to WiFi as normal, no DNS would resolve (it was pointed to 192.168.1.100 of my home network), and I couldn't connect to anything - including logging in the Self Service app to re-issue sudo access, to change the DNS. I had to walk a new colleague how to handle the scandal over the phone, driving through the mountains... thank goodness for good cell service!
- feet 4y agoYou could set up a VPN for cases like that. Just VPN into your home network to have all your usual services and dns
- yabones 4y agoWouldn't help here, since most people have to use DDNS to connect back home since residential IPs change constantly. And with no DNS resolver, no DDNS lookup, no phone home. Best way to handle it is to just reconfigure your router to hand out the pihole dns server to all the clients on your network. That way it's automatic when at home, and doesn't override anything when you're away.
- HelenePhisher 4y agoYou could just use Tailscale.
- robby_w_g 4y agoI think tailscale could handle this problem pretty well: https://tailscale.com/kb/1114/pi-hole/ https://tailscale.com/kb/1114/pi-hole/ You can configure the default DNS for devices when they connect to tailscale. This way, pi hole is opt in for users who want to set up tailscale. Disclaimer: I haven't tried this myself since I have Mullvad ad blocking setup and I'm lazy
- tkuraku 4y agoI think the best way to set pihole up is to use the docker image, https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole/ https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole/. run it on a pi or any other computer with docker. Upgrades are painless.
- uzername 4y agoI went with the pihole in docker approach with a Ubuntu 22.04 machine. Pretty smooth, I had a few quirks with docker desktop for linux that might not show up otherwise. Definitely my recommendation too.
- hoherd 4y agoI firmly agree, but would make an even more specific recommendation to use the docker-compose setup so that redeploying the same customizations is easy. I do this on two different hosts so I have redundant DNS, and it's been working great for several years. https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole/blob/62ca934d07/examples/docker-compose.yml.example https://github.com/pi-hole/docker-pi-hole/blob/62ca934d07/ex...
- m0sa 4y agoI have my Pis in a swarm and use `docker stack deploy` to deploy my Pi-Hole setup (with cloudflared for DoH etc) remotely from my desktop PC.
- jedisct1 4y agoI just use dnscrypt-proxy. A GUI is not really useful IMHO. And at scale, dnscrypt-proxy's logs can go to ES/Kibana if really needed.
- herodotus 4y agoI have been using my Raspberry Pi-Hole for more than 3 years now without much difficulty. But when I installed replaced my old wifi routers with Linksys Velops, my Pi-hole log is flooded with .in-addr.arpa queries from the routers. Does anyone know if there is a way to remove these from the log? What would happen if I blocked them?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sgc 4y agoHas anybody installed and configured a Squid proxy on a pihole, or using it alone on a pi? Is it relatively easy to do? I would rather have the more fine-grained control a Squid proxy allows, but I have no experience with it.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoI use a localhost-bound forward proxy, but it is not squid. I can run the proxy on any computer, whether it is a laptop, a router, an RPi or a non-rooted "smartphone" running Android.1 Optionally, I can bind the proxy to an RFC1918 address then use the computer running the proxy as a gateway for other computers on the local network. This is not for everyone (e.g., I use a text-only browser reading sites submitted to HN) but if one knows what sites she needs to access ahead of time (e.g., all sites submitted to HN), then she can avoid using remote DNS entirely.2 All remote DNS data is fetched in bulk, e.g. using DoH and HTTP/1.1 pipelining, and then loaded into the proxy's memory. 1. By using NetGuard and port forwarding DNS. 2. One can then enjoy reading about myriad security issues that rely on remote DNS, such as the recent DNS rebinding-dependent exploit against Tailscale.
- codepoet80 4y agoI use both Squid (to bump SSL for old devices) and PiHole on a 3b!
- sgc 4y agoDo you use Squid content-based filtering? It is pretty resource intensive for some uses AFAIK.
- ikinsey 4y agoI definitely recommend checking out Steven Black's unified hosts file [0] for DNS-level adblocking outside of one's local network. It's the default block list in Pi-Hole. [0] https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts
- euroderf 4y agoInstalls smoothly on mac.
- jypepin 4y agoThat's good timing, because with the increase in the price for youtube premium, I started thinking that I wanted an alternative to watching youtube on my TVs without ads. Does anyone know if using a pi-hole triggers ad-blockers popups on websites, and if yes, is it easy to deal with (either activate ads for specific websites, etc)?
- notadev 4y agoI set up Pi-Hole in Docker (along with Unbound) to provide recursive DNS. Then changed my router’s DNS settings to point to 192.168.1.2 which is the Pi-Hole. Works perfectly and blocks thousands of requests from the kid’s devices as well as our TVs and smart devices.
- JadoJodo 4y agoI managed a Pi-Hole in my house for about 4-years, and then I found NextDNS. I'm not a person who shies away from doing things the complicated way (because it's fun or makes life better), but paying only $19/yr to have everything managed automatically for me was a no-brainer. Not having to worry about my mobile devices using it, too, was icing on the cake.
- 404mm 4y agoThanks for this!! Do they have any “tools” to temporarily allow some blocked content from a device? Or does one have to go to web and adjust the profile?
- JadoJodo 4y agoIt doesn't have the "pause" button, like pi-hole has. But I just check the logs and see why it was blocked, and then whitelist (if needed).
- groovybits 4y agoThis is false. My NextDNS clients on macOS, iOS, and iPadOS devices all feature a Disable toggle that stops all blocking and allows un-blocked DNS resolution. I don't use Windows at home, but I imagine there is a similar toggle.
- 404mm 4y agoLooks like there is a way to “pause” NextDNS. To have this ability, you have to set it up via their App and not the (recommended) configuration profile. Then you will gain a simple app with Enable/Disable toggle.
- MattSayar 4y agoNextDNS is essentially Pi-Hole as a Service, and I'm really happy with it since I just switched from my Pi-Hole days ago. One of Pi-Hole's biggest limitations is that it only worked on my local network, but NextDNS works anywhere you can specify your DNS settings. Additionally, my Pi-Hole would frequently (at least once a month) require reboots and troubleshooting. That's the last thing I want to do (with family (im)patiently waiting) after working all day.
- nimbius 4y agoa raspberry pi is currently selling for north of $200 due to its scarcity. The smartest thing I did was buy a $60 used chromebook, convert it into an LXD "server" and run pi-hole there. better performance. I sold my five pi's on Ebay months ago for around a grand.
- anthropodie 4y agoNo one mentioned AdGuardHome yet? AdGuardHome is far better than PiHole. It's a single Go binary and I think UI is better. It won't break if you upgrade your system. You don't need docker or LAMP stack. Just pull binary and run it. It will even generate systemd service file for you if you need. Edit: https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y ago> You don't need docker or LAMP stack. Just pull binary and run it. It's almost like there's a lot of needless overhead in modern software or something.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoAgreed, I recently migrated from pihole to adguard and the reliability and general ease of use has been much better
- pandemic_region 4y agoAgreed, the fact that it's a single binary made me switch from pi-hole. I don't need to run an extra device now, AdGuard runs directly on my edgerouter-x.
- aimor 4y agoThanks for the recommendation. I love my pihole, except for the once or twice a year it manages to break itself and lock up my headless pi.
- anthropodie 4y agoThis is exactly the reason why I was looking for an alternative and found AGH.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThey ship a distroless container image too. Fast and easy and just works. I switched after getting tired of babysitting PiHole.
- efields 4y agoA million years ago (2019 or so) I bought a Pi on eBay preloaded with PiHole. It's worked well ever since.
- fletchowns 4y agoSeems sketchy - how do you know it's a legit copy of PiHole on there?
- nirvgorilla 4y agoI tried to archive this site with archive.today and it says "country blocked." Can you ask this piece of garbage, for-profit guide maker to not block countries from accessing his supposed "guides?" I bet this scumbag did that intentionally. https://archive.ph/ds3eV https://archive.ph/ds3eV
- yegor 4y agoShameless self plug: Using Control D for your DNS is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be... unnatural. It does everything NextDNS, Adguard can do, and a whole bunch more (block is not the only action).
- navels 4y agopro-tip: when your home internet goes down, check first that your Pi hasn't crashed :-)
- dotBen 4y agoTip: don't run Pi-Hole or any of these containers on a Pi, they're underpowered, flakey and now hard to get. I run several docker containers, including Pi-Hole, on a Lenovo ThinkCenter thin client which I run headless next to my router. Purchased "used" for $120 from eBay it was actually overstock and brand new. Tons more processing power and RAM than a Pi, SSD and for basically same price all in as a Pi. Just wipe the old version of Windows and install your favorite *nix flavor. Every time I need another containerized app to run I'm up and running in just a few minutes with plenty of headroom left on the small box. See: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/11/used-thin-client-pcs-are-an-unsexy-readily-available-raspberry-pi-alternative/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/11/used-thin-client-pcs...
- slickdork 4y agoDo you worry about the battery being a fire hazard? But I do agree: run pi-hole as vm/dockers on some home server.
- zrail 4y agoWhat battery?
- slickdork 4y agooh woops, i read thinkpad instead of thinclient and thought it was a laptop.
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- shasts 4y agoI was concerned with the power draw. But as per the article, it looks like the difference is negligible. I assumed being ARM, pi was supposed to draw lower power. Looks like not the case. Found another study confirming the same. https://uni.hi.is/helmut/2021/06/07/power-consumption-of-raspberry-pi-4-versus-intel-j4105-system/ https://uni.hi.is/helmut/2021/06/07/power-consumption-of-ras...
- antman 4y agoAny idea for something rpi that filters traffic on https content for children? Perhaps add a browser certificate and a configurable proxy?
- aceazzameen 4y agoBeen running a pi-hole for a few years now and have no complaints. It's the DNS server for my router, so everything on my network uses it. It's behind on updates though. I still need to enable SSH on my pi just so I can update the pi-hole (I believe it can only be done via SSH?). Been too lazy to bother hooking up a mouse/kb to the device again. I'll take this as a reminder that I should get on that.
- Eleison23 4y agoI used a PiHole on an actual Pi and I actually bragged about it during a job interview. However it was difficult to admin and difficult to tweak to my liking. I've moved to NextDNS and I'm impressed by the featureful features it features. I also enjoy the seamless transitions from my home network to anywhere else while keeping NextDNS resolving correctly. The only feature I wish it had was an off switch. It is not easy to get its hooks out of each device and I cannot find a way to make it act like a classic resolver... except when I exceed the monthly free account quota, and then it cuts off its special features until next month. No hate for the PiHole here; it served me well and it really gives lots of kids a nice project and it's totally turnkey protection. Mad props to the PiHole guys and gals for proving this is viable and this is a good thing for privacy and safety.
- synergy20 4y agoFor those use openwrt routers, its adblock worked well for me.
- Minor49er 4y agoWhat timing. I just set up a Pi-Hole last weekend. One of the things I've been wanting to use it for is ad blocking on my Chromecast, but the Chromecast routes around it. I think I need to set it up as a DHCP server. I currently have my router set to use the Pi-Hole as the DNS server and have blocked port 53 for everything else
- yumraj 4y agoMarginally off topic: I’ve been using pihole for a really long time, but lately have run into an issue around blocking YouTube. I have wildcard blacklisted YouTube.com and www.YouTube.com, but it doesn’t work. It’s not just me, I found a thread online of others discussing this. I’m using Firefox, so it’s not Chrome bypassing DNS check. Does anyone know what the hell is going on?
- nigma 4y agoJust guessing, but there may be other devices providing DNS service on your network. For example I have found that AppleTV is listening for DNS queries on a couple ports and MacOS will happily fallback to that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t0bia_s 4y agohttps://freetubeapp.io/ https://freetubeapp.io/
- t0bia_s 4y ago"If you don’t have a second Pi-hole, you can also populate DNS 2 with a public DNS server such as Cloudflare (1.1.1.1)." This make pi-hole useless. I would prefer to let DNS2 empty. Also pihole won't catch DoH queries, that could be set in browsers or other apps.
- idatum 4y agoI use both Pi-Hole on an RPI3 on a VLAN locked down for IoT devices, and OpenBSD + unbound(8) on my default network. Both options are great, and OpenBSD/unbound has been running just as easily. Here is a recent HN thread on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33122419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33122419
- yydcool 4y agoIs this just a cat-and-mouse game? DNS is not a good way to identify ads.