3 ms·
Eh? No, that's not a reasonable comparison at all. A closer one might be that a food critic does not bake bread, they just observe and moan about it (though eve
by rsynnott 4y ago
Eh? No, that's not a reasonable comparison at all. A closer one might be that a food critic does not bake bread, they just observe and moan about it (though even that is probably not a great comparison, because food critics probably can, to at least some extent, ultimately influence the food...)
To be clear, the job of a dictionary is to look at which words are being created, which words are becoming obsolete, how the usage of words is changing, and document all that. Nobody (or at least virtually nobody) opens up the new edition of the dictionary and looks for new words to work into conversation; the feedback from dictionaries back into actual English is minimal to null.
Incidentally, the reason that the food critic is more influential on the bread than the lexicographer on the language is that people, in quite large numbers, read restaurant reviews as entertainment, but not dictionary entries.