4 ms·
It probably varies by state (or not), but the last time I was on a jury, the jury selection process went like this: 1. 12 jurors are seated. 2. the prosecutio
by mindcrime 15y ago
It probably varies by state (or not), but the last time I was on a jury, the jury selection process went like this:
1. 12 jurors are seated.
2. the prosecution asks questions of the jurors, either as a group (eg, "raise your hand if X") or individually.
3. the defense does the same thing
4. the prosecution can excuse any jurors they think are not suited for the case
5. the defense can do likewise
6. If less than 12 jurors remain, enough new ones are seated to bring the number back to 12, and the process repeats
And the questions the prosecution asks are often framed like "Is there any reason you would fundamentally be unable to return a 'guilty' verdict in this case?" or "is X a reason you would not be able to return a 'guilty' verdict?" etc.
At which point, an honest person who believes jury nullification would apply here, would have to say "Yes, I would refuse to vote guilty in this case because I think the law is wrong" or whatever. Of course if you do that, you're basically asking to be excused.
In my case, they never used the phrase "jury nullification" in the selection process, but they asked questions that roughly corresponded to asking about that.
Also, I'm not sure if there is a limit to how many jurors each side can excuse. In the case where I served, quite a few jurors were excused by one side or the other, but we didn't come close to exhausting the pool of candidates (which was, I believe, somewhere between 50-60 people).
- colanderman 15y agoThanks. I've never been on a jury so I'm totally unaware of the selection process. It seems less unfair that both sides get to excuse jurors; still, on average, it seems it would drastically skew the pool of jurors away from a random sample of the general populace.
- msbarnett 15y ago> still, on average, it seems it would drastically skew the pool of jurors away from a random sample of the general populace. A jury pool has never been meant to represent a random sample of the general populace. Indeed that would be enormously counterproductive: in, say, a Klan dominated county we might expect a random sample of the county populace to turn up 9 racists in a sample of 12, but that is not a jury makeup likely to result in a fair verdict for a black defendant. All of these questioning and dismissal mechanisms exist to make sure that the jury pool is absolutely NOT 12 random people, but is instead as close to a collection of 12 people who are believed to be able to return an impartial verdict as can be reasonably managed in the opinion of the court, by balancing the concerns of both prosecution and defence council.
- andrewla 15y agoI was called up for jury selection in Manhattan, and this was my experience. They asked if anyone had a problem with the law in question (it was a drug case) and then asked if I would be able to return a guilty verdict. I was not paneled on the jury. In my case, a large number (>100) jurors were dismissed for what did not appear to be any reason, so it may have been something else I said or something I wrote on the questionnaire they gave us. I was also surprised by the number of dismissed jurors, since I was led to believe (mostly, I think, by Law & Order) that there was a limit on the peremptory dismissals. On the elevator on the way out, other dismissed jurors congratulated my on a novel way to avoid jury duty. This annoyed me, since I would have really liked to have been on that jury. Although I agree with the article that juries should have more powerful, I don't see how a believer in nullification can get on a jury without lying.
- rdtsc 15y agoHowever they can't stop you from changing your mind. If they didn't ask if you "won't have a problem when it comes to deliberations" you can reasonably start disagreeing with the law the more you understand how this law is applied to real people in real cases.
- mindcrime 15y agoAlthough I agree with the article that juries should have more powerful, I don't see how a believer in nullification can get on a jury without lying. Yeah, I had more or less the same thought. In my own case, I do believe in Jury Nullification; it just happened that the case was a property crime case (breaking and entering, larceny) which is one of the areas where the law seems reasonably just. So I didn't speak up or anything, and ultimately did serve on the jury.
- JoshTriplett 15y ago> I don't see how a believer in nullification can get on a jury without lying. If you're going into a case knowing you'll say "guilty" or "not guilty" without actually hearing the facts of the case, you should get kicked off the jury, independent of your belief in jury nullification. If you plan to decide based on both the law and the facts of the case, you should listen very carefully to the questions asked, to ensure that your boolean answers remain truthful. Question: "Do you have a problem with the law in question?" Unspoken answer: "Depends on the facts of the case." Boolean answer: "No." Question: "Would you be able to return a guilty verdict?" Unspoken answer: "Yes, I have the ability to do so, and in general a belief in jury nullification means I want to decide based on the facts of the case as well as the law, which the constitution of my state specifically gives juries the power to do." Boolean answer: "Yes."
- pnathan 15y agoI stood for a juror in county court a few years back. This was pretty much the process followed. It was very focused on being impartial and following the law. I think different courts and jury stylings have different rules, but I am unsure where and how.
- rbanffy 15y agoGood lawyers will excuse jurors based on how they will likely relate to the case being presented. For instance, here in Brazil, most defense lawyers will excuse jurors of Japanese origin based on the idea they would impose tougher moral standards than other groups. Lawyers are obliged to always offer the best possible defense to the extent of their abilities, and that includes selecting a biased jury if that's possible.
- elecengin 15y agoThis is called voire dire: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_selection#Voir_dire http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_selection#Voir_dire The plaintiff / defense teams are allowed to remove an limited number of jurors unless the removal is among a list of valid exempt causes (in which case the removal is exempt from the limit). See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peremptory_challenge http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peremptory_challenge The process can become very very thought out in high profile cases - there are psychologists hired to advise litigators on how favorable a potential jury member might be, and the list of potential jurors for a given day can be retrieved ahead of time and background checks run each one (all within the rules). Here is an intresting article from one of these "Jury experts" discussing the process: http://www.americanbar.org/publications/youraba/201103article01.html http://www.americanbar.org/publications/youraba/201103articl...
- ams6110 15y agoI would say that with the rise of facebook and other social media, it's easier than ever before for both the prosecution and the defense to be able to develop a very good profile of the potential jurors. And if one side or the other does not have the resources or expertise to do so, they could be at a serious disadvantage before the trial even starts.
- SomeCallMeTim 15y agoI was selected on a jury once, but only just barely. It was a drug-related case, and the defense attorney challenged the prosecution, who had made a peremptory challenge to remove me from the jury. His argument was that I was the only one even close to the age of the defendant left on the jury, and that by removing me he would be removing all of the defendant's "peers." (He was young; I was young.) The prosecutor withdrew his challenge, and I stayed. Funny thing was, I was pretty anti-drug at the time, so it could have backfired. But I ended up being the jury foreman and we acquitted without much debate after someone decided to ask if anyone in the room actually thought he was guilty. They didn't really have anything on the kid; the trial was a total waste of taxpayer's money. But you have an excellent point: If anyone writes online about supporting jury nullification, odds are good they'll get a challenge-for-cause any time they're in jury selection. At least if they're easily traced by name to those comments.
- powertower 15y ago> And the questions the prosecution asks are often framed like "Is there any reason you would fundamentally be unable to return a 'guilty' verdict in this case?" or "is X a reason you would not be able to return a 'guilty' verdict?" etc. In my case it was a civil trial and he (the plaintiff's attorney) asked everyone to raise their hands if they thought they could follow the instructions of the court. I kept my hand down. He told me to raise my hand. I told him I had some opinions on jury nullification. He looked at the judge. The judge didn't say anything. He then asked me what my opinions were. I said what I thought the definition was for "jury nullification", and that ultimately I have no problems disregarding the instructions of the court. I was then, most immediately, dismissed from jury duty. The first person out of that room. It was very nerve wrecking having to do that (being in the court room for the first time, and all that). But worth it. *The case was something about the "fair value" of someone's property that was taken by the state (and DOT) due to road construction ("eminent domain" maybe).
- JoshTriplett 15y ago> It was very nerve wrecking having to do that (being in the court room for the first time, and all that). But worth it. You got to make a point to a small room full of people. You didn't, however, get to have any effect on the verdict, so ultimately your opinions on jury nullification had no effect except to get you kicked off a jury. Unless you wanted to get kicked off the jury, that doesn't seem worth it to me.
- zbuc 15y agoYeah, you should keep off the soapbox until after the case has run its course. If you think that using jury nullification is a possibility for you, keep your mouth shut and just do it otherwise you'll be excused.