3 ms·
Dictionaries do not redefine words; they describe how words are used (at least in English; there are a couple of languages where someone seriously attempts top-
by rsynnott 4y ago
Dictionaries do not redefine words; they describe how words are used (at least in English; there are a couple of languages where someone seriously attempts top-down control, but English isn’t one of them).
- theodric 4y agoBakers do not bake bread, they merely construct a gel from precursor ingredients. The oven bakes the bread.
- hnbad 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_prescription https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_prescription https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_description https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_description Dictionaries do the latter. No need to come up with snarky analogies.
- theodric 4y agoThanks for the Wikipedia links. I have a degree that included a great amount of study of (socio-)linguistics and am well acquainted with the distinction. Describing something in such a way that it furthers an agenda is not objective, nor is it good sociolinguistics, but that's what the dictionary in question has been accused of doing.
- hnbad 4y agoMaybe you should revisit your linguistics course notes then. The purpose of a dictionary is to represent language use. In fact, the definition of "woman" is largely unchanged: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33785834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33785834 If your agenda tracks with how language use changes in wide swaths of the population, sure, a dictionary "furthers the agenda" but it does so by accurately reflecting language use, not what you want language use to be. I could argue that the second definition of "Darwinism"[1] furthers an agenda, but that's inane. This is how the word is used and it's the concept I take offense with, not the word itself. The dictionary just represents the reality of that being how the word is used. It sounds like you oppose the notion that "gender" or "gender identity" is, to put it simply, a thing. And you ascribe "an agenda" to those who agree that it is a thing while implying that not acknowledging that many people explicitly or implicitly (i.e. by behaving as if it is a thing without outright saying so, e.g. by respecting preferred pronouns or continuing to refer to someone as a woman or man after finding out they're trans and thus likely don't fit the reproductive definition of those words) agree that it is a thing is absent of an agenda. Actually I'm sure that's not what you're trying to argue because that is clearly ridiculous. Since you explicitly reference an "agenda", I would like you to spell out to me what you think that agenda is and whose it is. Because if you simply meant "bias", it should be obvious that an unbiased dictionary is impossible because it by definition has to represent social biases as there is no objective source of truth when it comes to descriptive linguistics. [1]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Darwinism https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/Darwinism
- rsynnott 4y agoEh? No, that's not a reasonable comparison at all. A closer one might be that a food critic does not bake bread, they just observe and moan about it (though even that is probably not a great comparison, because food critics probably can, to at least some extent, ultimately influence the food...) To be clear, the job of a dictionary is to look at which words are being created, which words are becoming obsolete, how the usage of words is changing, and document all that. Nobody (or at least virtually nobody) opens up the new edition of the dictionary and looks for new words to work into conversation; the feedback from dictionaries back into actual English is minimal to null. Incidentally, the reason that the food critic is more influential on the bread than the lexicographer on the language is that people, in quite large numbers, read restaurant reviews as entertainment, but not dictionary entries.
- vintermann 4y agoMaybe you mean, dictionaries aren't supposed to redefine words. Officially, everyone working on a dictionary is a good honest little descriptivist. But it's not like you can replace a lexicographer with a transparent mathematical algorithm. There's plenty of room for judgement calls, and very little room for correction, since dictionaries have a self-reinforcing effect. People certainly use dictionaries prescriptively, so there's always some (petty) power at stake in getting to say what the right meaning is.
- vintermann 4y agoIt occurs to me, that even though gaslighting is certainly too strong a word, there ought to be a word for this: making a statement of the definition of how it should work, and using it as proof that's self-evidently how it actually works. I feel like I see it a lot. Some typical phrases used as evidence for the ideal they represent: "Representatives protect the interests of their constituents". "Judges base their decisions on facts and the rule of law". "Newspapers cover those topics which are deemed to be interesting to their readers". "A balanced portfolio invests in diverse stocks and bonds to reduce volatility".
- mgdlbp 4y agoTautological statement is tautological.
- kortilla 4y agoIf dictionaries just “described how words are used”, they would be filled with thousands of definitions for every word. They implicitly define them by choosing which definitions are to be trusted and which are “wrong”.
- rsynnott 4y agoThey pick which are most _commonly used_, in general. There is a reasonable argument that many of them are still a bit too stuck in a world where "it has to fit in a book" was a major concern, and are thus too aggressive in discarding rarely used definitions.
- s9w 4y ago