3 ms·
I've never really understood how SOPA will deal with websites that are indisputably multi-use. I don't think anyone could, with a straight face, argue that Scr
by ghshephard 15y ago
I've never really understood how SOPA will deal with websites that are indisputably multi-use. I don't think anyone could, with a straight face, argue that Scribd doesn't have a significant amount of non-copyright infringing use (unlike Napster, which was close to 99%+ copyright infringing by volume) - thought it does have a significant component of copyright infringements that rights holders are always having to stamp out with DMCA takedown requests.
So - what to do with sites like Scribd, post SOPA? Just blacklist the entire site because it gets a lot of DMCA requests?
What do the SOPA proponents (do we have _ANY_ of those on HN, I really would love to be educated by them) have to say about that?
- rhizome 15y agoI've never really understood how SOPA will deal with websites that are indisputably multi-use There is no such thing to a smaller mind, such as a Congressperson's. The people who argue and vote for these laws are not big computery people, they are lawyers, and exceedingly lazy ones at that. The subtlety you describe, that some websites can be multi-use, is lost on people who can't understand how Reddit in not just a den of kiddie porn after hearing the stories over the summer.
- tedunangst 15y agoI think we have arrived here, in some part, because of how much some sites relied on safe harbor provisions. They were added to protect a host which had a tiny bit of inadvertent infringing material. But people have been (ab)using that as a free pass to deliberately host copyrighted things until they get caught. If everybody claims to be indisputably multi-use, the net effect is that no one is. Since the DMCA appears to have failed (in the eyes of copyright holders), and since that failure appears in large part to be due what they consider a loophole, don't be surprised if the next round of legislation is not going to include the loophole. If you don't want the government regulating your business, a little preemptive self regulation often goes a long way.
- zoom 15y agoI'm for SOPA only because I hate DNS.